DAVAO CITY (MindaNews / 19 November 2026) – Senator-judges reduce brief the protection crew’s presentation of video clips of the late Senator Miriam Defensor-Santiago and Chief Justice Renato Corona, arguing that statements made within the 2011 impeachment trial are “immaterial and irrelevant” to the present proceedings in opposition to Vice President Sara Duterte.
Through the resumption of the impeachment proceedings on Thursday, Senator-Choose Erwin Tulfo informed the protection to let the “deceased relaxation in peace,” questioning the relevance of exhibiting their clips.
Tulfo identified that the Duterte impeachment trial is a totally completely different case from the 2011 impeachment trial in opposition to Corona, noting that it entails a distinct set of senator-judges.
Apart from these clips, the protection crew additionally performed a video of a speech by former President Rodrigo R. Duterte, the place he rejects the concept of impeaching then-Vice President Leni Robredo.
By presenting the clips, significantly of Corona, protection counsel Mark Vinluan framed his argument across the alleged weaponization of the Anti-Cash Laundering Council (AMLC) in opposition to Duterte within the guise of monetary investigation and the prohibition on political harassment beneath Part 16 of the Anti-Cash Laundering Act.
Impeachment, Vinluan pressured, isn’t solely authorized but additionally political.
“We’ve already realized at this level that an impeachment isn’t purely a authorized continuing. There’s a political side to it, and I feel, Your Honor, we’ve been prudent in laying the idea for our questions. Once more, Your Honor, we ask for a bit leeway for the protection,” he mentioned.
Within the video, Santiago, one of many three senator-judges who voted to acquit Corona, chastised the prosecution panel’s method of presenting their proof in opposition to the respondent.
In a separate clip, Corona recounted the ordeal of going through the impeachment court docket and the way the proceedings tarnished his and his household’s status.
Corona was impeached for his failure to correctly declare property in his assertion of property, liabilities, and web price, Senator-Choose Raffy Tulfo identified.
Home prosecutor Chel Diokno mentioned he didn’t see the relevance of presenting the statements made by Corona in his personal impeachment trial, besides that “it’s an enchantment to the emotion that I imagine has no place within the impeachment trial.”
“No matter query requested could be immaterial and irrelevant and would represent rumour as a result of we will’t even cross-examine the late Chief Justice Corona on his statements, and it will be deceptive as a result of there isn’t any such proof of persecution on this case earlier than the court docket,” Diokno mentioned.
Senator-Choose Risa Hontiveros mentioned the presentation of those clips was “unfair,” significantly to the impeachment court docket.
“The 2 people (Santiago and Corona) proven have already handed away, and the third one (Duterte) isn’t right here, so we, the senator-judges, can’t converse to any of them. Simply to specific, Mr. Presiding Officer, this sort of state of affairs isn’t honest. It isn’t honest both to the three individuals whose movies had been proven, neither is it honest to this Senate impeachment court docket,” Hontiveros mentioned.
Senator-Choose Panfilo “Ping” Lacson mentioned he didn’t see the importance of highlighting the lone opinion of Santiago, who was simply one of many 24 senator-judges from the 2011 impeachment trial of Corona.
For his half, Senator-Choose Alan Peter Cayetano requested the impeachment court docket to offer the protection some leeway within the presentation of their proof because the prosecution panel was given time to current their very own witnesses, even proof for withdrawn impeachment articles.
“Usually, I agree with the ruling and statement of the presiding officer. I don’t suppose there’s a disagreement there, however I’d ask for some latitude for the protection for a easy cause that the prosecution was given a lot time presenting grave threats, presenting completely different articles,” he mentioned. (Antonio L. Colina IV / MindaNews)
https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/
https://mindanews.com/top-stories/2026/11/defense-questioned-for-presenting-immaterial-and-irrelevant-video-clips/



