Below the doctrine, the prosecution should identify a ‘principal plunderer’ and show that the accused personally acquired or benefited from the stolen cash. Remulla’s interpretation of that: ‘The smarter the thief, the safer he’s.’

It’s already a 12 months since Jesus Crispin “Boying” Remulla was transferred from the helm of the Department of Justice to the Office of the Ombudsmantaking the accountability of submitting circumstances over the flood control corruption.

However in marking his first anniversary because the Ombudsman, Remulla on Monday, October 12, couldn’t assist however criticize the “principal plunderer” doctrine, which emerged from a Supreme Court docket ruling in 2016.

For him, that doctrine “stands in the way in which” of accountability and finally securing convictions.

Robust phrases from Remulla’s handle: “The anti-piracy legislation was created to carry accountable those that steal billions. However, on this doctrine, the largest syndicates are the toughest to catch.

“That is not justice. That is safety.”

(The legislation in opposition to plunder was legislated to carry accountable those that steal billions. However with this doctrine, the largest syndicate is the toughest to catch. That’s not justice, that’s a defend.)

The “principal plunderer” doctrine emerged from former president Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo’s SC case involving her alleged misuse of P366 million in confidential and intelligence funds of the Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Workplace. In 2012, then-ombudsman Conchita Carpio-Morales charged Arroyo with plunder.

The 2016 SC determination, penned by then-justice Lucas Bersamin, acquitted Arroyo and granted her release. (Bersamin turned President Ferdinand Marcos Jr.’s government secretary, resigning in November 2025.)

Remulla mentioned that the SC ruling learn into the Republic Act No. 7080 or the Anti-Plunder Act two necessities “that Congress by no means wrote.”

The prosecution should identify a “principal plunderer” and show that the accused personally acquired or benefited from the stolen cash.

Remulla’s interpretation of that: “The smarter the thief, the safer he’s.”

“Move the cash by way of sufficient dummies, middlemen, and shell firms, and nobody might be proven to have touched it,” he mentioned. He famous that such a scheme is current within the flood management controversy.


Why Ombudsman Remulla thinks it’s important for SC to reverse ‘main plunderer’ doctrine

Remulla’s comment got here after he reported that 39 flood control cases have been filed with the anti-graft court docket Sandiganbayan and regional courts.

And because the Workplace of the Ombudsman already achieved the “hardest half” of constructing circumstances, the subsequent chapter lies with the courts, which they count on to be “neutral, impartial, and attuned to the occasions.”

Remulla has repeatedly talked about the hurdle set by the “principal plunderer” doctrine.

In 2016, four justices dissented with the SC ruling to acquit Arroyo, together with the introduction of two extra components within the prosecution of plunder. For them, it was a “harmful precedent.”

Among the many dissenters, Justice Marvic Leonen wrote again then: “In doing so, this Court docket units itself upon the course of encroaching on Congress’ plenary energy to make legal guidelines. It additionally denies the State the chance to adequately current its case. Likewise, it unwittingly licenses essentially the most crafty plunderers to prey upon public funds with impunity. This isn’t what the Anti-Plunder Legislation intends.”

“So I say this with all due respect to the Supreme Court docket: it’s time to revisit this doctrine. It’s time to revisit it,” Remulla mentioned in his first annual handle.

(I say this with full respect to the Excessive Court docket: It’s time to revisit this doctrine.)

For now, the Excessive Court docket can solely act when a case involves their desk.

Lawmakers can even move laws that may successfully abolish the doctrine. (However will we truly count on them to make such a transfer?)

What’s sure for now’s the Ombudsman is making an attempt to ship alerts to the nation’s judiciary. Are these alerts being acquired? – Rappler.com

https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/

https://www.rappler.com/newsbreak/inside-track/why-ombudsman-remulla-wants-revisit-main-plunderer-doctrine/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here