PASIG CITY (MindaNews / 13 March) – Six misconceptions are costing us the peace course of.
—
When the MILF suspended its decommissioning commitments in July 2025, the fast response from many quarters was predictable: requires dialogue, assurances of dedication to the peace course of, and a wait-and-see posture. What was largely absent was an trustworthy reckoning with why the method retains arriving at these moments of disaster.
The Bangsamoro peace course of is in bother not primarily due to spoilers or funding shortfalls or institutional capability gaps. It’s in bother as a result of the individuals with essentially the most energy to help it have constantly misunderstood what the battle is definitely about.
Six misconceptions drive this misunderstanding. They matter as a result of fallacious frames produce fallacious responses.
It’s not about growth. The dominant intervention logic for many years has been: the Bangsamoro are poor, poverty breeds battle, repair the poverty and the battle resolves. This body has generated actual investments — BARMM’s poverty charge fell from 52.6% to 23.5% between 2018 and 2023. However the peace course of remains to be in disaster. Poverty discount doesn’t dissolve a political and rights-based grievance. The Bangsamoro didn’t decide up arms as a result of they lacked infrastructure. They did so as a result of their lands had been taken. Colonial regulation made the bias express: a 1913 public land act gave Christian settlers 16 hectares; Moros acquired 8. By 1919, non-Moros may declare 24 hectares whereas Moros had been capped at 10. Forty-two authorities resettlement tasks adopted, transferring roughly 750,000 hectares to settler households. Between 1903 and the Sixties, Muslims went from over 75% of Mindanao’s inhabitants to a minority throughout the island that had been their homeland. Growth applications that skip this historical past deal with the symptom and let Manila off the hook for the rights violations on the battle’s root.
It’s not about faith. The Philippines is predominantly Catholic; the Bangsamoro are Muslim. The spiritual battle body writes itself. Additionally it is fallacious. The MILF’s foundational paperwork converse of ancestral area and political self-determination, not theological grievance. The Moro declare to their territory predates Islamic arrival in Mindanao within the 14th century. Treating this as a non secular battle produces counterterrorism responses the place political engagement is what’s wanted — and it offered harmful cowl within the post-9/11 interval for many who wished to break down the excellence between the MILF and armed prison teams just like the Abu Sayyaf.
It’s not about stopping armed battle. The Bangsamoro has had ceasefires earlier than. The 1976 Tripoli Settlement produced silence, then collapsed. The 1996 peace deal created ARMM — which grew to become a textbook case of autonomy captured by political dynasties and starved of actual energy. The architects of the 2014 CAB understood this; they designed an structure for structural transformation, not a ceasefire. Seven years after the foundational laws, normalization is stalled, transitional justice is basically unimplemented, elections scheduled for 2022 have nonetheless not occurred, and decommissioning is suspended. The ceasefire holds. The battle stays unresolved.
It’s not solved by the institution of the BARMM. There’s a narrative circulating in growth and diplomatic circles: the peace course of succeeded, BARMM was established, and now it’s governance and growth. BARMM is a car, not a vacation spot. The substitute of Murad Ebrahim as Chief Minister in March 2025 — the Amerul Muhajideen of the MILF — was not an administrative transition. In response to the MILF, it was a regime change. It altered who leads the BARMM and whose pursuits it serves. Elections stay suspended. The normalization commitments are badly behind. You may have a area named Bangsamoro whereas the substance of Bangsamoro self-governance is progressively hollowed out.
It’s not about holding elections. A model of this misreading is circulating proper now: maintain the BARMM parliamentary elections in September 2026, and the peace course of will get again on monitor. The Bangsamoro, the argument goes, simply have to elect their very own leaders.
The Bangsamoro have been electing leaders for generations — by nationwide elections, ARMM elections, native elections throughout Muslim Mindanao. Electoral participation just isn’t what the battle is about. What the CAB guarantees is self-determination: the fitting of a individuals to manipulate themselves on their ancestral territory underneath a framework of real autonomy. Elections are a essential characteristic of that framework. They aren’t its substance. Holding elections whereas normalization stays stalled, transitional justice is unimplemented, and BARMM’s political path is managed by forces exterior the peace settlement just isn’t decision. It’s democratic scaffolding round an unresolved rights declare.
And it’s not Manila’s drawback alone to resolve. The CAB is an internationally witnessed settlement. The events constructed accountability mechanisms into its construction intentionally — as a result of bilateral agreements between a strong state and an armed group, with out exterior witnesses, have a poor monitor file right here. When worldwide companions disengage, Manila can quietly renegotiate, delay, or underfund shifts.
What all six myths share is that this: they permit the political roots of the battle to stay unaddressed. The Bangsamoro battle is about dispossession, oppression, and tyranny. It’s about grave human rights violations that had been by no means accounted for. It’s a few individuals’s declare to manipulate themselves on their ancestral territory — a declare that predates Philippine statehood and can outlast any particular person administration’s endurance with it.
Till that’s understood, prescriptions will preserve touchdown huge off the mark.
What is required now could be particular. The Philippine authorities should honor the CAB’s normalization timeline, not handle it to its personal political comfort. Transitional justice should transfer from paper to implementation. The September 2026 elections must be held — however as one a part of a real transition, not as an alternative to the structural commitments the CAB requires. Worldwide companions should not deal with the signing of the CAB because the conclusion of their accountability — they witnessed it, and so they should witness its implementation with equal seriousness.
The Bangsamoro individuals have been affected person. They accepted the CAB’s framework as a pathway to self-determination. They watched elections get deferred, normalization stall, and political management over their area shift in methods the settlement by no means envisioned.
That endurance just isn’t limitless. And when it runs out, we won’t be able to say we didn’t perceive what was at stake.
(MindaViews is the opinion part of MindaNews. Camilo “Bong” Montesa of Cagayan de Oro is a lawyer and professor primarily based in Pasig Metropolis. He has spent three a long time in battle and peacebuilding work within the Philippines.)
https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/
https://mindanews.com/mindaviews/2026/03/peacetalk-we-keep-getting-the-bangsamoro-wrong/



