That is AI generated summarization, which can have errors. For context, all the time check with the complete article.
‘The Structure solely designated a particular presiding officer for the impeachment of a president… However it doesn’t say who will preside for all different trials,’ says UP legislation affiliate dean Paolo Tamase
It was no shock that Senator Chiz Escudero presided over Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial, given Senator Ping Lacson’s earlier pronouncement.
He was formally elected because the presiding officer through the trial’s opening on Monday, July 6.
However nonetheless, the senators from the minority bloc led by Cayetano siblings gave their all to dam his election. Senator Alan Peter Cayetano insisted that the Senate president — within the current case, Sherwin Gatchalian — ought to preside over Duterte’s impeachment trial, based mostly on the 1987 Structure.
He even cited information from the constitutional fee to argue his case.
However his argument is defective. Right here’s why.
What the Structure says
The difficulty of the impeachment presiding officer is important due to the ability he/she holds. The minority bloc would desire a presiding officer who could be advantageous to them, given their inclination towards the Vice President on trial.
A presiding officer mainly dictates the rhythm of an impeachment trial.
He/she is remitted to “make and situation, by himself or by the Secretary of the Senate, all orders, mandates, and writs approved by these guidelines or by the Senate, and to make and implement such different rules and orders within the premises because the Senate could authorize or present.” That is based mostly on the Senate’s impeachment rules.
Article XI, Part 3 of the 1987 Constitution explains how an impeachment ought to proceed.
A plain studying of Part 3’s paragraph 6 states: “When the President of the Philippines is on trial, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court docket shall preside, however shall not vote. No particular person shall be convicted with out the concurrence of two-thirds of all of the Members of the Senate.”
In different phrases, there was no particular rule that claims that solely a Senate President can preside over an impeachment trial, aside from a Chief Justice.
“My view is it’s not unconstitutional,” College of the Philippines Faculty of Regulation affiliate dean and constitutional legislation professor Paolo Tamase advised Rappler. “The Structure solely designated a particular presiding officer for the impeachment of a President, taking that from the US Structure. However it doesn’t say who will preside for all different trials.”
“If the Structure is obvious that it’s only when the President (is impeached) that the Chief Justice will preside and every thing else is open to the Senate and Impeachment Court docket, you observe the textual content as a result of the textual content of the Structure follows,” UP legislation professor and consitutional legislation professional John Molo mentioned in a Rappler interview.
Senate’s revised guidelines
“In actual fact, the Structure clearly supplies that the Senate shall ‘promulgate its guidelines on impeachment to successfully perform the aim of this part,’” Tamase defined.
Part 3 (8) of the 1987 Structure’s Article XI certainly states that the Congress — the Home of Representatives and the Senate — shall have its guidelines on impeachment “to successfully perform the aim of (the Article XI).”
As defined by Senate President Sherwin Gatchalian, the Senate additionally amended its impeachment guidelines to permit one other senator to preside over the trial, apart from the Senate president.
Senate Decision No. 48, adopted on June 3, made this modification potential.
“The president of the Senate shall preside in all different instances of impeachment except the Senate, by a majority vote of the members current, elects one other senator because the presiding officer,” the brand new rule says.
Traditionally, it’s both a chief justice or the Senate president who presides over an impeachment trial.
Former chief justice Hilario Davide Jr. presided over former president Joseph Estrada’s impeachment trial from December 2000 to January 2001.
Senate presidents presided over the impeachment that reached the Senate: former Senate president Juan Ponce Enrile in former chief justice Renato Corona’s trialand former Senate president Chiz Escudero in Duterte’s 2025 impeachment.
That is truly Escudero’s second time taking up the duty.
The primary one was controversial as a result of delays in the trial and the remanding of the articles of impeachment to the Home of Representatives which additional delayed the proceedings. The Supreme Court docket ultimately killed the 2025 impeachment after it dominated in favor of Duterte, discovering that the Home’s articles of impeachment had been unconstitutional. – Rappler.com
https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/
https://www.rappler.com/philippines/things-to-know-impeachment-presiding-officer-senate/




