The party-list system was meant to problem elite politics. But it surely has as a substitute change into a bastion of households and contractors. This report offers the numbers: half of the 64 party-list representatives within the Twentieth Congress are members of lively political clans, and practically a 3rd have ties to authorities contractors.

by Guinevere Latoza and Christian Chua

Almost 40 years in the past, the framers of the post-Marcos structure supplied for a party-list system to make sure that Congress wouldn’t be dominated by political households.

As we speak, the hope—that social gathering checklist representatives would supply a counterweight to the facility of dynasties—has been fully dashed.

Within the Twentieth Congress, half of the 64 party-list representatives come from political clans whose members presently maintain nationwide and native workplace, or held elective posts instantly earlier than them. These embrace kin of the president and vp—the primary time in Philippine electoral historical past that the kin of the nation’s two highest officers concurrently clinched party-list seats in Congress.

Marcos Jr.’s cousin-in-law Yedda Romualdez and her son Andrew Julian Romualdez ran beneath the Leyte-based Tingog Sinirangan, whereas Harold Duterte, a cousin of Vice President Sara Duterte, received a seat by means of Pwersa ng Pilipinong Pandagat.

The framers of the 1987 Structure designed the party-list system to function a platform for issue-based lawmakers representing different views, not the pillars of the institution just like the Marcoses and Dutertes who’ve monopolized elective workplace of their bailiwicks for many years. The party-list seats are on prime of different elective posts held by members of those dynasties.

The president’s sister Imee is a senator. Marcos Jr.’s son Sandro represents the primary district of Ilocos Norte; his cousin-in-law is Ilocos Norte governor; and his nephew is vice governor of the identical province.

The Marcoses’ attain goes all the best way to Leyte. Ferdindand Martin Romualdez, Marcos Jr.’s cousin and Yedda’s husband, is Leyte’s first district consultant. One other presidential cousin is mayor of Tacloban Metropolis, Leyte’s capital; Marcos Jr.’s nephew, the mayor’s son, is the vice mayor of the identical metropolis; and one other nephew is a Tacloban Metropolis councilor.

In the meantime, the vp’s brother Paolo represents the primary district of Davao; her nephew represents the second district; her different brother Sebastian is performing Davao Metropolis mayor; and one other nephew is Davao Metropolis vice mayor.

By the Philippine Middle for Investigative Journalism’s rely, 32 of the 64 party-list representatives within the Twentieth Congress come from lively political clans though the events they belong to assert to symbolize the poor, farmers, and abnormal people from their provinces.

Authorities contractors, too, have penetrated the Twentieth Congress by means of the party-list route.

PCIJ analysis reveals that almost a 3rd of party-list lawmakers are both founders or shareholders of firms which have been awarded authorities contracts, have kin who’re authorities contractors, or obtained marketing campaign donations from such people. They declare to symbolize a number of sectors and regional constituencies.

“Teams related to highly effective political households have used the party-list as a ‘backdoor’ to broaden dynastic affect within the Home of Consultant,” said the Nationwide Residents’ Motion for Free Elections (NAMFREL). The system has been “captured by political dynasties and financial elites,” they additional asserted.

The flood management corruption scandal that rocked the nation in mid-2025 gave technique to authorities probes and media studies that unravelled ties between public works contractors and lawmakers, together with party-list representatives.

Amid public strain, President Marcos Jr. instructed Congress to prioritize passage of a party-list reform invoice. The Senate is now deliberating varied proposals geared toward reorienting the party-list system to its authentic objective.

The 1987 Structure reserved 20% of Home seats for party-list lawmakers or those that symbolize nationwide, regional, and sectoral events. Occasion-list elections undertake proportional illustration, which signifies that the extra votes a gaggle will get, the extra seats they’ll assume.

In the course of the first party-list election in 1998, solely “marginalized and underrepresented sectors” resembling staff, farmers, city poor, indigenous folks, youth, and ladies had been allowed to take part. In 2001, the Supreme Court docket dominated that party-list teams should symbolize marginalized and underrepresented sectors.

However in 2013, the excessive court docket reversed itself and determined that party-list teams “don’t must symbolize any marginalized and underrepresented sector.”

This ruling “opened avenues for rich and politically related people to steer party-lists with none substantive sectoral observe file or real advocacy,” in line with NAMFREL.

After the ruling, political clans fielded candidates, simply successful social gathering checklist seats by mobilizing their political machines. All it takes to win a celebration checklist seat is round 250,000 votes.

The Marcos-Romualdez dynasty

Spanning Ilocos Norte and Leyte, the Marcos-Romualdez clan is without doubt one of the Philippines’ most overweight political dynasties. Almost two dozen members throughout 4 generations have held seats from metropolis corridor to Malacañang.

President Ferdinand Edralin Marcos, Jr. takes his oath of workplace on the Nationwide Museum Constructing on Thursday, 30 June 2022. Screenshot from RTVM

Opening up social gathering checklist illustration to clans permits them to amass much more energy than they have already got. Lawmakers have appreciable clout in deciding how public funds are distributed throughout authorities businesses, who then bid out contracts to non-public firms.

Getting appointed chairperson of the Home appropriations committee, particularly, might give a lawmaker huge discretion in deciding the place public funds go. This panel is in control of the nationwide authorities’s spending invoice.

Within the nineteenth Congress, former Ako Bicol Rep. Elizaldy Co held the put up. Afterward, the Ombudsman said that Co is a helpful proprietor of Sunwest Inc., which occurred to be the top contractor for flood-control works throughout the identical interval he chaired the appropriations committee.

The Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act bans public officers from straight or not directly having monetary pursuits in any enterprise, contract or transaction with the federal government. The Code of Conduct of Public Officers mandates public officers to divest from firms whose actions “might have an effect on” the efficiency of their responsibility.

In the meantime, the Omnibus Election Code prohibits electoral candidates from receiving marketing campaign donations from authorities contractors, franchisees, and licensees.

“Everyone is aware of about it in Congress that a lot of their colleagues are contractors additionally, and that this can be a prohibited exercise,” Ombudsman Jesus Crispin Remulla, a former lawmaker himself, mentioned in October final yr. His workplace is tasked with investigating public officers concerned in wrongdoing.

“I don’t know if it’s identified to them, or it’s simply the impunity of all of it that folks don’t care anymore if it’s in opposition to the regulation as a result of they suppose nobody’s going to run after them. But it surely’s one thing we now have to handle,” he added.

Magbubukid Rep. Ferdinand Beltran, a member of the Home appropriations committee, is without doubt one of the party-list lawmakers who’re additionally contractors. He’s the proprietor of Pampanga-based public works contracting firm Ferdstar Builders Inc., in line with the corporate’s August 2024 Common Info Sheet.

Beltran’s spouse, son and daughter-in-law are co-owners of 11-16 Building Corp., one other public works contractor. PCIJ discovered {that a} technical employees of the identical firm, Nikko Alfaro, donated P300,000 to Magbubukid’s 2025 electoral marketing campaign.

Some have extra oblique hyperlinks to contractors. FPJ Panday Bayanihan Rep. Brian, the son of former Senator Grace Poe, will not be a contractor however information present that his social gathering accepted donations from authorities contractors Maynard Ngu and Joseph Quirante value P500,000 every.

Ngu is the chief govt of Cosmic Applied sciences, Inc., a contractor for the Division of Training. In a Senate listening to final yr, former public works undersecretary Roberto Bernardo alleged that Ngu is the  bagman of Senator Francis Escudero.

In the meantime, Quirante is the chief monetary officer of Octagon Concrete Options, a contractor for the Division of Public Works and Highways. He occurs to be the brother-in-law of Escudero.

Poe, now a vice chairperson of the Home appropriations committee, additionally ran alongside Batangas contractor Mark Patron, the second nominee of FPJ Panday Bayanihan.

What began with a mayor in Cebu has grown into one of many Philippines’ strongest political dynasties, spanning 4 generations, a number of seats in Congress, and the nation’s highest places of work.

02 Duterte family Malacanang photo
Former President Rodrigo Duterte and his youngsters Sebastian, Veronica, Sarah and Paulo on the Malacañang Palace throughout his presidency. Malacañang photograph

Electoral reform teams and lecturers are lobbying for a variety of proposals to revamp the party-list system, together with:

  • Requiring party-list nominees to have a documented observe file of at the very least three to 5 years of sectoral advocacy inside the sector they search to symbolize (NAMFREL)
  • Conducting thorough background vetting and evidentiary public hearings on applicant party-lists (NAMFREL)
  • Disqualifying party-list nominees who maintain pursuits in companies with authorities licenses, franchises, or contracts (Authorized Community of Truthful Elections or LENTE)
  • Mandating public disclosure of party-list marketing campaign donations earlier than election day, slightly than 30 days after (LENTE and NAMFREL)
  • Barring kin of sitting elective officers as much as at the very least the second diploma of consanguinity or affinity from being party-list nominees (NAMFREL and LENTE)

As well as, political science professor Alicor Panao proposed eradicating the three-seat restrict for party-lists. Below the present regulation, a gaggle can solely safe three seats at most whatever the proportion of votes they get.

The restrict, he mentioned, betrays the idea of proportional illustration which signifies that the proportion of votes every party-list garners ought to correspond to the variety of seats they get. If, for instance, a gaggle obtained 30% of party-list votes, they need to additionally get 30% of obtainable seats.

Panao mentioned it additionally forces teams who might have comparable advocacies to separate into smaller events to get as many seats, slightly than consolidate into probably bigger and stronger events.

Unmasking party-list ties

image 9

Various party-lists who’ve vital electoral bases have sustained their numbers or staged comebacks within the Twentieth Congress.

The progressive Makabayan bloc nonetheless has three seats—one every for ACT Academics, Gabriela and Kabataan. Social democratic Akbayan garnered the best variety of votes and secured three spots. First-timer Mamamayang Liberal, the sectoral group of the Liberal Occasion, additionally received a seat.

Representatives of those teams have observe information of organizing alongside political or sectoral traces. They don’t have any ties to ruling political households. They usually don’t have any identified hyperlinks to contractors. However, they’re extra of the exception slightly than the rule.

Professor Panao mentioned that instructional campaigns on how the party-list system works have to be sustained.

“Let’s simplify our technical data. What ought to voters take note of? For instance: In case you’re voting for a party-list, you don’t take a look at the personalities behind it. So even when they dance, you don’t mechanically vote for them. You learn the platform, not the dance,” he mentioned.

He added that the problem now could be fostering abnormal residents’ participation in politics past elections.

“If we actually wish to change our political system, are you prepared to sacrifice? Are you prepared to affix a party-list group? Are you prepared to participate within the social gathering’s campaigns?” he mentioned.—PCIJ.org

The analysis workforce contains Jodie Dayrit, Arabella Mariano, Molly Nocum, Klyde Charles Painor, Jenelle Raganas, and God’s Irrigation Stripe.

Time Rey produced the information visualizations.

https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/

https://mindanews.com/special-reports/2026/03/in-numbers-dynasties-and-contractors-capture-party-list-seats-in-the-Twentieth-congress/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here