Public works tasks marked 100% full by the Division of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) had been alleged substandard tasks, in accordance with images and paperwork obtained by Rappler, and corroborated by an insider supply aware about these tasks.
The knowledge we gathered exposes a modus operandi of how public works find yourself being substandard. The kickbacks and revenue shares add up per participant on the mission, in accordance with our supply, in order that solely a dismal 40% of the finances is left for the construction.
The insider supply confirmed Rappler paperwork that indicated the DPWH awarded a ₱66-million flood management mission to a contractor, who then subcontracted it for less than ₱26.5 million. Which means that solely 40% of what was budgeted from taxpayers’ cash really went to the mission.
“50% of the finances being spent is already excessive,” mentioned the supply who agreed to talk to Rappler on the situation that we withhold identities for safety causes.
The place does the DPWH finances go?
Based mostly on insider supply’s account
60%
Revenue shares and ‘SOPs’
(euphemism for kickbacks)
40%
Precise finances for subcontractors
to construct the mission
This story will talk about intimately two different tasks in Tarlac and Cavite, and which implicate large names of contractors just like the Discayas and the Romeros.
“Ang turo naman sa atin as Catholic, hindi lang ‘yung sin of fee, ‘yung omission isa ring half ng kasalanan. Dun ko nakikita ‘yung kasalanan ko, kapag hindi ako nagsalita nang ganito,” the supply mentioned.
(We have been taught as Catholics that there is not solely a sin of fee, but additionally a sin of omission. That is my sin if I do not communicate up.)
The concerned workplaces in DPWH denied that the tasks which will likely be talked about right here on this story had been substandard. In addition they denied information of any subcontracting that occurred.
The DPWH mentioned it is going to proceed to be careful for corrupt practices.
“Secretary Vince Dizon, has initiated, instituted, and carried out measures and reforms, and continues to advance these efforts, to curb and deal with doable corrupt practices inside the Division’s Implementing Workplaces, together with enhancing monitoring mechanisms and minimizing discretionary authority, the place possible,” DPWH Undersecretary Ricardo Bernabe mentioned in a press release despatched to Rappler.
Flood management in Gerona, Tarlac
Mission 21CJ0008 or Part III of flood administration program alongside Tarlac River in Gerona, Tarlac. Marked 100% full. Video taken on March 18, 2026.
The supply mentioned they have been dropping sleep over a flood management mission in Gerona, Tarlac, which you see above, responsible that if they don’t communicate up in regards to the substandard mission, it might put residents within the space in danger.
The mission is Quantity 21CJ0008, awarded by the DPWH Tarlac 1st District Engineering Workplace (DEO) on March 21, 2022 to R-II Builders Inc, which is the corporate of Reghis Romero II, in accordance with company filings with the Securities and Change Fee (SEC) and on the corporate web site. Romero is the daddy of former 1-Pacman Partylist Mikee Romero. The unique contract value was ₱41.89 million.
A number of paperwork present that the mission was subcontracted to the corporate Arconic Inc. R-II and Arconic are related by one other Romero son, Nathaniel L. Romero. Nathaniel was the CEO of RMR Capital, the previous R-II Holdings, as of 2025, in accordance with its SEC filings. Nathaniel was additionally one of many founders of Arconic Inc., in accordance with incorporation papers filed with the SEC, though he’s now not a listed proprietor as of 2025.
R-II Builders subcontracted this mission to Arconic, making them the primary subcontractor. Arconic subcontracted the mission a second time to the corporate SMM Development. This implies there was double subcontracting, and the second subcontract to SMM was inked on April 25, 2022, or only a month after the unique DPWH contract.
The Tarlac 1st DEO mentioned “they haven’t any information of, nor did they consent to or enable, any subcontracting preparations,” in accordance with DPWH’s Bernabe, who got here beneath the management of Vince Dizon and was introduced in to “clear” the division.
Arconic confirmed to Rappler that they “helped R-II Builders Inc. handle the implementation of the identical as its mission supervisor,” the corporate’s president Greg Ignacio mentioned in a response letter to us.
