DAVAO CITY (MindaNews / 29 January) — The Supreme Courtroom En Banc denied the movement for reconsideration filed by members of the Home of Representatives, which sought the reversal of its earlier ruling declaring the Articles of Impeachment in opposition to Vice President Sara Duterte unconstitutional.
In a press launch issued on Thursday, the Courtroom, in a unanimous resolution, upheld its July 25, 2025 resolution that declared the fourth impeachment criticism unconstitutional for violating due course of and the one-year bar rule beneath Article XI, Part 3(5) of the Structure.
Article XI, Part 3(5) offers that “no impeachment proceedings shall be initiated in opposition to the identical official greater than as soon as inside a interval of 1 12 months.”
4 impeachment complaints had been filed in opposition to the Vice President.
The primary three impeachment complaints had been filed in accordance with the primary mode of initiating an impeachment criticism by non-public people and numerous teams on December 2, 4, and 19, 2024, whereas the fourth one was filed in accordance with the second mode on February 5, 2025, and transmitted to the Senate on the identical day because the Articles of Impeachment.
The Courtroom stated, nonetheless, that the primary three complaints weren’t positioned within the Order of Enterprise throughout the required 10 session days.
The Courtroom interpreted “session days,” as utilized in Article XI, Part 3, subsection (2) or for functions of the primary mode of initiating an impeachment criticism, to imply a “calendar day during which the Decrease Home holds a session,” slightly than “legislative session days.”
It additionally enumerated situations when an impeachment criticism is deemed initiated, thereby triggering the one-year bar rule.
In line with the Courtroom, one in every of such situations is “when a correctly verified and endorsed impeachment criticism is just not positioned within the Order of Enterprise of the Home of Representatives inside 10 session days, or referred to the Committee on Justice after it has been put within the Order of Enterprise inside three session days as required by Article XI, Part 3(2) of the Structure.”
The Courtroom additionally distinguished the second mode of initiating an impeachment criticism from the primary one.
It stated that the second mode beneath Article XI, Part 3(4) requires “an endorsement by at the very least one-third of the members of the Home of Representatives, which is adequate to transmit the Articles of Impeachment.”
The Courtroom, nonetheless, famous that it acknowledged the Decrease Home’s train of its personal rule-making energy and that Part 2 of the “Home Guidelines, as it’s at the moment worded, requires the referral to the Committee on Justice even when filed by means of the second mode.”
It added that “the Home might—optionally upon its personal prerogative—refer an impeachment criticism already endorsed by at the very least one-third of all its members” to the Committee on Justice to “be certain that the endorsement of the members of the Home is verified” and “to substantiate that the proof supporting the grounds within the criticism exists, and that each member of the Home has been given a duplicate of the criticism, in addition to the proof supporting it.”
The Courtroom stated that present Home Guidelines additionally require referral to the Committee on Justice to “respect the Committee’s prerogative to consolidate completely different formulations of the criticism, if any, in order that just one criticism is endorsed to the plenary for transmittal to the Senate.”
In its July 25, 2025 resolution, penned by SC Senior Affiliate Justice Marvic Leonen, the Courtroom declared the impeachment criticism unconstitutional on the bottom of violation of due course of, other than the one-year bar rule.
It added that it “is just not absolving Vice President Duterte from any of the costs in opposition to her. However any subsequent impeachment criticism might solely be filed beginning February 6, 2026.”
In line with the Courtroom, “due strategy of regulation applies to the impeachment course of.”
“Due course of because it applies to the impeachment course of is sui generis or a category of its personal. Full-blown trial occurs on the Senate,” it added.
Due course of, in keeping with the Courtroom, requires, at the very least for the second mode, that the grounds invoked within the criticism or decision are these contained in Article XI, Part 2 of the Structure; the process is ruled by the Guidelines on Impeachment promulgated by the Home of Representatives previous to any submitting of any impeachment criticism; and as already supplied by the present Home Guidelines on Impeachment, all endorsing members ought to have been given a duplicate of the criticism and all its supporting proof. (Antonio L. Colina IV / MindaNews)
https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/
https://mindanews.com/top-stories/2026/01/sc-upholds-ruling-declaring-impeachment-complaint-vs-vp-sara-unconstitutional/



