On the downstream of Cebu’s Cotcot River, the Division of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) Cebu fifth District Engineering Workplace (DEO) initiated a multimillion-peso flood management venture meant to guard residents in Sitio Sulima, Barangay Cotcot, Liloan throughout extreme flooding situations.
It didn’t throughout 2025’s Storm Tino (Kalmaegi) onslaught.
The stated venture was initiated on February 16, 2024, and was accomplished on December 26, 2024. For a complete contract price of P96.4 million, the DPWH Cebu fifth DEO constructed an embankment, arrange a sidewalk, and put in solar-powered road lights.
This venture was awarded to St. Matthew Gen. Contractor & Improvement Corp. and MC Geometric Proportions Inc. St. Matthew is owned by the Discayas — among the many nation’s most infamous authorities contractors, who are actually dealing with malversation circumstances.
Curlee Discaya is dealing with a malversation case for his involvement within the anomalous launch of P53.9 million for a flood management venture in Calumpit, Bulacan. Sarah Discaya was additionally named within the criticism however is at present dealing with a separate malversation case stemming from a P96-million ghost project in Davao Occidental.
Based mostly on the contract awarded to them, the job was easy: construct an embankment with a pathway on the facet and put up road lights so residents can see the place they’re going at evening.
The place did it falter? It ignored a quite simple design that engineering consultants commissioned by the DPWH, supported by the Japan Worldwide Cooperation Company (JICA) in 2017, had made to enhance the world’s drainage — a diversion channel, particularly in Sitio Sulima.
The absence of the diversion channel manifested in an overflow of the embankment throughout Storm Tino, as particles piled up on the singular water path, unable to search out different exit factors.
“Gathered there after (the flood). There are nonetheless homes, animals,” Sulima resident Lourile Amaro instructed Rappler on Might 21. (All of it piled up there when the floodwaters handed by. There have been homes, animals.)
The design for the diversion channel was among the many advisable flood management interventions specified by the Metro Cebu Built-in Flood and Drainage System Grasp Plan (MCIFDSMP), or generally known as the “Metro Cebu flood management grasp plan.“
In 2012, the Metro Cebu Improvement and Coordinating Board, responding to the rising circumstances of flooding all through the metropolitan areas, requested the DPWH for help in making a flood management grasp plan. This later grew to become the grasp plan commissioned by DPWH in 2017 and was one of many precedence initiatives below the JICA-led 2013 Roadmap Examine for Sustainable Improvement of Metro Cebu.
From 2017 to the current, most of the designs specified by the Metro Cebu flood management grasp plan have been left unrealized, and the Discaya venture was just one out of a whole lot.
Rappler took an additional take a look at contracts and paperwork to know how the Discaya venture was accepted and why it ended up deviating from the grasp plan.
P96-million venture
The venture in query, Contract ID No. 24HI0014, coated 620 meters downstream of the Cotcot River, and was accepted by DPWH Cebu fifth District Engineer Ma. Jannet Nero.
On September 1, 2025, technical workers from the DPWH Cebu fifth DEO inspected the venture and issued a Discover of Defects when chipped plaster was discovered on the venture website.
The venture was accomplished on December 26, 2024. Which means that a faulty portion of the flood management venture was recognized lower than a 12 months after it was completed.
Engineer Grezel Savariz of the DPWH Cebu fifth DEO, nonetheless, instructed Rappler on June 2, 2026, that the defect was thought-about solely minor and was led to by excessive temperatures that induced the plaster to crumble.
Savariz stated the venture was designed to have a walkway for residents on prime of the embankment. When requested why there have been no fences to forestall accidents, the engineer stated that it was not included within the planning and design stage.
A fast take a look at the contract settlement confirmed that P1.3 million was additionally allotted for the acquisition of 13 solar-powered LED street lamp posts.

Proposed options from the Metro Cebu Grasp Plan, nonetheless, by no means included photo voltaic panels or pathways alongside the river’s downstream.
Yumi Espina, an architect-engineer and environmental planner, instructed Rappler that the enforcement of a three-meter easement ought to have been prioritized within the space over the set up of road lights and a pathway.
Underneath the Water Code of the Philippines (Presidential Decree 1067), the minimal distance from rivers that ought to stay clear of personal buildings is three meters.
“What’s using the photo voltaic road lights? If there isn’t a easement, it might even invite extra settlers to occupy the easement,” Espina stated.

