Davao Metropolis dominated the Senate’s impeachment trial this week. Vice President Sara Duterte’s protection offered its first witnesses. Many witnesses and information traced again to Mindanao.

The trial resumed November 9 after a month-long recess. Solely Article II stays, masking alleged unexplained wealth. It additionally cites undisclosed property and undivested enterprise pursuits. Prosecutors dropped the three different articles in October. Hearings ran from November 9 to November 12.

The week gave the protection its first actual likelihood. Its attorneys might lastly reply the prosecution’s wealth allegations. Duterte had refused to debate the fees intimately publicly. Her group plans to name 24 witnesses in whole.

The courtroom additionally reaffirmed its November 6 proof ruling. It admitted related financial institution, tax, company and property information. Proof on the three withdrawn articles stays excluded.

The courtroom additionally restored its sub judice rule. It now covers all 4 articles of impeachment. That features the three articles prosecutors withdrew. Coated events can’t publicly talk about the case’s deserves. The hearings then turned to Duterte’s residence area.

Davao and Samal property information underneath scrutiny

On Monday, the protection known as Davao Metropolis assessor Jaime Adalin. He mentioned a 379-square-meter lot in Matina Crossing. The property is linked to husband Manases Carpio. Her SALN reportedly put its acquisition price at ₱10 million.
The deed of sale confirmed solely ₱6 million. Senator-judges additionally famous an area political hyperlink. Adalin turned assessor whereas Duterte was Davao Metropolis mayor.

The courtroom additionally questioned his familiarity with the property. The protection insisted the lot appeared in her SALN. The important thing difficulty went past whether or not it was declared. Senators wished to know if its particulars had been reported precisely. Constant reporting of its valuation additionally mattered.

Tuesday’s listening to moved throughout the gulf to Samal. Samal Metropolis assessor John Kenneth Enumerables defined property information. The Island Backyard Metropolis of Samal lies off Davao Metropolis. Some paperwork positioned the lot in Barangay Matanos.
Others positioned it in Barangay San Isidro. Metropolis tax maps listing no Barangay Matanos, he stated. The dates additionally didn’t match.

The deed of sale indicated a 2018 buy. Her 2025 SALN reportedly listed 2013 as a substitute. That leaves a five-year hole within the document. The hole raised questions concerning the disclosure’s accuracy. Neither assessor absolutely cleared up the discrepancies.

Davao enterprise ties draw constitutional questions

Wednesday introduced the week’s most consequential testimony. Lawyer Suzette Balucanag-Punay represents GenCorp and Metro Metropolis Chow Meals. She described Duterte’s unfastened funding in a Davao Jollibee department. Duterte obtained about ₱2.14 million from 2022 to 2025.

The corporate known as the funds a return of capital. Punay stated Duterte was not a GenCorp shareholder. Her title is absent from GenCorp’s Common Info Sheets.
She couldn’t produce a written settlement, nevertheless. No doc confirmed the unique quantity or compensation phrases. The unique funding reportedly went to Davao Bounty Instances Company. But the funds got here from GenCorp. Senators requested what authorized foundation linked the 2 companies.

Senator Francis Pangilinan pressed Punay on this level. How might Duterte obtain funds with out taking part in GenCorp? Senator Raffy Tulfo raised a associated query. Had been these returns of capital or funding earnings?

Senator Sherwin Gatchalian raised a sharper Davao concern. GenCorp reportedly received about ₱33 million in metropolis contracts. These got here whereas her brother Sebastian Duterte was mayor.

Punay additionally confirmed Duterte’s 20-percent stake in Metro Metropolis Chow. Duterte sat as director there from 2022 to 2025. She additionally served on its compensation committee. Punay insisted she took no lively administration function. Article VII, Part 13 restricts such pursuits for high officers.

The availability covers the President and Vice President. It limits their enterprise engagements and monetary pursuits. The contracts tie the difficulty on to Davao Metropolis Corridor. Davao Metropolis has been led by Dutertes for many years.

Spending, financial institution witnesses, and what lies forward

Thursday centered on spending on Carpio’s bank card. Household buddy Anel Antero described a dinner in Japan. It concerned the couple’s regulation college pals.

He stated he repaid Carpio about 40,000 yen. That equals round ₱16,000. He couldn’t firmly recall a ₱580,000 remittance in 2020. One other witness, Chadrin Parian, testified on sports activities spending. Parian stated Carpio spent ₱256,000 on footwear for gamers.

The footwear adopted a championship match in Malaysia. Crew members’ dad and mom additionally obtained pairs. Prosecutors requested if this match RA 6713’s modest-living customary. Senators Pia Cayetano and Robin Padilla pushed again.

They questioned scrutiny of a guardian rewarding younger athletes. Senator Juan Miguel Zubiri urged a special focus. Zubiri, a former Bukidnon congressman, cited Cale88 Meals Company.

The agency is a declared asset of Carpio. It allegedly obtained over ₱300 million in international remittances. The protection additionally dropped all 16 financial institution witnesses Thursday. It first withdrew 15, citing the necessity for velocity. It then disbursed with BPI’s Paul Roderick Ysmael.

The protection stated his letter on the accounts was established. This limits prosecutors’ likelihood to probe information by way of them. The protection has but to rebut the central determine. Prosecution skilled Alexander Cabrera pegged unexplained wealth at ₱817.87 million.

Protection attorneys have up to now defined transactions one after the other. They’ve supplied no full reconciliation of her funds. A number of witnesses additionally lacked paperwork or agency solutions.

For Mindanao, the trial carries explicit weight. Her strongest political base lies in Davao and Mindanao. She is broadly seen as a 2028 presidential contender. A conviction would take away her and bar her from workplace. Marcos would then nominate a substitute from Congress.

Prosecutors now want 14 votes to convict. A September ruling lowered the brink from 16. 4 senator-judges can’t take part due to authorized instances. Former President Rodrigo Duterte stays detained at The Hague.

His ICC trial for crimes in opposition to humanity opens November 30. Sara Duterte additionally faces a separate legal case. It issues alleged threats in opposition to Marcos and his household.

Extra classes are set for November 19, 20 and 23. The ASEAN Summit pauses hearings from November 16 to 18. Price range deliberations may even compete for senators’ time.

Presiding Officer Chiz Escudero says it might finish by December.

(Dean Antonio Gabriel La Viña is from Cagayan de Oro and is a professor of regulation, philosophy, politics, governance in a number of universities, together with in Mindanao. He was previously Dean of the Ateneo College of Authorities and is presently the pinnacle of Klima Middle of Manila Observatory. Dean Tony has been a human rights lawyer for 36 years. He’s presently the managing associate of La Viña Zarate and Associates, a member of the Everlasting Court docket of Arbitration in The Hague, and Chair of the Jurisprudence and Authorized Philosophy Division of the Philippine Judicial Academy. Dean Tony is founding president of the Motion In opposition to Disinformation and the founding chair of the Mindanao Local weather Justice Useful resource Facility. He’s the Vice-Chair of the Board of Trustees of the Samdhana Institute.)

https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/

https://mindanews.com/mindaviews/2026/11/a-mindanawons-impeachment-diary-davao-records-take-center-stage/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here