Arconic additionally supplied Rappler with DPWH certificates of completion, however these paperwork had been addressed to R-II Builders, not Arconic. We adopted up about its second subcontract to SMM, however we now not obtained a response.
R-II Builders instructed Rappler the identical, saying in a response to us on Monday, April 13, that: “For the Tarlac Mission, RBI engaged Arconic, Inc. (“Arconic”) as its Mission Supervisor and never as a sub-contractor.” Like Arconic, R-II Builders additionally didn’t reply to the query about SMM’s involvement.
The supply mentioned subcontractors are already lined up as early because the bidding. “Could mga bata-bata na itong mga kompanyang ito. So alam na nila kung sino ‘yung kukunin nilang mga subcontractor,” mentioned the supply. (These corporations have their favored subcontractors. They already know which subcontractors they’re going to get.)
The supply mentioned that based mostly on their expertise, contractors who’ve connections with top-level officers are notified if a finances has been made out there by a proponent from both the Home or the Senate. When the contractor agrees to tackle the mission, paperwork are then ready.
“Even earlier than the bidding, a contractor already is aware of the mission is theirs,” mentioned the supply in Filipino.
The subcontract to SMM was price solely ₱28.156 million, or solely 67% of the ₱41.89-million unique value within the DPWH contract. Subcontracting is mostly allowed in authorities infrastructure tasks for sure works solely.
However, by evaluating the invoice of portions — or a doc itemizing down the scope of labor together with the amount of supplies — within the unique DPWH contract and the subcontract to SMM, we came upon that the mission was subcontracted in its entirety. Even so, the entire subcontract constituted solely 67% of the finances.
The Payments of Portions are just about equivalent – the whole mission subcontracted?
The result’s a substandard mission, as a result of they minimize value on supplies to make the slashed finances work, mentioned our supply.
Images of the location earlier than restore, and paperwork we obtained assist the declare that the mission was substandard. Paperwork confirmed that the development was accomplished on December 22, 2022, however upon inspection by the DPWH on September 22, 2023, there have been “appreciable damages (sic)…. such (as) cracks and collapsed embankment.”
The DPWH Tarlac 1st DEO mentioned “injury to the slope safety was attributed to exterior elements, together with vital water move and vibrations from ongoing building actions above, which disturbed the embankment supplies and affected roughly ten (10) spans of the slope safety.”
Video of the substandard Gerona flood management mission. Obtained by Rappler.


Nevertheless, Rappler noticed one doc that factors to substandard work, reasonably than exterior elements contributing to break.
In an alternate of letters between the 2 subcontractors over who ought to shoulder the price of restore, SMM mentioned: “Could we additionally emphasize that Arconic itself will not be following what has been given beneath the unique plan.”
SMM claims, in accordance with the doc, that Arconic “instructed” them to bury sheet piles for six meters solely, and never 7.5 meters underground as must be the case. There have been additionally fewer sheet piles. What ought to have been 5,543 meters of sheet piles per the unique invoice of portions, grew to become 4,463.95 meters solely.
DPWH Tarlac 1st DEO maintained that ample sheetpiles had been used.
“With respect to the sheet piles, the involved Mission Engineer confirms that the desired size, as supplied within the Program of Works, was utilized and that the sheet piles had been put in on the applicable depth, based mostly on inspection and monitoring,” mentioned the workplace.
R-II Builders mentioned they’ve a DPWH doc from March 6, 2024 “certifying that the mission is free from defects and failures that are traceable to poor workmanship, use of poor-quality materials and non-compliance with plans and specs.”
The supply insisted the mission was substandard, pointing to collusion between DPWH personnel and the contractor. The supply mentioned they proceed to fret for the close by group.
“If this (substandard work) continues, the village there would bear the results,” mentioned the supply in Filipino.
Arconic mentioned “we’re constrained to placed on file that we’re presently unable to touch upon the identical, both attributable to lack of privity, or on account of litigation we’re presently pursuing.”
The remainder of the finances went to SOPs, or a euphemism for kickbacks, in accordance with the supply although they made a disclaimer that they haven’t any direct information about any deliveries of kickbacks, or who the recipients are.
