MindaNews / 26 February – Each election season within the Bangsamoro, the identical stories emerge. Datus negotiating bloc votes. Liberation teams directing their constituencies. Entire communities arriving on the polls having already determined collectively. COMELEC and worldwide observers notice the violations. The language is all the time the identical: voter intimidation, undue affect, compromised secrecy of the poll.

The stories are correct. The framing is incorrect.

What they’re describing is just not a pathology. It’s the Bangsamoro’s political structure working precisely because it was constructed—simply by means of channels that our electoral system refuses to acknowledge.

Two sorts of authority, one voting sales space

Within the Bangsamoro, political company has by no means been purely particular person. It operates by means of a minimum of two layers of collective authority that exist lengthy earlier than anybody enters a polling precinct.

The primary is conventional authority. When a datu takes a political place, it’s not often a unilateral resolution. It follows dialogue inside the clan—session amongst elders, negotiation with allied households, calculation of what serves the group’s survival and bargaining energy in a political system that rewards consolidation. The group aligns not merely out of worry, however as a result of fragmenting the clan vote has actual prices in a world the place safety, land, and assets are nonetheless negotiated collectively.

The second is revolutionary authority. The MILF and the MNLF are usually not exterior political events that confirmed as much as inform communities the best way to vote. For his or her constituencies, these organizations are the organized expression of the Bangsamoro’s personal aspirations for self-determination—constructed by means of a long time of shared sacrifice, displacement, and wrestle. When the motion takes a place, it carries an ethical weight that goes past instruction. It’s a group chatting with itself by means of the establishment it created.

Drive each of those underground by insisting on the secrecy of the person poll, and you don’t eradicate their affect. You make them much less seen, much less accountable, and extra simply captured by whoever holds probably the most leverage—whether or not that may be a real group chief or a warlord sporting a pacesetter’s garments.

Rido by one other title

Right here is the deeper downside. Aggressive elections, as presently designed, map political battle instantly onto clan and group identification with no mediating construction. They create winners and losers in a society the place these distinctions have traditionally triggered rido—clan feuding that doesn’t keep within the poll field.

Add to this that the liberation motion is just not one bloc. The MILF and MNLF have by no means been unified, and the factions inside every carry completely different political pursuits and territorial loyalties. When a number of collective authorities ship competing alerts to overlapping constituencies, the person voter is just not exercising free alternative. They’re caught within the crossfire of communal obligations, with no institutional mechanism to resolve the stress earlier than it turns into a physique rely.

We all know this sample. It repeats each election cycle. And each cycle, we design the subsequent election as if we don’t.

The trustworthy center floor

None of that is an argument for merely accepting how issues are. Datus can and do silence girls, youth, and lower-status group members within the title of consensus. Liberation group endorsements can cross from ethical authority into coercion when backed by armed capability. Custom is all the time weak to seize by those that presently wield it.

However allow us to be equally trustworthy concerning the various. Remoted particular person voters within the Bangsamoro are topic to the identical pressures—by means of land dependency, financial leverage, and the specter of social exclusion—simply by means of channels that our stories don’t flag as “voter intimidation” as a result of they’re much less seen.

Three issues price attempting

Fairly than one other spherical of the identical argument, listed here are three concrete proposals price debating.

Regulate bloc voting as a substitute of criminalizing it. Legally acknowledge collective political deliberation as a legitimate type of democratic participation—on the situation that the method is open, documented, and inclusive of girls and youth. Whenever you formalize it, you may maintain it accountable. Coercion then turns into unlawful not as a result of the group voted collectively, however as a result of the inner deliberation excluded its personal members.

Give liberation teams formal constituency standing. The MILF and MNLF train actual political authority over actual constituencies. Bringing that authority into a proper, accountable framework—as constituency organizations with rights and tasks—is much less harmful than leaving it casual and opaque. Former armed teams in different post-conflict settings have been given structured political roles as a part of peace structure. There’s precedent. There’s a logic.

Construct a Bangsamoro Electoral Council with enamel. COMELEC was not designed for the Bangsamoro’s political sociology. A Bangsamoro-specific electoral oversight physique—with datu representatives, liberation motion members, and profession election officers—might adapt procedures to native circumstances, mediate disputes earlier than they flip violent, and validate group deliberation processes. Not a alternative for COMELEC. A translation layer.

None of those proposals are snug. All of them will face opposition from Manila and from those that consider any lodging of collective authority concedes an excessive amount of to warlordism. These objections deserve severe debate.

However the query we maintain avoiding is that this: if our electoral mannequin gives no legit channel for collective political company in a communitarian society, why are we stunned when that company routes itself by means of channels we can not see or regulate?

The person secret poll is a software, not a commandment. The Bangsamoro deserves a democratic system constructed for the society it really is—not the one our electoral templates assumed it will be.

The writer has labored in peace and battle within the Bangsamoro for over 20 years.

https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/

https://mindanews.com/mindaviews/2026/02/commentary-stop-calling-it-voter-intimidation/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here