THE HAGUE, Netherlands – It was a day of quotable quotes on Monday, February 23, when the Worldwide Felony Courtroom (ICC) opened its weeklong listening to on the affirmation of costs in opposition to former Philippine president Rodrigo Duterte.

Each side declare they received spherical one, and so they might each be proper. In addition they might have been attempting to win completely different battles.

Right here’s a rundown on what occurred on Day 1 of Duterte on pre-trial on the ICC.

Prosecution

The prosecution introduced testimonies from unnamed witnesses who stated that they had labored as assassins for the Davao Demise Squad. One witness claimed to have attended a gathering the day Duterte created the dying squad, the place the previous mayor of Davao Metropolis allegedly handed round a basket from which hitmen picked their handguns.

“The brand new members (of the dying squad) might pull one (gun) out like getting a prize. So they might every have a weapon for his or her new job. It was a celebratory occasion for Mr. Duterte. The witness defined Mr. Duterte was pleased at this dinner assembly,” stated prosecution senior trial lawyer Julian Nicholls.

“That is what the witness recollects of the assembly: he, Duterte, informed us that your job right here within the metropolis can be to kill the drug pushers, the snatchers, and the hold-uppers,” stated Nicholls.

The prosecution proceeded to indicate clips of Duterte admitting each to media and to Congress that he has a dying squad. The prosecution went on to say that no matter Duterte stated in his public remarks had been true.

“That’s not hyperbole. That’s not bluster. That’s him telling the reality when he feels secure, and that he can financial institution on his continued impunity,” stated Nicholls.

Deputy prosecutor Mame Mandiaye Niang and prosecution trial lawyer Julian Nicholls throughout the first day of affirmation of costs listening to in opposition to former president Rodrigo Duterte on February 23, 2026. Picture courtesy of the ICC

Within the ICC, there are completely different modes of felony legal responsibility. In Duterte’s case, his mode is an alleged oblique co-perpetrator. This merely means he didn’t pull the set off on the crimes being charged in opposition to him, however that he was “on the very coronary heart of the frequent plan to, use his phrases, neutralize alleged criminals within the Philippines by way of murders,” as Deputy Prosecutor Mame Mandiaye Niang stated.

On this mode of felony legal responsibility, one essential issue is psychological aspect or proving that the alleged co-perpetrator was conscious {that a} crime was going to occur.

“Mr. Duterte supposed and knew that the charged crimes had been occurring, or that they might happen within the abnormal course of occasion that he had set in place and put in movement,” stated Niang.

Lead protection counsel Nicholas Kaufman countered this by declaring that Duterte by no means wavered from warning policemen to not go rogue. Recalling that Duterte as soon as stated, “abuse your authority, and there shall be hell to pay,” Kaufman stated, “properly, there you might be, you will have it straight in your face, PEXO exonerating proof inside what’s claimed to be incriminating proof.” (PEXO stands for probably exonerating proof.)

Kaufman reiterated that these speeches weren’t enough proof.

The prosecution, nonetheless, stated their authorized principle doesn’t rely solely on speeches. “Disregard each speech ever made by Mr. Duterte. Throw all of them out. There’s nonetheless ample proof of considerable grounds primarily based on the opposite proof which now we have placed on our record of proof,” stated Nicholls.

“It’s all the time a thriller to me how Duterte would be capable to present proof he’s not concerned within the drug warfare, and I confirmed that earlier when the protection primarily stated that Duterte’s phrases had been hyperbole or joke,” stated Neri Colmenares, a human rights lawyer helping a bunch of sufferer, in a mixture of English and Filipino.

“That’s one of many weakest protection, I’ve additional confirmed it’s arduous to current proof at trial to defend him so for me, I’m extra assured that costs shall be confirmed,” stated Colmenares.

Adult, Male, Man
Lead protection counsel Nicholas Kaufman on the primary day of affirmation of costs listening to in opposition to former president Rodrigo Duterte on February 23, 2026. Picture courtesy of the ICC
Protection

Kaufman’s opening assertion portrayed Duterte as a “poor boy” from Davao Metropolis whose solely crime was having a potty mouth and “unpalatable” phrases and persona. Kaufman attacked President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. for sending Duterte to The Hague, the victims’ lawyer for allegedly politicizing the case, the journalists for allegedly sensationalizing tales of killings, and human rights attorneys and activists whom he referred to as leftists.

