Amongst different deserves, the prosecution’s case idea in opposition to former president Rodrigo Duterte lies on the phrase “neutralization” which suggests “kill” or “killing” below Duterte’s warfare on medicine.
It’s because the police memorandum that launched the drug warfare — Command Memorandum Round (CMC) No. 16-2016 signed by then-Philippine Nationwide Polioce chief Ronald dela Rosa — contained the mentioned time period.
Whereas the prosecution devoted a substantial time through the International Criminal Court’s (ICC) pre-trial hearings to elucidate why the phrase “neutralization” within the CMC led to 1000’s of killings, Duterte’s lawyer Nicholas Kaufman tried to downplay the phrase by utilizing it as an insult in opposition to President Ferdinand Marcos Jr.
“So it’s certainly the protection’s case that President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. got down to neutralize Rodrigo Duterte and his legacy,” Kaufman instructed the prosecution on Monday, February 23. “Sure, Mr. Deputy Prosecutor, I used that legendary phrase, neutralize, so central and so important to your case idea, as a result of you understand simply in addition to me that I’m utilizing the time period metaphorically.”
Nevertheless it didn’t cease there — Kaufman, as anticipated, introduced up the time period once more throughout his presentation on the deserves on Thursday, February 25. This time, Duterte’s protection lawyer used the Supreme Courtroom’s (SC) inaction on the petition difficult the constitutionality of the memoranda that launched the drug warfare.
“The Supreme Courtroom of the Philippines, nevertheless, so far has declined to situation any ruling declaring he marketing campaign unconstitutional, has declined to invalidate circulars, and has declined to rule so far that neutralize or neutralization means to kill,” the lawyer mentioned on Thursday.
Kaufman’s declare will not be nevertheless completely correct: the SC didn’t decline to situation a ruling however has but to situation its determination. However, even with out the SC definition, a variety of native sources can already be put collectively to grasp the widespread which means of “neutralization.”
From the Supreme Courtroom petition
Within the drug warfare’s early years, human rights legal professionals from the Free Authorized Help Group (FLAG) filed a petition with the SC to problem the drug war-related circulars issued by the Duterte administration. The human rights legal professionals challenged the legality of those orders:
- Command Memorandum Round No. 16-2016 – launched the warfare on medicine
- Memorandum Round (MC) No. 2017-112 by the Division of the Inside and Native Authorities – in a while referred to as Masa Masid, which turned an avenue for residents to report suspected drug personalities
Dela Rosa’s CMC contains “normal pointers, procedures, and duties of police places of work/items/stations” within the drug warfare, including that the marketing campaign is “in help to the Barangay Drug Clearing Technique of the federal government and the neutralization of unlawful drug personalities nationwide.”
The petition has been pending since 2017, or almost 9 years because it was filed. Nevertheless, the arguments raised — in addition to tidbits of knowledge — raised by authorized specialists within the proceedings of the mentioned case already present an image of what neutralization means.
For instance, former FLAG chairperson and now Akbayan Representative Chel Diokno said in that Dela Rosa’s CMC No. 16 needs to be declared unconstitutional as a result of “neutralizing” is a non-legal time period. Diokno added that the round empowered the police to “neutralize” suspected drug personalities, as a substitute of their precise features like to assemble proof and construct a case.
“It isn’t outlined within the PNP Handbook of Operations or in any official PNP doc. However in official PNP stories and police parlance — as admitted by Dela Rosa — ‘neutralize’ means to kill,” FLAG’s petition mentioned.
FLAG additionally highlighted the round’s web page 5 which says, “Any individual suspected to be concerned in unlawful drug trafficking who dies or refuses the home to deal with visitation shall be referred to the anti-illegal drug items for speedy case build-up and negation.”
In line with the legal professionals’ group, this wording confirmed that it’s “clear and unmistakable” that the warfare on medicine was by no means meant to reform drug suspects.
In the course of the oral arguments for the SC case, then-senior affiliate justice Antonio Carpio mentioned what “neutralize” may imply primarily based on out there data. (READ: Kill or arrest? SC’s Carpio pins down what PNP means by ‘neutralize’)
“The PNP Director Common Dela Rosa was quoted in a Davao paper, Davao At this timeand he mentioned, their goal was for all drug personalities within the space to be, and I quote, ‘neutralized, which means they need to give up, be arrested, or be killed throughout drug operations’,” the Justice of the Peace mentioned then.
What different sources say
ICC witness and self-confessed former Davao Dying Squad member Arturo Lascañas mentioned in his affidavit that neutralize — usually utilized by Duterte in orders — means to kill in any method.
Lascañas talked about the phrase “neutralize” or “neutralization” at the very least 37 occasions in his affidavit seen by Rappler.
The Home of Representatives launched its quad committee in 2024 with the aim of probing Duterte’s warfare on medicine, extrajudicial killings, and Philippine offshore gaming operators. Aside from testimonies that clearly established the drug warfare’s system and affidavits that straight linked Duterte to those alleged killings, the hearings additionally clarified what neutralization means.
