Former general deputy ombudsman (ODO) Melchor Arthur Carandang was punished by the Duterte administration for merely doing his job.
Duterte’s Workplace of the President (OP) fired him in 2018 over alleged breach of confidentiality and graft when he made statements concerning the financial institution investigation into former president Rodrigo Duterte’s wealth.
Eight years later, in 2026, Carandang discovered justice in a Supreme Courtroom (SC) choice that voided his dismissal.
“The Order, dated June 14, 2019, of the Workplace of the Ombudsman directing Melchor Arthur H. Carandang to stop and desist from performing his powers and features as Total Deputy Ombudsman, and declaring his put up vacant is likewise declared void,” the SC’s third Division mentioned in its January 29, 2026 ruling penned by Affiliate Justice Maria Filomena Singh.
The SC can not reinstitute Carandang as a result of his time period had already expired in 2020. As a substitute, the Excessive Courtroom gave Carandang his backwages from the interval of his preventive suspension and dismissal, as much as the supposed finish of his time period.
“Carandang is entitled to all retirement advantages efficient upon the expiration of his time period solely as much as the top of his time period,” mentioned the Courtroom.
President’s energy has limitations
“The 28-page ponencia of Justice Singh lucidly analyzes why the president has no administrative or disciplinary jurisdiction over Deputy Ombudsman,” former SC affiliate justice and ombudsman Conchita Carpio Morales instructed Rappler.
Carandang’s case was a check of the Ombudsman’s independence. The difficulty was whether or not the manager (Duterte) has the facility to dismiss an official (Carandang) of a constitutional physique just like the Workplace of the Ombudsman.
For the SC, Duterte’s OP had no energy over Carandang as a result of the authority to self-discipline the previous Ombudsman official lies with the constitutional physique.
The third Division upheld the Courtroom of Appeals’ (CA) ruling that the Second Gonzales choice applies as “you have got determined to face” (to face by issues determined) in Carandang’s case. The CA granted Carandang’s 2021 petition difficult his dismissal, that’s why the case reached the SC.
In 2014, the Courtroom promulgated the Second Gonzales decision that declared Section 8(2) of Republic Act No. 6770 or The Ombudsman Act of 1989 unconstitutional. Below the mentioned provision, a deputy or particular prosecutor could also be faraway from workplace by the president.
The you have got determined to face doctrine, in the meantime, requires courts to comply with already settled choices when confronted with related info and circumstances. So in different phrases, Carandang’s dismissal was void as a result of Duterte’s OP had no energy to dismiss him. Their supposed authorized foundation was already unconstitutional.
“Past historic precedent, it seems that the independence granted to the Workplace of the Ombudsman below the 1987 Structure was intentionally designed to curb the potential for government overreach,” mentioned the SC.
“Permitting the President to unilaterally self-discipline officers charged with investigating potential wrongdoing throughout the administration invitations retaliation, coercion, and the suppression of oversight, situations essentially at odds with transparency and accountability. The try to take away Carandang displays exactly the abuse of energy that the Second Gonzales Resolution sought to forestall,” the Singh ponencia added.
Ombudsman-Duterte standoff
After the complaints had been filed in opposition to Carandang, he was suspended at first, then was later ordered dismissed.
For a time, Carandang remained lively in his place as a result of his boss, Morales, opposed the suspension.
“I refused to implement the order because the president doesn’t have disciplinary jurisdiction over Deputy Ombudsmen (following the case of Gonzales). That aggravated my bitter relationship with Duterte,” the previous Ombudsman instructed Rappler.
What Morales provided was to as an alternative investigate Carandang for alleged breach, and that they might resolve if he could be punished with sanctions. Sadly for Carandang, Morales’ time period was solely till July 26, 2018.
“On July 30, 2018, 4 days after my retirement, the Palace issued the choice dismissing Carandang. My successor dutifully carried out the choice,” mentioned Morales.
Duterte appointed former SC affiliate justice Samuel Martires as his Ombudsman, and as anticipated by some, the then-ombudsman implemented the dismissal order in 2019. Martires mentioned he had no choice but to dismiss his second in command.
“They used ODO Artwork to attempt to push for the reversal of the Supreme Courtroom’s ruling — by no means thoughts that within the course of, they sullied the nice identify of ODO Artwork, and even forfeited all the advantages that he labored so onerous to earn. ODO Artwork was already there when the Workplace of the Ombudsman was established, and he labored his method as much as develop into the second-in-command of the workplace, with none document of corruption or abuse,” a former colleague of Carandang on the Ombudsman instructed Rappler.
“I’m joyful that he has now been absolutely vindicated, however I personally wish to see the legal professionals who pushed for his dismissal — the illegality of which they freely admitted — punished for his or her blatantly wrongful conduct,” Carandang’s former colleague added.
Duterte appointed his former lawyer, Warren Liongto interchange Carandang in 2020. Liong would later be dragged into the Pharmally Pharmaceutical Corporation mess that includes allegedly anomalous procurement contracts through the COVID-19 pandemic.
The CA affirmed this yr that Liong and fellow defendants had been administratively liable for grave misconduct, gross neglect of obligation, severe dishonesty, and conduct prejudicial to the very best curiosity of the service because of the Pharmally gaffe.
Carandang was simply doing his job
The bases of the executive complaints in opposition to Carandang had been his statements concerning the supposedly anomalous financial institution transactions associated to Duterte. These had been associated to former senator Antonio Trillanes IV’s complaints to the Ombudsman pertaining to Duterte’s alleged unexplained belongings.
Two separate complaints had been filed in opposition to Carandang after his interview. Among the many complainants had been legal professionals Jacinto Paras and Glenn Chong, each allies of the previous president.
For its half, Duterte’s OP discovered adequate proof to search out Carandang chargeable for graft and corruption and betrayal of public belief — bases to dismiss him from authorities service.
Even in a hypothetical scenario the place the OP has jurisdiction over Carandang, the Singh ruling mentioned the allegations in opposition to the previous ODO rested on a “weak basis.”
The SC mentioned Carandang’s statements didn’t meet the required proof to show the executive allegations. It defined that the previous ODO’s statements had been truly observations made by an official whose job was to probe into public officers and workers, together with the president.
In keeping with the Excessive Courtroom, Carandang’s use of the phrases “cow” (perhaps) and “perhaps” (probably), amongst others, confirmed that there was no wrongful intent on Carandang’s half through the media interview.
The SC took be aware of this as a result of there was an allegation that Carandang made false statements when he mentioned that he acquired financial institution transactions from the AMLC, regardless of the AMLC secretariat’s assertion that it didn’t present any report back to the Ombudsman.
The SC added that the previous ODO’s statements confirmed “neutrality,” including that “by no stretch of the creativeness can any act of graft or corrupt observe be attributed to him.”
“Fairly than betraying public belief, Carandang’s act of offering info on the standing of a pending grievance earlier than his workplace is according to the general public’s proper to info on issues of nationwide curiosity,” the Singh ponencia defined. – Rappler.com
https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/
https://www.rappler.com/philippines/why-melchor-arthur-carandang-victory-duterte-win-ombudsman-independence/