The Metro Cebu Built-in Flood and Drainage System Grasp Plan advisable {that a} diversion channel be made downstream of the Cotcot River to enhance the waterway’s drainage capability.
The diversion channel, designed to have a shorter alignment of 650 meters to lower than 200 meters, would supposedly facilitate drainage of the Cotcot River, however no such construction stands on the venture website, as of this writing.
Sulima resident Angelyn Cabatingan whose home was proper subsequent to the Discaya-linked flood management venture instructed Rappler that the water from the venture overflowed throughout Storm Tino and the embankment partitions have been punctured by the flood waters and particles, leaving fissures throughout the revetments.
Through the Tino onslaught, Cabatingan watched her home get flogged by pounding winds and rainfall, inflicting the again portion to offer method. She was nonetheless luckier than her neighbors, who needed to climb onto the roofs of their properties for security and watch their garments get washed away by the torrent.
No less than 11,322 houses have been broken in Liloan and greater than 12,000 residents have been left homeless and compelled to remain in evacuation shelters. To today, greater than 2,000 residents within the city stay displaced.

“It is extremely harmful so long as it rains (It’s terrifying at any time when it rains),” Cabatingan stated.
However that’s not all. The DPWH Central Visayas workplace awarded a P149-million flood management venture to MC Geometric Proportion and the Discayas by Alpha & Omega Normal Contractor & Improvement Company.
The venture was for an embankment on the upstream partition of the Cotcot River. It was initiated in April 2024 and accomplished in March 2025.
On November 16, 2025, ICI Particular Adviser and Investigator Rodolfo Azurin Jr., together with DPWH officers, inspected flood management initiatives in Cebu, and confirmed that this upstream venture, amongst others, didn’t comply with Metro Cebu’s grasp plan for flood management and drainage techniques.

Forgotten grasp plan
Even when the infrastructure initiatives had been achieved correctly, they might not have survived The catastrophic flooding unleashed by Storm Tino, in line with Maria Nenita Jumao-as, director of the College of San Carlos-Water Assets Middle.
“I want to imagine that if (the Cebu grasp plan initiatives) have been applied the way in which they have been speculated to be applied, then we might have much less injury and fewer lack of human life,” stated DPWH Secretary Vince Dizon, in a ONE Information interview in November 2025.
Dizon’s assertion was based mostly on the ICI’s evaluation of flood management initiatives in Cebu.
In an unique interview with Rappler, Cebu Vice Governor Glenn Soco stated that the grasp plan was supposedly adopted by the Regional Improvement Council in 2017. However he added that Cebu’s flood mitigation failures stem from a fragmented system stricken by bureaucratic disconnects and inflexible monetary frameworks.
That is compounded by the Duterte-era cash budgeting systemhe stated. Underneath the money budgeting system, LGUs are given a finances implementation interval of 1 12 months, with an prolonged cost interval of three months after the fiscal 12 months.
Soco stated that they may not apply the money budgeting system to initiatives like relocation and flood management initiatives as these normally take multiple fiscal 12 months, forcing them to return the funds to the nationwide treasury earlier than finishing the venture.
In September 2022, then-DPWH Central Visayas Regional Director Ernesto Gregorio Jr. instructed the Cebu Provincial Board that the grasp plan was given a finances of P44 billion in 2018 and an implementation interval of 10 years. On the time in 2022, only P1.8 billion had been used for the implementation of the plan.
“I feel what has occurred is that as an alternative of a unified method to deal with flooding in line with the grasp plan, it has develop into a ‘piecemeal’ (method) on a per district workplace stage,” the Vice Governor added.
In response to Engineer Jose Renee Miole of the DPWH Cebu fifth DEO, it falls below the DPWH’s accountability to provide designs for flood management initiatives alongside the Cotcot River.

In November 2025, within the aftermath of Tino, the DPWH secretary announced that his division would be certain to implement the grasp plan.
As of June 2, nonetheless, DPWH Cebu fifth DEO stated they’ve but to obtain a replica of the Metro Cebu Built-in Flood and Drainage System Grasp Plan.
As plans to implement the advisable interventions within the 2017 Cebu grasp plan are nonetheless elusive, what stays clear is that it is just a matter of time earlier than residents are but once more left to fend for themselves when Tino-like downpours strike the province as soon as extra.
“We’re scared and traumatized…they must do these flood management initiatives proper this time in order that form of flood by no means occurs once more,” Cabatingan stated. – Rappler.com
*Some quotes have been translated into English for brevity
Reporting for this story was supported by Internews’ Earth Journalism Community (EJN) below the Excessive Climate within the Philippines Investigative Reporting Fellowship
https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/
https://www.rappler.com/newsbreak/investigative/cotcot-river-structural-errors-discaya-flood-control-cebu/



