For the primary time for the reason that Lopez cousins’ battle broke into the open in March, Federico “Piki” Lopez made his first public look. At First Gen Company’s digital annual stockholders’ assembly (ASM) on Thursday, Could 28, after all, the query would come: “What is occurring to the household?”
The First Gen chairman gave traders three sentences. The Lopez Inc. board, Piki stated, has withdrawn the resolution removing him as president. He described the transfer as “a attainable first step” for all events to resolve their points, a “peace overture” of kinds. And he added that he stays “absolutely ready for any end result,” whereas persevering with to meet his fiduciary duties to all shareholders of the Lopez group. Then he moved on.
For a feud that has produced press releases about “poison capsules” and a 71% majority ousting him “for trigger,” the impact of these three sentences is disproportionate. They mark the primary time the patriarch of the power arm has formally acknowledged, in a recorded stockholders’ assembly, that almost all cousins have pulled again the very instrument they used to attempt to take away him. Additionally they present how far the battle has shifted since Rappler first described it as a “ceasefire on paper, war in the courts” earlier in Could: the ceasefire now has paperwork behind it, however the battle has not ended.
What Piki stated – and what he didn’t
The query on the rift got here throughout the open discussion board after Piki and president Francis Giles Puno introduced their experiences. It was the one household query learn out.
Piki’s reply was measured to the purpose of being surgical. He confirmed that the board of Lopez Inc., the personal apex holding firm that sits above Lopez Holdings and First Philippine Holdings (FPH), had withdrawn the sooner board decision eradicating him as president. He stated he views this withdrawal as “a attainable first step for all events to lastly resolve the problems which have sadly been dividing our clan.” He referred to as it a “peace overture,” including that he stays “absolutely ready for any end result” that follows.
He then pivoted from household to fiduciary. “Within the meantime,” he stated, he’ll proceed to carry out his fiduciary duties and act as a accountable steward of the companies within the Lopez group, “notably First Gen Corp. and First Philippine Holdings Corp.,” which have institutional minority shareholders with vital financial pursuits.
Equally telling is what he didn’t say.
He by no means named his cousins. He didn’t point out ABS-CBN, or Rockwell, the companies that sit on the opposite facet of the group’s emotional and monetary map. He didn’t consult with Prime Infra or to the “poison pill” accusations that almost all cousins have hooked up to the gasoline and hydropower offers. He didn’t use the phrases “win” or “vindication.”
The distinction in tone is stark. Of their March 31 and April 29 statements, the bulk heirs described Piki as a “king” working a “scandal”-ridden empire, attacking what they referred to as “poison tablet” protections that supposedly make his job “price billions of pesos of different individuals’s cash.” Piki’s reply on the ASM, by comparability, was couched within the vocabulary of boards and courts: “fiduciary duties,” “stewardship,” “peace overture,” and “any end result.” (READ: How to make yourself very expensive to fire: The Lopez cousins’ war)
It’s the similar register he utilized in his April 17 townhall with workers, when he stated he didn’t need to flip the gathering into “a rally that foments hate,” and insisted that the corporate’s response to the dispute needed to stay skilled and institutional. The Could 28 annual stockholders assembly confirmed him carrying that stance into probably the most formal public venue he has: a stockholders’ assembly the place each phrase is minuted and filed.
One facet has been combating in tabloid register. The opposite, no less than on this room, stayed within the language of governance. That distinction doesn’t resolve who is correct, however it’s a truth with its personal weight.
What a withdrawn decision actually means
Behind the calm phrasing sits a risky timeline.
In late March, majority shareholders at Lopez Inc. holding 71% of the personal firm’s shares — handed a resolution removing Piki as president “for cause,” citing the Prime Infra gas salethe hydropower offers, and alleged lack of board approval, amongst different complaints. Piki responded by going to court docket. A regional trial court docket stepped in twice — first with a short lived restraining order, then with an extended injunction — blocking the implementation of the ouster decision whereas the intracorporate case proceeds.
On Could 14, Lopez Inc. filed a board doc formally withdrawing that very same decision. That’s the doc Piki was referring to when he spoke of the board having “withdrawn” the transfer in opposition to him. The court docket order had already disabled the decision; withdrawing it goes one step additional by taking the weapon itself off the desk, no less than for now.
It is very important separate what this does from what it doesn’t do.
Withdrawing a decision just isn’t the identical as settling the underlying dispute. The Could 14 doc doesn’t resolve who needs to be president of Lopez Inc. over the long run. It doesn’t reply the bulk’s accusations concerning the Prime Infra transactions or the change of administration management clauses. It doesn’t finish the court docket instances over entry to books, company governance, and alleged breaches of fiduciary responsibility.
What it does is take away the instant risk that almost all might level to a reside board decision and declare that Piki is “not president” of Lopez Inc. regardless of the injunction. It lowers the temperature of the battle from acute institutional decapitation to a slower battle over management, oversight, and legal responsibility.