Abrasively calling the folks he talked about “unfastened collective of civil society,” Kaufman’s tirades sounded very very like Duterte and his mouthpieces throughout his presidency.

Kaufman insisted that each one of Duterte’s inflammatory remarks had been simply hyperbole. He went on to say that Marcos “neutralized” Duterte.

“Sure, Mr. Deputy Prosecutor, I used that legendary phrase, neutralize, so central and so important to your case principle, as a result of you recognize simply in addition to me that I’m utilizing the time period metaphorically,” stated Kaufman.

“Neutralize” is a key phrase as a result of this appeared in police circulars issued by then police chief Ronald “Bato” Dela Rosa, which the prosecution claims was an authority to kill.

The Duterte administration didn’t admit to this. Kaufman introduced it as much as drive residence his level that “neutralize,” as with Duterte’s speeches, shouldn’t be taken actually.

“That phrase has been key to all of those killings, my response actually was alas, if solely the Supreme Courtroom decides the case now we have one thing to say, and Kaufman cannot insult the victims through the use of that phrase, whilst I perceive as a protection counsel what he needed to do, which is why I used to be saying the price is price ita,” stated Ted Te, former spokesperson of the Philippine Supreme Courtroom and likewise a human rights lawyer who has labored on drug war-related instances.

(That phrase has been key to all of those killings, my response actually was it’s a disgrace, if the Supreme Courtroom solely determined that case, we’d have had a definition for that phrase, and Kaufman wouldn’t have been capable of disrespect victims through the use of that phrase, whilst I perceive as a protection counsel what he needed to do, which is why I used to be saying his charges are price it.)

Te was referring to a nonetheless pending nine-year-old Supreme Courtroom petition to declare Duterte’s warfare on medicine unconstitutional.

The place’s the jurisdiction argument?

“It was attention-grabbing to me to see that there wasn’t plenty of reference to the problem of jurisdiction of the court docket over the case which is one thing that’s below attraction proper now, so I’d be curious to see if and the way that’s introduced up throughout the subsequent the following few days,” stated Maria Elena Vignoli, senior counsel of Human Rights Watch’s worldwide justice program.

Even Salvador Panelo, Duterte’s former presidential authorized counsel and a kind of the household despatched to help, was searching for the massive jurisdictional argument. The protection staff considers jurisdiction their largest power. Kaufman has enlisted the assistance of French lawyer Dov Jacobswhose tutorial work on jurisdiction had been the supply of some ICC judges prior to now.

“(Kaufman) did properly besides that I’d like to listen to him query the jurisdiction of this court docket as a result of that’s the very fundamental, on the core of this case, that this court docket can’t proceed, can’t even enter into this case as a result of it has no jurisdiction,” stated Panelo, who was with Duterte in Malacañang in 2018, justifying their unilateral withdrawal from the ICC.

The large jurisdiction query is that if the ICC has energy over a non-member state? Primarily based on the last pre-trial chamber decisionjurisdiction stays over the crimes allegedly dedicated whereas the nation was nonetheless a member.

Who took Spherical 1?

Colmenares stated he’s now assured that the costs shall be confirmed after having heard the opening statements.

“I’ve not seen any protection proof that he didn’t commit (the crimes) (I didn’t see any proof from the protection to show he didn’t commit the crimes) besides to say that his was simply smoked statements (that his statements had been misinterpreted). That solely goes to indicate the costs are going to be confirmed,” stated Colmenares.

Duterte’s staff, nonetheless, was very glad with Kaufman’s efficiency on Monday.

“(Kaufman) was excellent, very efficient, very direct. It’s really easy to make allegations or shows however these shows have to be primarily based on proof,” stated Duterte’s former labor secretary Silvestre Bello II.

“For me, Kaufman’s total assertion just isn’t authorized, however politicall (for me the whole assertion by Kaufman was not authorized however political). Will it profit Sara Duterte? I don’t know, however perhaps, as a result of it’s going to feed into the narrative of the Dutertes that Sara can use,” stated Colmenares.

Observe Rappler for extra protection on the affirmation of costs listening to. – Rappler.com

https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/

https://www.rappler.com/newsbreak/explainers/highlights-duterte-pre-trial-february-23-2026/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here