MAKATI CITY (MindaNews / December 16) – Each few years, somebody declares—typically with alarm—that “the values of the youth are gone.”
As if morality had been a wood ship docked someplace previously, now stripped plank by plank by modernity, social media, and an excessive amount of Wi-Fi. To not point out Chat-GPT.
I hear this cry in school rooms and from pulpits, at household reunions and—loudest of all—on Fb. And after I hear that, it makes me consider an outdated philosophical puzzle: the Ship of Theseus.
The query is straightforward sufficient. If a ship’s components are changed steadily, one plank at the moment, one other mast tomorrow, till not one of the unique stays, is there one thing new that may nonetheless be referred to as the identical ship?
The Greeks discovered this troubling.
We mortals within the Philippines appear to search out it troubling, too.
After we say the youth are “not the identical,” what we actually imply is that this: Their language has modified. Their heroes are completely different. Their struggles are unfamiliar.
And so, we ask—generally anxiously, generally angrily: Are they nonetheless us? That is Ship-of-Theseus considering utilized to ethical schooling. We assume: there’s a fastened ethical core, values are like removable components, and alter, if unchecked, means loss.
That’s the reason ethical schooling typically turns into defensive—extra about defending values than forming individuals. We educate as if morality had been a museum artifact: Don’t contact. Don’t revise. Don’t query.
However lived morality has by no means labored that means. Not in historical past. Not in religion. Not in actual Filipino lives.
I’d prefer to make a short detour—removed from Athens, and certainly Manila—to Seventeenth-century Iran. And there, a thinker by the identify of Mullā Ṣadrā urged one thing fairly radical: Substance is itself in movement.
Not simply colours, not simply habits, not simply exterior habits—however being itself is all the time turning into. He referred to as it ḥarakat-e jawhariyya: substantial movement. In easy phrases: Issues do not stay the identical regardless of change. They continue to be themselves by way of change.
From this angle, the Ship of Theseus isn’t any paradox in any respect. The ship is one steady journey of turning into. Its id lies not in frozen components, however in directed motion. After which, virtually quietly, the ethical panic begins to fade.
Seen on this mild, ethical schooling within the Philippines will not be about ensuring that college students are the identical as their grandparents.
It’s about guiding who they’re turning into.
Our personal languages say this clearly: pagpapakatao—turning into absolutely human; paghubog ng pagkatao—shaping character; paglilinang—cultivation, not storage. Even in Islamic ethical schooling, the soul isn’t static. The nafs strikes—from impulse (nafs al-ammārah), to conscience (nafs al-lawwāmah), to serenity (nafs al-muṭma’innah). In Catholic formation, conversion (metanoia) is lifelong. In indigenous knowledge, an individual matures by way of expertise, not insulation.
Why, then, will we educate morals as if progress had been betrayal?
It’s maybe no coincidence that this nervousness is now discovering expression in coverage. Beneath the reform proposals related to the Second Congressional Fee on Training (EdCom II), there’s a transfer to realign the overall schooling curriculum by eradicating Ethics as a stand-alone topic on the tertiary degree and relocating it to Senior Excessive College, on the idea that moral formation might be sufficiently addressed earlier and thereafter “mainstreamed” throughout school disciplines.
The proposal, at first blush, sounds sensible, perhaps even environment friendly. If, as its champions contend, ethics has been taught in Okay-12—and if issues of the “ethical lifeworld” are purportedly woven by way of all the pieces—why ought to we make room for any of it in school anymore (now or ever) as a separate house of inquiry?
However learn by way of the lens of the Ship of Theseus, the advice quietly reveals its personal paradox. In treating ethics as a removable plank—one thing that may be shifted downward, redistributed, or absorbed with out loss—it assumes that ethical formation will by some means stay intact even when its most reflective stage is faraway from the very degree the place college students start to train skilled, civic, and political company.
That is the place diffusion is mistaken for formation. Ethics in Senior Excessive College introduces values; ethics in school interrogates them. With no devoted house for sustained ethical reflection on the tertiary degree, college students are educated to grasp strategies quicker than they’re taught to ask why these strategies must be used—or for whom. Moral questions then survive solely as footnotes, if in any respect, to technical competence.
Satirically, this curricular transfer appears pushed by the identical unease it seeks to resolve. It presumes that ethical reasoning both matures by itself or has already been accomplished by the point college students enter greater schooling. However turning into moral will not be automated, neither is it completed at eighteen.
Movement with out path will not be formation; it’s drift.
If ethical schooling is really about guiding who college students have gotten, then eradicating structured moral inquiry exactly on the stage when younger adults confront energy, occupation, and public accountability will not be a impartial act of streamlining. It’s a alternative—one with ethical penalties of its personal.
The coed who questions authority will not be morally misplaced. The younger voter who refuses outdated political loyalties will not be value-less. The kid negotiating religion in a digital world will not be abandoning morality. They’re in movement. The actual query will not be: “Are they nonetheless the identical?” However: Towards what are we serving to them transfer?
That’s the educator’s activity—to not freeze id, however to present path.
Maybe this nervousness cuts deeper as a result of the Philippines itself is a Ship of Theseus. Colonial names changed. Constitutions rewritten. Areas reimagined. Identities pluralized. Mindanao is aware of this higher than most. We’re consistently assured that change endangers our id. However historical past doesn’t bear this out: Identification lives on when it’s oriented, not when it’s frozen.
As Mullā Ṣadrā would say—although he by no means set foot right here—continuity will not be the absence of change. It’s change with that means.
So, what ought to ethical schooling do?
Not shout “Bumalik kayo sa dati!” However ask, patiently and courageously: What sort of individuals are we forming? What ethical horizon are we pointing to? Are we accompanying progress, or merely guarding reminiscences?
The ship is shifting—whether or not we prefer it or not. The duty is to not cease it. The duty is to show it methods to sail.
And maybe that’s the most Filipino ethical lesson of all.
#MoralEducationPH #Pagpapakatao #ValuesEducationPH #ShipofTheseus #MullaSadra#IslamicPhilosophy #PhilosophyofEducation
(MindaViews is the opinion part of MindaNews. Mansoor L. Limba, PhD in Worldwide Relations and Shari‘ah Counselor-at-Legislation (SCL), is a publisher-writer, college professor, vlogger, chess coach, and translator (from Persian into English and Filipino) with tens of written and translation works to his credit score on such topics as worldwide politics, historical past, political philosophy, intra-faith and interfaith relations, cultural heritage, Islamic finance, jurisprudence (fiqh), theology (‘ilm al-kalam), Qur’anic sciences and exegesis (tafsir), hadith, ethics, and mysticism. He might be reached at mlimba@diplomats.com and www.youtube.com/@WayfaringWithMansoor, and his books might be bought)
https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/
https://mindanews.com/mindaviews/2025/12/marginalia-the-ship-that-keeps-moving/