Seen in that gentle, the “peace overture” language and the “absolutely ready for any end result” language sit in deliberate pressure. A peace overture that leaves all of the underlying instances alive just isn’t a give up. It’s a administration of threat. And somebody who’s “absolutely ready for any end result” just isn’t behaving as if the cousins’ withdrawal has restored everlasting concord.
The battle is being managed, not ended. The ceasefire is within the paperwork; the battlefield has moved again into the courtrooms and the negotiating rooms.
A standard election in the midst of a battle
If the household story was contained to a few sentences, the institutional story ran by your entire assembly.
First Gen’s ASM adopted the procedural script exactly. The company secretary reported that 4.67 billion shares, or 91.77% of excellent inventory, had been current in particular person, by distant communication, or by proxy — a excessive attendance charge by native requirements. The agenda coated approval of the earlier yr’s minutes, presentation of the annual report and audited monetary statements, ratification of board and administration acts for the reason that final assembly, election of administrators, appointment of exterior auditor, and approval of a brand new worker inventory buy plan.
On the election of administrators, the outcomes had been unequivocal. All 10 nominees to the board — together with unbiased administrators and representatives of controlling shareholder First Philippine Holdings (FPH) — had been elected with over 99% of the shares represented on the assembly voting of their favor. There have been no different slates, no protest nominations, no failed candidates.
This issues as a result of different Lopez corporations haven’t had such easy paths this yr. In early Could, the Securities and Change Fee (SEC) allowed FPH to carry its July 27 annual assembly with out electing a brand new board, a no-election association that successfully retains the incumbent administrators — together with Piki as chairman — in place on holdover till the intra-corporate case is resolved or a court docket orders in any other case. Lopez Holdings, for its half, postponed its personal annual assembly from June to August after two unbiased administrators resigned in fast succession, citing the necessity to give minorities extra time to appoint replacements.
Rappler’s Could 11 story — “When the annual meeting has no election: What the Lopez family dispute means for every investor,” — framed these developments as examples of how the calendar of annual stockholders’ conferences — the one legally assured second annually when homeowners can vote on who runs their corporations — bends when highly effective households struggle. First Gen’s ASM presents a counterfactual throughout the similar company tree.
Right here, the complete accountability ritual occurred: discover, quorum, report, ratification, election, auditor, inventory plan. Right here, the board formally submitted itself to a vote, though the maths of management meant the consequence was successfully predetermined: First Philippine Holdings owns 67.84% of First Gen’s widespread shares and 100% of its voting most well-liked inventory, sufficient to elect your entire slate by itself.
To the market, that distinction sends a message. No matter is occurring at Lopez Inc.’s personal boardroom, the power platform that bears the household’s listed flagship identify seems useful on the stage of course of. That doesn’t settle the household query. It does say that, for now, the constructions round First Gen’s governance have held.
Beaver’s quiet cameo
The household was most seen within the assembly not when Piki answered the rift query, however within the final unscripted minute.
Simply because the chairman was about to adjourn, the company secretary introduced that two administrators had requested panelist entry to the web assembly. One in every of them was Manuel “Beaver” Lopez.
Beaver, who had additionally stayed off-screen for many of the assembly, is important another way: he sat on the First Gen board when the Prime Infra gasoline and hydropower offers had been mentioned and accepted, and he has since crossed the aisle within the household dispute, becoming a member of the bulk cousins’ camp that now questions those self same offers for regularity.
Piki acknowledged the request and referred to as on Beaver, giving him the ground.
Beaver unmuted, stated he had no questions, thanked the chair, and signed off. The assembly then wrapped. There have been no statements, no last-minute objections, no seen pressure on display.
The second is sort of comically anti-climactic, however it’s not nothing. A director aligned with the cousins’ majority quietly logged in to the ASM of the corporate his facet has been criticizing, was acknowledged by the cousin they tried to take away, and selected silence. It might have been a surveillance train, a gesture of normalcy in step with the formal withdrawal of the ouster decision, or just a examine that votes had been counted and the assembly had proceeded by the e book. It was most likely some mix of all three.
In a gathering the place the household battle surfaced solely in three sentences — the withdrawal of the ouster decision, his description of it as a ‘peace overture’ and ‘attainable first step,’ and his promise to maintain appearing as steward whereas remaining ‘absolutely ready for any end result’ — Beaver’s temporary cameo landed just like the rift in miniature: current, unresolved, and selecting, for that afternoon no less than, to not converse. – Rappler.com
Listed below are different articles on the Lopez cousins’ feud you might have missed:
https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/
https://www.rappler.com/enterprise/how-piki-lopez-answered-family-rift-question-annual-stockholders-meeting-may-28-2026/





