Senate minority bloc members on the Senate Plenary Corridor on June 2, 2026. (Sen. Risa Hontiveros through Fb)

Previous attendance information of senators throughout periods with a quorum of 12 members had been offered amid arguments over the variety of senators required for such a declaration.

A quorum was declared within the higher chamber on Wednesday, June 3, after Sen. Chiz Escuderowho had been out of the general public eye following his alleged involvement within the flood management scandal, appeared within the Senate.

With 12 senators current, the Senate resumed its session after two consecutive days of failing to convene because of the absence of senators from the bloc, led by Sen. Alan Peter Cayetano.

A roll name was carried out, a quorum was declared and all chamber positions had been declared vacant, clearing the best way for the reorganization.

Sen. Sherwin Gatchalian was elected Senate President Professional Tempore, serving as appearing Senate President.

Senate committees additionally had new chairpersons elected following the reorganization.

The transfer drew criticism from some members of the Alan Peter-led bloc, similar to Sen. Pia Cayetanowho questioned the validity of the June 3 session.

“When did 12 equals 13? So at this time, when 12 senators convened and purportedly held session, how can that be legitimate? 12 is just not 13. Alam ng Grade 1 scholar ‘yan,” she stated in a statement.

Sen. Vicente “Titus” Beneath IIIa former Senate Minority Chief who additionally served as Senate President thrice, responded.

“When does 13 turn into 12? It’s when 24 turns into 22!” he wrote on social media in response to Pia.

An online user defined the figures, saying that 24 turns into 22 when two is subtracted from 24.

The web consumer added that 24, when divided by two, turns into 12.

There have been 12 senators within the plenary corridor on Tuesday, June 2, following Escudero’s look, and the quantity was ample for a quorum to be declared.

A quorum is the minimal variety of senators required for the Senate to formally conduct enterprise, similar to passing payments, holding hearings, or making formal choices.

Gatchalian’s group said {that a} quorum of 12 “is decided primarily based on the variety of members who’re legally capable of discharge the capabilities of the Senate.”

He stated this was “in full accord” with a Supreme Courtroom ruling stating “that an absolute majority of 12 out of the 23 members can represent a constitutional majority of the Senate for quorum functions.”

Gatchalian was referring to the landmark SC ruling within the 1949 case of Avelino v. Bowl.

In that call, the Excessive Courtroom held that “an absolute majority (12) of all of the members of the Senate much less one (23), constitutes constitutional majority of the Senate for the aim of a quorum.”

Former SC Affiliate Justice Jose Feria additionally argued that the constitutional majority must be computed primarily based on the precise variety of members inside the Senate’s jurisdiction.

“Due to this fact, as Senator Confesor was in the US and absent from the jurisdiction of the Senate, the precise members of the Senate at its session of February 21, 1949, had been twenty-three (23) and due to this fact 12 constituted a majority,” Feria’s opinion learn.

In the meantime, different Filipinos additionally pointed to the participation of present senators in earlier quorums amid debate over the validity of the June 3 session.

A Fb web page cited cases by which Cayetano siblings, in addition to Sen. Loren Legardahad been a part of a quorum of 12 senators, primarily based on Senate journals uploaded on the Senate web site.

In 4 cases, they had been recorded as current through the roll name, indicating their participation within the quorum.

These periods happened on Feb. 11, 2009; Sept. 29, 2010; May 5, 2015 and June 2, 2015.

“So when 12 had been accepted then, why is it an ‘unlawful coup’ now?” the Fb web page requested.

Former Senate President Franklin Drilon additionally stated that, primarily based on his expertise, 12 senators already represent a quorum within the Senate.

“Throughout my time in March 2015, out of the 24 senators, there have been (4) outdoors the nation and three in jail. So the whole variety of the Senate was solely 17 senators. And my ruling on the time was 12, that is a quorum,” he shared.

Sen. Erwin Tulfoin the meantime, challenged the Cayetano siblings to overview the Senate’s attendance information from 2008 to 2015.

The information confirmed that, through the phrases of three Senate presidents, periods proceeded with a quorum though solely three senators had been bodily current within the plenary corridor.

— with reviews from Philstar.com/Ian Laqui, Renalyn Ramirez, Martin Ramos, Rosette Adel, Camille Diola and Kristine Daguno-Bersamina

https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/

https://interaksyon.philstar.com/politics-issues/2026/06/04/314468/current-senators-joined-past-12-member-quorum-sessions-senate-records-show/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here