The present focus of consideration within the Division of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) flood management initiatives scandal is the investigation and filing of charges in opposition to authorities officers (together with legislators) and contractors implicated within the case. Thorough investigation and considered prosecution of these concerned within the anomalous flood management and associated initiatives ought to certainly be pursued at this stage.
However lest what’s now reputed to be the most important scandal to hit the Philippines simply goes the best way of many earlier corruption scandals by which all or many of the “large fish” have remained scot-free — similar to within the P728-million fertilizer fund rip-off (2004) and the P10 billion pork barrel rip-off (2013) — we should always study the patterns which have emerged from the varied scandals and draw classes from them. And we should always maintain shut observe of your complete course of that the DPWH scandal will bear.
Outrage and vigilance are inclined to wane and even fully dissipate as the method of a corruption case drags on by way of years of litigation.
Corruption normally proceeds in a linear vogue within the sense that many corrupt politicians and bureaucrats reach conducting their clandestine predation undisturbed and unexposed and making all the pieces appear regular. Since predators are inclined to develop greedier over time, the road may be drawn as turning into increasingly more crooked and in an ascending trajectory.
Typically, nevertheless, corruption is uncovered and uncovered, and a scandal arises. The corruption is disrupted. The corruption scandal undergoes a cycle, which may very well be quick or lengthy. It ends with a return to corruption by a number of of the corrupt officers — not simply these convicted but additionally those that escaped conviction. (It have to be famous right here that most of the nation’s grand corruption scandals have ended with no large fish, and even no single individual, being put behind bars.) For corrupt officers, it’s again to linear corruption. This might once more be disrupted with an exposé of a brand new corruption case implicating a number of of the corrupt officers concerned within the earlier scandal. A brand new cycle then begins.
The levels of a lengthy corruption scandal cycle are:
- Uncovering and/or exposé
- Investigation
- Indictment and Prosecution
- Punishment or Acquittal
- Non-implementation/Reversal of Punishment or Pardon
- “Rehabilitation” and Relegitimation
- “Return to Regular”
Within the first three levels of the cycle, nobody has but been established as being responsible of corruption.
The resignation of an implicated public official might at occasions transpire inside these first three levels. “Return to Regular” may imply resumption or reversion to trustworthy public service of these earlier implicated within the corruption scandal, however it may additionally imply the return to predatory exercise by a number of of the corrupt officers concerned within the scandal, whether or not convicted or not.
The brand new stage
If corrupt officers, particularly the large fish, don’t reach getting away at one stage, then they attempt to get away on the subsequent stage. Many Filipinos suppose that justice has triumphed when a corrupt official is convicted and meted the suitable punishment. However someday later, when many don’t observe the case anymore, the decision may very well be reversed or not applied, or the official is pardoned. Corrupt officers — convicted or not — run once more for public workplace or safe a reappointment to “rehabilitate” and relegitimize themselves.
Shorter cycles contain the skipping of sure levels. The shortest cycle could be a leap from Uncovering/Exposé (Stage 1) to “Return to Regular” (Stage 7), which merely implies that the exposé has been a dud. Corrupt politicians attempt to maintain the cycle as quick as doable, as a protracted cycle may entail spending years in jail or in judicial appeals.

Adjustments in authorities and modifications within the nation’s high anti-corruption company, the Workplace of the Ombudsman (OMB), have a fantastic bearing within the improvement of a corruption scandal cycle. A corrupt or inept president or ombudsman can’t be anticipated to be enthusiastic nor critical in combating corruption. Some presidents and ombudsmen have come beneath the cloud. Former president Joseph Estrada, implicated in a bribery scandal (Juetengate), was ousted by a preferred rebellion and was later convicted of plunder. Former president Gloria Macapagal Arroyo was rated because the most corrupt Philippine leader in historical past in a 2007 Asian Pulse survey, beating out even Ferdinand Marcos, Sr., and Estrada. She was indicted for plunder in 2012, however acquitted by the Supreme Courtroom in 2016.
