Every few years, rights holders are given the opportunity to tell the European Commission which pirate sites and services deserve a place on its counterfeit and piracy watchlist.
The focus of these submissions has traditionally been on torrent sites, cyberlockers and IPTV pirate services. However, in recent editions, intermediaries such as hosting companies and Cloudflare have also been added.
LaLiga is taking this growing reach a step further. In its submission for the 2027 edition, the Spanish Football League calls for the inclusion of NordVPN, ProtonVPN, ExpressVPN and Surfshark.
The 14-page filing targets a wide range of websites and services, including traditional piracy threats, but the VPN space is new. The league notes that it is not concerned with the technology itself, but with the way these providers are marketed by others through their partner programs.
“The behavior that takes these services beyond neutral technical provision is the deliberate marketing of circumvention, carried out at arm’s length through partner programs,” writes LaLiga.
Geo-unblocking free football broadcasts
LaLiga explains that publishers and influencers with affiliate deals will publish updated guides for the 2026/27 season showing how to watch their football matches for free via these VPNs. On these pages, the providers are ranked and referenced to discounted subscriptions. At the same time, you receive a commission for the resulting sales.
Some of these guides indicate that football fans can use VPNs to bypass geo-blocking and watch free or cheap broadcasts in other countries. This is not related to pirate streams, but LaLiga points out that it affects the territorial exclusivity of its licensing agreements.
“the loss of neutrality”

Instructions like this are not hard to find. We came across several Spanish-language sites updated for the new season that recommend connecting to a foreign VPN server to stream games abroad for free.
These recommendations are published by partners, not by the VPN providers themselves. LaLiga’s statement does not claim that the providers write the guides themselves, but rather argues that the providers benefit from them.
Bypassing pirate site blocks
In addition to circumventing geoblocking, the filing also flags guides that they believe pose a more serious problem. These are affiliate sites that identify pirate streaming sites and services and explain that a VPN can bypass court-ordered site blocking measures.
LaLiga says anyone can review this affiliate marketing activity, but the submission does not name or link to any individual guide or influencer who crosses a line.
LaLiga says the publishers behind the guides are not always independent and link review site vpnMentor to Kape Technologies, which owns several VPN services.
“Guideline publishers are in some cases not independent. Within any of the above-mentioned corporate groups, VPN review and ranking publications are owned by the same people as the products they evaluate, a relationship that these publications disclose,” the filing says.
There is no mention of which of these publications contain the guides described by LaLiga.
independence

The filing also argues that some VPN providers have released marketing materials aligned with their gaming calendar. This is not supported by examples, but in February a Spanish court in Cordoba reached a similar conclusion when it issued a unilateral site blocking order against ProtonVPN and NordVPN.
Without hearing from the VPN providers, the court reportedly concluded that both NordVPN and ProtonVPN were actively promoting their ability to circumvent geographic restrictions by citing game plans in their marketing materials, while also labeling the VPNs as active participants in the piracy chain.
The matter has not yet been resolved. In May, the same court declined to fine NordVPN for non-compliance, acknowledging that the destination IP addresses of the pirate streams changed frequently. The main proceedings are still ongoing.
The VPN technology is fine
LaLiga is calling on the Commission to list the four providers because they allegedly facilitate access to blocked pirate sites and services. The league emphasizes that it is not targeting the technology itself.
“This request is not based on the provision of VPN services as such, but on the commercial use and active promotion of their ability to circumvent court-ordered blocking measures,” writes LaLiga.
The submission also begins with a disclaimer. “This statement does not establish any legal liability towards the companies mentioned,” it says.
The main accusation relates to the aspect of affiliate advertising, without providing any concrete evidence. It remains to be seen whether this will be enough for the EU Commission, especially since it is still controversial in court and in the legislature whether VPN providers should be obliged to implement blocking orders.
AFTVnews Downloader Short Codes
VPNs aren’t the only general-purpose tools in LaLiga’s statement. The league is also targeting AFTVnews Downloader, a popular app for Fire TV and Android TV devices that allows users to download files by entering a URL or numeric shortcode.
LaLiga says it has cataloged 341 of these codes, 262 of which led to pirate apps. The league describes the codes as a curated catalog that is under the operator’s “exclusive editorial control.”
“The ease and simplicity with which applications can be discovered and installed through this catalog is a testament to its nature as an editorially curated platform, distinct from the underlying distribution infrastructure,” writes LaLiga.
AFTVnews, which has more than 100 million users, describes the codes as “generated by the AFTVnews URL Shortener,” suggesting they were created from user-submitted links.
Downloader

The downloader has been targeted before. In 2023, Google removed the app from its Play Store after complaints from Israeli television networks and again after a DMCA notice from Markscan. The app was later reactivated.
Whether the commission will mention Downloader or any of the four VPN providers in its 2027 piracy watchlist remains to be seen. The latest 2025 counterfeit and piracy watchlist did not include VPN services, but did mention various hosting providers, IPFS, and domain name privacy service Njalla.
—
Update: AFTVnews’ Elias Saba shared the following response with us after publication.
“LaLiga’s description of the AFTVnews URL Shortener as a ‘curated catalog’ is incorrect. My Downloader app is a general-purpose web browser and file downloader; shortcodes simply save users from entering full URLs. Anyone can submit a URL, and the service automatically generates an active shortcode and a short URL without editorial review or approval. Neither Downloader nor the URL Shortener provide code directories, code recommendations, or a way to search or search for codes search.”
“I do not tolerate copyright infringement and have never promoted it through my news site, apps or URL shortener. I accept copyright removal requests for shortened URLs, promptly disable codes and shortened URLs in response to valid notices, and block re-shortening of reported target URLs. I have not seen the referenced notice from LaLiga or the codes identified therein. I will contact LaLiga about both so that I can promptly address the reported links. I will also submit a response to the European Commission to correct the description of my app and services.
—
A copy of LaLiga’s submission to the European Commission can be found here (PDF).
We reached out to ProtonVPN, the VPN Trust Initiative, for comment, but they did not respond prior to publication.
Disclosure: TorrentFreak uses VPN affiliate links, but not in a bypass context.
Create your very own Auto Publish News/Blog Site and Earn Passive Income in Just 4 Easy Steps



