THE HAGUE, Netherlands – There isn’t any direct hyperlink from the “stuff that got here out of Rodrigo Duterte’s mouth and the deaths pertinent to the case.”

This was lead protection counsel Nicholas Kaufman’s predominant level when he offered his arguments on Day 3 of the affirmation of prices listening to on Thursday, February 26.

Offering the nexus is important for a case like this within the Worldwide Prison Courtroom, and the prosecution, throughout their flip, supplied a pyramid of how Duterte’s phrases, lists, and insurance policies resulted within the killings of individuals from the 78 victims included of their prices.

“However the prosecution can not present such a causal hyperlink. They’ve by no means been ready to try this. They present you a stunning pyramid,” stated Kaufman.

One of many particular examples supplied by the prosecution on Day 2 was how Duterte threatened to kill Albuera, Leyte mayor Rolando Espinosa, put him on his narco-list, after which he was killed and marked as “neutralized.”

“The variety of people on this so-called kill record, the very record on which the prosecution depends to indicate the information that demise would ensue, is 4,817. Those that are literally neutralized dwarfs compared and stands at 248. So, assuming that ‘neutralized’ truly means killed, which it doesn’t, then there is no such thing as a digital certainty attributable to Rodrigo Duterte that demise would ensue from this kill record. Relatively, a 5% likelihood,” stated Kaufman.

For the prosecution, they have been capable of show a important component, which is that Duterte made an “important contribution” to the crimes, akin to offering logistical help (the giving out of weapons) and providing monetary rewards.

At this stage, it’s nonetheless a decrease normal of “substantial grounds to imagine” to maneuver to trial.

Each side declare win on Spherical 3

For former Duterte Cupboard members, Kaufman’s presentation “shattered” the case.

“The prosecution idea has been shattered to items as a result of the very testimonial proof and the documentary proof offered by the prosecution (have) been completely rebutted,” stated Panelo.

Kaufman additionally hammered on the truth that within the speeches whereby Duterte stated to kill, he would additionally say to simply pull out their gun in self-defense. For Kaufman, these sorts of speeches exonerate Duterte. Kaufman additionally cited later circulars by the Duterte authorities that truly instructed police to observe due course of. Rappler has earlier reported on these circulars that appeared to attempt to cover the legal loopholes of Senator Ronald “Bato” dela Rosa’s authentic Oplan TokHang memorandum or police round No. 16-2

The victims’ legal professionals, in the meantime, weren’t bothered by Kaufman’s presentation, saying that it was a weak protection.

“That’s a weak argument,” stated human rights lawyer Neri Colmenares. Whereas Kaufman stated there had been no proof of a “assembly of the minds” between co-perpetrators, Colmenares stated such a literal assembly was not wanted.

“I don’t suppose there’s any evidentiary requirement that they need to meet collectively to show it. President Duterte, in fact, devised a typical plan. He ordered it, however he simply wants to speak to Bato, (former justice secretary Vitaliano) Aguirre, and say: ‘Look. We do that, proper?’ ‘Okay. Sure, sir,’ they agreed,” stated Colmenares.


Kaufman insisted there had been no proof of “computerized compliance” down the meals chain, or the prosecution’s pyramid. There’s one insider witness aware about Oplan TokHang, however Kaufman discredited that witness additionally, saying that the kills the witness made have been “on the whim” of a barangay chair.

At one level of the session, Kaufman stated there could possibly be no proof of Duterte ordering or abetting the crimes as a result of the prosecution didn’t formally embody command accountability within the prices. Kaufman stated the judges mustn’t let the prosecution requalify its prices.

“In case you do — and I imagine you shouldn’t, I respectfully submit — it is best to order the prosecution to resubmit its doc containing the costs and its pre-confirmation transient, and to launch Mr. Duterte within the interim,” stated Kaufman.

Kaufman later instructed reporters that it was not a proper second request for interim launch. Yearly, the judges must evaluate if Duterte’s detention remains to be crucial. The later a part of Day 4 might be dedicated to the detention evaluate.

‘I don’t make gentle of victims’ grief’

Kaufman opened his session by saying that no matter he stated that day was in no disrespect to victims.

“The protection doesn’t disrespect the soul of any deceased individual, nor does it make gentle of the lack of life. Any criticism made by us at the moment is not going to be leveled on the family members of these, such because the tearful relative whom I noticed within the gallery right here on Tuesday,” stated Kaufman.

The lawyer stated that as a result of “in each case of this court docket, the victims (are) central.”

“After all, I felt for the poor woman on the gallery yesterday who was crying, as a result of I’m a human being, we’re all human beings, and I don’t make gentle of her grief. Nevertheless, I’ve a job to do, and that’s to defend somebody who I imagine has been wrongly charged,” stated Kaufman.

However Llore Pasco, who misplaced her two sons within the drug struggle, stated she nonetheless felt diminished and belittled.

“We see that our humanity is de facto underestimated. It appears that evidently our family members are nugatory. It is stated that it is only a quantity, it is like our struggling, our struggling shouldn’t be valued,” stated Pasco.

(We noticed that our humanity was belittled. It was as if our family members meant nothing. That they have been only a quantity, like our sufferings and difficulties don’t have any that means.)


Kaufman’s main defense: No direct link from Duterte to the dead bodies

– Rappler.com

https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/

https://www.rappler.com/philippines/kaufman-no-direct-link-duterte-dead-bodies-icc-pre-trial-february-26-2026/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here