MindaNews / 12 August 2026 — A state auditor testifying earlier than the Senate impeachment court docket maintained that the reviews submitted by the Workplace of the Vice President (OVP) and the Division of Schooling to the Fee on Audit (COA) weren’t sufficient to justify rewards funds from confidential funds.

Protection counsel Kristine Ferrer (R) cross-examines state auditor Xylene Mae del Campo earlier than the Senate impeachment court docket. Screenshot from the YouTube channel of the Philippine Senate

Throughout the cross-examination Wednesday by protection counsel Kristine Ferrer, Xylene Mae del Campo, state auditor of the Fee on Audit – Intelligence and Confidential Funds Audit Workplace, mentioned the reviews submitted by the places of work of Vice President Sara Duterte had been inadequate as proof exhibiting success of its information-gathering actions.

On Tuesday, upon questioning by personal prosecutor Lorna Kapunan, Del Campo testified that primarily based on the OVP’s protecting intelligence operations reviews, Duterte’s engagements from the primary to the third quarters of 2023 had been attendance in graduation workouts, tree planting actions, courtesy visits and coordination conferences.

She mentioned these functions are usually not compliant with Joint Round 2015-01, and there’s nothing within the accomplishment reviews that might warrant the fee of rewards.

Del Campo additionally testified Tuesday that the insufficiency of paperwork from the OVP led to a complete disallowance of ₱73 million.

The disallowed quantity covers ₱69.5 million for the fee of rewards for which the OVP solely submitted acknowledgment receipts. The remaining ₱3.5 million covers gadgets that weren’t enumerated below Joint Round 2015-01, similar to furnishings and computer systems, she mentioned.

Requested by Senator-judge and presiding officer Francis Escudero which funds had been disallowed, Del Campo clarified that solely the rewards funds require proof of success, not the fee for info.

She mentioned reward funds require an consequence like an arrest, as an example, whereas fee for info can cowl confidential operations that lead to no untoward incidents.

Del Campo repeatedly answered that some confidential expenditures had been disallowed as a result of these had been listed as rewards funds, however no arrests had been talked about. She mentioned what Duterte’s workplace had completed was fee for info as a substitute.

“There have been gadgets citing possible threats from the NPA, however what I’m in search of is proof of success, which is whether or not somebody was arrested, as a result of having no untoward incidents will fall below buy of knowledge.

“It may be mentioned that as a result of buy of knowledge, we had a scenario the place ‘there have been no untoward incidents’,” she defined in blended English and Filipino.

After Ferrer identified that the arrest requirement just isn’t specified within the joint round and Escudero sought clarification on it, Del Campo defined that it’s primarily based on her personal skilled judgment and on the hooked up paperwork of different businesses she audited which confirmed arrests to help rewards funds.

Ferrer directed Del Campo to a provision in a 1992 COA Round which states that requiring receipts or invoices for confidential operations would possibly endanger brokers and compromise missions. The state auditor agreed that the identical precept nonetheless applies to such operations.

Kapunan objected to Ferrer’s referencing to the 1992 round, which she mentioned has been outdated by Joint Round 2015-01.

Ferrer mentioned the joint round requires confidential fund disbursements to be supported with documentary proof of fee submitted in a sealed envelope, however doesn’t specify what sort of doc.

Requested by Escudero whether or not the joint round says the COA ought to demand receipts, Del Campo answered “no,” however added that the receipts requirement is predicated on one other merchandise of the round permitting auditors to require different supporting paperwork deemed vital for analysis.

Arguing it’s argumentative, Kapunan objected to Ferrer’s query of why the round didn’t merely spell out a receipts requirement. Escudero sustained the objection.

Later in the course of the cross, Del Campo discovered a chance to additional clarify that whereas acknowledgment receipts can stand as proof of fee of rewards and knowledge, purchases of things like furnishings require receipts to show that these had been actually purchased.

She added this commonplace applies not solely to the OVP and DepEd however to different businesses as nicely. (H. Marcos C. Mordeno / MindaNews)

https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/

https://mindanews.com/top-stories/2026/08/state-auditor-stands-firm-on-disallowed-confidential-expenses/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here