My first job title was marketing coordinator at a young Zappos.com. There I oversaw a ridiculous number of proposals and initiatives, from affiliate marketing to early pay-per-click to sky typing and print magazines. We had a little luck with earned media (thanks, Tony Winders), but as far as I remember we never bought pay TV or print media. (The big exception was a digital billboard on the 101, which Tony Hsieh apparently set up for the owner, annoyed at not being featured as a nationally known brand.)
In my opinion, the glossy magazines had a particularly absurd suggestion. You took into account the likely inflated circulation of the magazine, then you assumed that everyone read every single page, then you assumed that the subscriber passed the magazine on to four other people who also read every single page, and then you calculated a ridiculously high CPM. And name-calling? Good luck.
Maybe there was a dedicated phone number. Occasionally there was a dedicated landing page. However, most of the time there was no reliable way to tie a sale to the ad.
While Affiliate is pressured by last-click attribution, you could say that the walled gardens are driven by any-click attribution. Or, hell, any look that came within ten feet of the screen and turned into a click. The partner must prove that a click took place. The platforms are increasingly asking advertisers to trust statistical models that say a sale has been influenced. This is what Wall Street calls “grading your own homework” and uses it to justify oversized budgets. In contrast, Affiliate is based on a deterministic chain that can be easily broken in the zero-click era.
But what if we could play their game? Here’s my suggestion: Using the next generation of tracking technologies now available with Partnerize and Impact.com, for example, affiliate reporting regularly includes two numbers: deterministic tracking (clicks, coupons, etc.) and a contribution or influence number (AI inference, other touchpoints not listed).
Presumably the latter will typically be larger than the former, probably several times larger based on various case studies published over the last year or more. If it’s the other way around, as one might imagine, it doesn’t matter.
This shows advertisers that, in a sense, they are getting more than they pay for. Unfortunately, the immediate reaction to be expected will not be a relaxation of budget plans. Call tracking identified conversions that advertisers had already achieved but were not attributed to marketing channels. When I had an agency many years ago, we suggested RingRevenue (now Invoca) to some of our clients who took large orders over the phone.
The suggestion was met with more or less a shrug or even a laugh – so why pay for what you get for free? The partners had no leverage or were completely unaware of what could be considered leaked commissions.
However, if this contribution number were regularly shared with partners, they would be in a better negotiating position. Perhaps more importantly, the same standard could be applied to other advertising channels that regularly receive full credit for derivative sales. This would put affiliate marketing on par with channels that routinely claim credit for sales they can only tap into.
Create your very own Auto Publish News/Blog Site and Earn Passive Income in Just 4 Easy Steps