“Kickbacks are mentioned throughout conferences, that they’re calling officers, who’s giving the approvals, however you do not know their names, the one factor is how a lot is slashed from the mission’s finances,” the supply mentioned in Filipino.
“Allegations in your letter seem to emanate from sources aimed toward besmirching our popularity or linking us to anomalous enterprise practices, regardless of our profitable and passable completion of those tasks,” mentioned Arconic.
Rappler reached out to SMM starting March 24, and known as a number of instances since then to observe up, however our calls to them had been unsuccessful. We dropped off letters to 2 listed addresses, which we had been instructed by the workers, had been the residence and workplace of SMM and its president. We are going to replace this story as soon as they reply.
Hospital at Naval Station, Cavite
The second mission is a public hospital contained in the Naval Station in Cavite Metropolis. Mission Quantity 21D00019 is a contract to construct two buildings — the nurses’ quarters, and parts of the primary hospital constructing. DPWH Area IV-A awarded the contract to Pacifico “Curlee” Discaya’s St. Gerrard Development on July 19, 2021 for ₱98.158 million. The mission was speculated to be accomplished in 300 days, or on Could 16, 2022.
Based on a cost demand letter we obtained, St. Gerrard subcontracted the mission to Arconic Inc. Discaya’s lawyer Cornelio Samaniego instructed Rappler in a textual content message on March 29 that his consumer “declined your request” for an interview or response.
Similar to the primary mission, the DPWH Area IV-A workplace denied information of the subcontracting association, including that “all paperwork associated to the implementation of this contract had been duly signed by the licensed consultant of St. Gerrard Development Gen. Contractor & Improvement Corp,” the workplace mentioned.
Arconic didn’t reply to the query about whether or not it was St. Gerrard’s subcontractor that was tapped for this particular phase of the mission.
The supply mentioned two DPWH personnel had been instantly in contact with the subcontractor Arconic all through the mission.
“The mere truth na might official sila sa website, might inspector, kung sino ang kinakausap nila maliwanag ‘yun. ‘Bakit hindi principal contractor kausap ko? Bakit ang subcontractor ang kausap ko?” mentioned the supply. (The mere undeniable fact that they’ve an official on website, there’s an inspector, it must be clear to them after they speak to somebody. Why weren’t they speaking to a principal contractor? Why had been they speaking to a subcontractor?)
The mission was suspended in September 2021 due to “poor and slender entry to the location,” in accordance with DPWH suspension orders we obtained, however the regional workplace confirmed it resumed however was terminated on April 18, 2023 “as a result of expiration of the FY 2021 and prior years’ appropriations for infrastructure capital outlay.”
The regional workplace mentioned they terminated it “for (the) comfort” of the federal government since their appropriations or their finances already expired.
The DPWH portal marks the mission solely 51.63% full.
It really reached 69.25%, in accordance with DPWH Area IV-A, and the workplace mentioned St. Gerrard was paid for what they accomplished. “No penalties had been imposed on St. Gerrard since previous to the issuance of Termination the mission didn’t incur any slippage, with the Precise Accomplishment forward of the Deliberate Accomplishment,” mentioned the regional workplace.
Our supply instructed a special story. Based on the supply, the mission was severely delayed, and causes had been “made up” to droop it and canopy the delay, finally “terminating it” simply so they’d not should return the funds.
“As a result of they already paid upfront although the mission will not be completed but, or none has been constructed on website,” mentioned the supply in Filipino.
The supply added that the development continued, however was off the information.
A doc we obtained confirmed that upon inspection by June 2024, some deficiencies had been noticed on the construction like incomplete plastering, concrete turning into honeycombs (or the development slang for when concrete has a defect resembling a beehive), and uncovered rebars.
Deficiencies noticed upon inspection
Swipe to see extra · Images obtained by Rappler
The DPWH regional workplace mentioned there was no investigation into this mission since there have been “no warrants” for it, however that they “constantly monitor these contracts since they’re nonetheless inside the guarantee.”
R-II builders and Arconic, as a three way partnership, snagged a parallel mission at virtually the identical time because the St. Gerrard contract.