In his bombshell testimonyformer drug warfare poster boy and retired police lieutenant colonel Jovie Espenido mentioned he was assigned to go the Ozamiz police to “dismantle the Parojinog drug operations by all means crucial” which “in police language…included neutralization or elimination of the goal.”
In 2017, then-Ozamiz mayor Reynaldo Parojinog, his spouse Susan, his brother Octavio Parojinog Jr., and their sister Mona have been killed with 11 others in a police raid.
“What I mentioned, your honor, it is vitally widespread for the officers and it solely has one which means. By all means, it’s as much as the discretion of operatives or entrance liners or those who implement search or arrest warrants,” Espenido mentioned.
When then requested if these meanings embody killing, Espenido replied, “It’s included there, your honor.”
“There was a dialogue (within the quad committee hearings) when some cops thought that the neutralization order, as indicated in a memorandum issued by the chief PNP then, means neutralization as in killing,” Home quad committee chairperson Ace Barbers instructed Rappler.
In a 2024 Senate listening to, Diokno talked about a press release from former PNP chief and spokesperson Dionardo Carlos in 2016 which acknowledged that the which means of the phrase “neutralized” is “killed.” Diokno additionally shared a report from Santa Ana, Manila Police that used “neutralization” to outline the killings as outcomes of alleged suspects’ resistance.
“Components of Sta. Ana Police Station (PS-6)… (are) incessantly conducting case buildup in opposition to the mentioned persona, and if proof warrants, a attainable police operation and intervention would step up for his speedy apprehension and neutralization,” the doc mentioned, as quoted by DZRH News.
Former Fee on Human Rights commissioner Karen Gomez-Dumpit instructed Rappler that the 2013 version of the Philippine Nationwide Police handbook of operations — which covers the interval of Duterte’s alleged crimes (2013 to 2016 as mayor; 2016 to 2017 as president) — mentions the phrase at the very least 5 occasions.
For instance, within the half detailing the method to take care of snipers, the handbook states: “To keep away from escape and supply fireplace energy help to neutralize armed and hostile suspects throughout firefight.”
“‘Neutralize’ seems on the textual content in tandem with apprehension, stop escape, seize,” Gomez-Dumpit defined. “To apprehend, seize, stop the escape of a suspect could also be thought of as types of neutralization however its which means additionally contains to kill.”
Neutralization actually means ‘to kill’
The group of trial legal professionals prosecuting Duterte on the ICC Pre-Trial Chamber I is satisfied that they’ve sufficient deserves to fulfill the required degree of proof to substantiate the costs and proceed to trial.
The prosecution’s Edward Jeremy mentioned on Tuesday, February 24, that neutralization merely means to kill, then went on to record cases the place alleged drug suspects have been “neutralized” just like the one-time, big-time drug operation in Bulacan in 2017, the place 32 individuals have been killed.
The prosecution additionally reiterated via one other trial lawyer, Robynn Croft, that the assaults in opposition to suspected drug suspects have been carried out pursuant to Duterte’s state coverage to “neutralize” the people.
Regardless of Kaufman’s effort to query the definition of neutralization, Nationwide Union of Peoples Legal professionals (NUPL) president Ephraim Cortez mentioned that the prosecution was profitable in exhibiting what the phrase means, primarily based on their submissions.
Cortez defined that when wanting on the proof, individuals shouldn’t take a look at at these details in isolation of different proof. In Duterte’s case, the NUPL president mentioned that the which means of the phrase neutralization may be very a lot clear if you take a look at Duterte’s speeches, the PNP memorandum, and the matrix of individuals killed.
Worldwide legislation professional and ICC assistant to counsel Ross Tugade defined to Rappler that “neutralization” might be defined by wanting on the drug warfare’s widespread plan and intent.
On the widespread plan, the phrase might be outlined by wanting on the demise certificates, for instance, as a result of these paperwork will match the dates of the “neutralization,” in line with Tugade.
“That would already let you know that inside the widespread plan, how did the co-perpetrators interpret the phrase neutralized?” Tugade added.
On the intent, Tugade mentioned individuals can take a look at the intent when the phrase neutralized was mentioned, then take a look at the chain of occasions that occurred because the phrase neutralization was talked about. As highlighted by the prosecution, individuals have been killed after Duterte and Dela Rosa launched the PNP memorandum that contained this phrase in competition.
“So neutralization right here, if you tie all of the items collectively, pull all of the strands collectively, can determine into the widespread plan and determine into the precise intent once they have been utilizing the phrase within the context of the police operations and what it resulted in,” the worldwide legislation professional mentioned. – Rappler.com
https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/
https://www.rappler.com/newsbreak/in-depth/neutralization-meaning-rodrigo-duterte-drug-war-local-sources/






