December 26, 2025 | 1:44pm
MANILA, Philippines — Senior highschool college students enrolled in costly personal colleges with annual tuition reaching as excessive as P317,314 acquired authorities vouchers meant to assist low-income learners, the Fee on Audit present in its newest report on the Division of Training.
The annual audit report launched Friday, December 26, flagged DepEd’s lack of “clearly outlined and standardized parameters” for figuring out college students’ precise monetary want within the senior highschool voucher program, which supplies as much as P22,500 in tuition subsidies to certified college students.
DepEd launched its senior excessive voucher program in 2016 firstly of senior highschool, in an effort to assist low-income Grade 10 graduates enroll in personal colleges and supposedly ease overcrowding in public colleges.
The voucher subsidy is remitted on to the college the scholar chooses somewhat than given as money, and the quantity varies primarily based on location and pupil class.
Among the more moderen controversies of this system have centered on the separate situation of “ghost college students” — instances the place personal colleges allegedly listed non-existent college students to assert authorities subsidies. This has since prompted DepEd Secretary Sonny Angara to launch a probe and order the elimination of a minimum of 55 personal colleges from this system.
However much less clear has been how most of the vouchers have gone to prosperous college students who may have enrolled with out the subsidies from the beginning.
COA’s audit report launched as we speak supplies a snapshot primarily based on NCR information for the college 12 months 2023-2024, which reveals a number of recipients enrolled in colleges that cost over a whole lot of 1000’s of pesos.
The audit reveals that of three,356 voucher grantees tracked in chosen “high-tuition” colleges, 546 have been robotically certified learners whereas 1,838 have been voucher candidates, in keeping with information from the Personal Training Help Committee Administration Portal cited within the report.
Within the audit report, high-tuition colleges are outlined as prestigious personal establishments the place annual tuition charges vary from over P100,000 to as excessive as P317,314.
“The presence of (beneficaries) in these prestigious or high-tuition personal colleges … raises issues concerning the fairness and appropriateness of public fund allocation beneath the SHS Voucher Program,” the report acknowledged.
COA famous that, as a result of the voucher subsidy covers solely as much as P22,500, households paying the remaining stability — over P294,000 in some instances — are presumed to have the monetary capability to afford education with out authorities assist.
“That is inconsistent with this system’s core goal to prioritize financially deprived learners,” the report added.
As an illustration, in a single unnamed college with annual charges as excessive as P195,753, there are a minimum of 1,208 college students in Grade 11 and 12 who benefited from voucher subsidies, in keeping with the abstract within the audit report. Consequently, DepEd coughed up P22.77 million in complete voucher subsidies to this high-tuition college.
Screengrab from Fee on Audit’s annual audit report for the Division of Training in 2024. This desk was included within the observations and findings of COA for DepEd’s voucher program for senior highschool college students.
The issue, state auditors discovered, lies in how college students qualify for this system within the first place. Whereas there are guidelines for prioritizing college students, in observe, the analysis of candidates is basically “discretionary,” giving important leeway to taking part colleges and PEAC in figuring out who will get permitted, COA stated.
There aren’t any specific standards, reminiscent of particular earnings thresholds or scoring mechanisms to persistently assess monetary want, COA stated.
Due to this, the reverse can even occur, in that college students who want the subsidies essentially the most find yourself not qualifying.
“Consequently, there’s a danger of inconsistent utility of the eligibility standards, doubtlessly resulting in the inclusion of scholars who might not be financially deprived, and the exclusion of these candidates who want it most,” the audit report acknowledged.
However are authorities vouchers really just for the poor? That is what the regulation says: Republic Act 8545 or the Expanded Authorities Help to College students and Lecturers in Personal Training (E-GASTPE) Act mandates that authorities help applications give desire to underprivileged college students.
The implementing guidelines of the Okay to 12 regulation additionally specify that voucher help ought to primarily profit college students who accomplished junior highschool in public colleges, with earnings background and monetary wants amongst key issues.
The COA report additionally takes care to say that there must be no “discriminatory” facet to the choice technique of voucher recipients.
“Whereas this system’s goal doesn’t intend to exclude or discriminate in opposition to any learner — on condition that equal enjoyment of rights and privileges is constitutionally assured — the regulation mandates that desire be given to underprivileged college students,” state auditors stated.
“Consequently, this system’s restricted price range could also be allotted to beneficiaries who should not among the many most financially in want, thereby depriving extra economically deprived college students of much-needed instructional assist,” the report added.
COA shared an identical discovering within the early years of the SHS program. In 2018, a COA efficiency report acknowledged that the Authorities Help to College students and Lecturers in Personal Training (GASTPE) program — which the SHS vouchers are beneath — was benefiting “non-poor” college students as a consequence of DepEd’s incapability to make sure its environment friendly implementation.
This 2018 report discovered that DepEd “doesn’t examine whether or not or not the scholars are literally underprivileged.”
Sen. Sherwin Gatchalian, then-chair of the Senate fundamental schooling panel, stated final 12 months that this system was a “wastage” and a “leakage” for failing to target the learners who wanted vouchers essentially the most.
https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/
https://www.philstar.com/headlines/2025/12/26/2496870/coa-why-were-senior-high-vouchers-given-students-high-tuition-schools