Mission Quantity 21D00016, a contract to construct different buildings of Stage 1 of the Naval Station hospital, was awarded to R-II and Arconic on July 9, 2021 for ₱138.96 million. This, too, was delayed.
On the DPWH portal, what ought to have taken solely 300 days was additionally terminated at 59.16%. R-II Builders and Arconic had been paid correspondingly.
“We verify that within the implementation of the mentioned mission, a number of delays had been encountered arising principally from this mission being pursued at a time when quarantine protocols had been nonetheless in place on account of the Covid-19 Pandemic,” mentioned Arconic.
Even this mission wanted some rectification, in accordance with the supply.
R-II Builders denied the allegation that this work was substandard, saying they’ve a DPWH acceptance letter dated April 22, 2024 “certifying that the mission is free from defects and failures that are traceable to poor workmanship, use of poor-quality materials and non-compliance with plans and specs.”
The supply confirmed an alternate of messages dated June 2024 saying that the contractors had been going to be supplied “an advance copy of High quality Assurance Unit findings for acceptance” for the mission, additionally asking if the contractors can “present rectification images for each discovering.” This, the supply mentioned, proves collusion.
On March 24, 2022, a brand new contract, or Mission Quantity 22D00017, was awarded to the three way partnership of Arconic Inc. and EGB Development for ₱93.12 million. This has been marked 100% full.
Rappler has confirmed that this mission, which was Part III to construct seven buildings of the hospital, is being investigated by the Workplace of the Ombudsman as a part of their inquiry into EGB Development. The corporate is owned by Erni Baggao of Isabela.
EGB is among the many prime 15 flood contractors on President Ferdinand Marcos Jr.’s checklist, and Rappler lately reported that Erni’s brother Glen Baggao is a well being undersecretary, elevating battle of curiosity questions on EGB’s contracts overlaying constructing public clinics and hospitals — just like the one on the Naval station.
The hospital was not operational once we visited in March.
The DPWH mentioned not one of the tasks on this story are being investigated “as there are not any present complaints indicating any irregularity.”
“Nonetheless, we welcome any criticism, data, and/or proof which may be supplied on this matter to allow the Division to promptly conduct the mandatory investigation and, the place warranted, provoke applicable administrative and/or felony proceedings,” mentioned the DPWH.
‘Eyes shut, mouths shut’
Subcontracting and downgrading an infrastructure mission is finished in plain sight, mentioned the supply. There is no earnest effort to cover it on website.
“The tradition on website is the subcontractors make certain the inspectors eat effectively, which is regular. Typically they offer money. So as a substitute of inspectors targeted on the work on website, they’re distant, consuming. Subcontractors can do no matter they wish to do as a result of inspectors can’t see. Worse, they work at night time as a result of there are not any inspectors. Within the morning you’d see it is achieved. Who can now say the work was substandard? None,” mentioned the supply in Filipino.
The supply mentioned that generally, inspectors flag a piece achieved proper.
“The inspectors would even give directions on do it mistaken. They’d ask, ‘Why are you placing extra metal? Why is it thick? Can you continue to revenue from it?’ I used to be considering, possibly if we do it proper, they would not get a kickback,” mentioned the supply in Filipino.
Requested to explain the corruption in DPWH, the supply mentioned it is like “stage 4 most cancers.”
“Why are you talking out now, some might imagine possibly you didn’t get your minimize in a single mission, that is why you are talking out,” I requested the supply.
“They will say that. However I’ve a clear conscience, no matter I noticed, that is what I’ll disclose,” the supply mentioned in Filipino.
Are they keen to assist authorities investigators? “100% keen,” the supply mentioned. – with stories from Lance Ariel Bustos/Rappler.com
Lance Ariel Bustos is a Rappler intern. He’s a 3rd yr Political Science scholar at De La Salle College-Manila, and is the Intermedia editor of The LaSallian.
Edited by Chay Hofileña
Movies by Franz Lopez
Visualizations by David Castuciano and Don Kevin Hapal
https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/
https://www.rappler.com/newsbreak/investigative/dpwh-flood-control-scam-subcontracting-modus-substandard-projects/