Former ombudsman Merceditas Gutierrez was impeached by the Home of Representatives in 2011 for, amongst different causes, failing to behave on a number of corruption allegations made in opposition to Arroyo, her husband and associates. Gutierrez resigned earlier than the Senate impeachment trial may start. Ombudsman Samuel Martires demonstrated the depths of his ineptitude when he confessed, in congressional hearings, that “corruption has change into a vogue, a fad … (and) is growing in every agency of the government” and that “we’re combating corruption right within the (Ombudsman’s) office.”
When the going will get tough for a corrupt politician in the midst of a corruption scandal cycle, she or he may very well select to let the method drag till a brand new President or Ombudsman comes alongside, hoping that the latter is extra pliable, corruptible or inept, or comes from the identical political occasion or faction.
How post-EDSA I governments dealt with corruption throughout the authoritarian period is sort of indicative of how efficient anti-corruption efforts have been. In the course of the martial regulation interval, there was rampant corruption by President Marcos, his spouse, Imelda, and his cronies. Amongst Marcos’ high cronies, as named by Wikipedia, have been: Juan Ponce Enrile, Antonio Floirendo, Danding Cojuangco, Roberto Benedicto, Lucio Tan, Geronimo Velasco, Roman Cruz, Rodolfo Cuenca, Manuel Elizalde, Ricardo Silverio, Herminio Disini, Pete Sabido and Jose Yao Campos. Though the the primary couple and Marcos’ cronies have undergone post-EDSA cycles of corruption, none of them has been tried and convicted of plunder or corruption. The lone exception is Imelda Marcos, who was found guilty by the Sandiganbayan of corruption-related fees, however she has not spent a single day behind bars. The Sandiganbayan has convicted only some of Marcos’ minor “cronies” on graft, similar to three former officials of Integrated Shoe Inc.
The Philippines’ main corruption scandals within the post-authoritarian interval have terminated at numerous levels, earlier than “Return to Regular” (RN). The shortest-cycle scandals have been the Offshore Wealth instances (Offshore Leaks, Panama Papers, Pandora Papers), which by no means fared past Stage 1 (Exposé) earlier than RN. The second shortest-cycle scandals, reaching solely Stage 2 (Investigation) have been the PEA-Amari and the Ilocos Tobacco Tax Funds scandals. The Philhealth scandal stays largely caught in the intervening time at Stage 2, the UC-Malampaya and Pharmally scandals, at Stage 3 (Prosecution).
The Sara Duterte impeachment case has gone again to Stage 2. With the release of retired major general Carlos Garcia after 17 years in jail, the Garcia “plunder” case might have ended at Stage 4 (Punishment) earlier than RN, however his spouse and three sons nonetheless face plunder fees. After years of investigation and litigation, the NBN-ZTE, Euro generals, navy “pabaon,” and Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Workplace fund scandals concluded in Stage 4 (Punishment or Acquittal) earlier than RN with both nobody or no large fish being convicted of corruption.
The fertilizer fund scandal seems to have reached an identical useless finish too. The primary Malampaya Fund scandal, did finish in convictions for a provincial governor and several other others. With the reversal of the dismissal of some Immigration officers, the Pastilyas bribery rip-off has moved to Stage 5 (Reversal). The ghost street initiatives ended at Stage 5 (Pardon) earlier than RN. Juetengate and the PDAF Pork Barrel rip-off have been long-cycle scandals, attaining Stage 6 (Learn: The politics of rehabilitation and relegitimation) with the return to public workplace of former President Estrada and lots of of these indicted within the PDAF rip-off.
Beneath are diagrams and a short rationalization of the cycles of a corruption scandal. They present how, by way of the levels, the numbers of officers being investigated or prosecuted for corruption are whittled down (typically to zero) and the way these considerably tainted “rehabilitate” or relegitimate themselves. Brief, medium and lengthy cycles all finish with 1.7 (or 2.0) “Return to Regular. Finish of Cycle” (RN/EC). 2.1 (not proven on the diagram) would imply the uncovering or exposé of a brand new scandal involving an official or officers implicated in 1.1.

1.0 Every thing Appears Regular. Public officers with integrity have interaction in real public service. Corrupt officers have interaction in clandestine predation – linear corruption. Some individuals not concerned could also be suspicious and even within the know, however they maintain quiet, and the corrupt exercise stays hidden to the general public.
1.1 Uncovering and/or exposé. This marks the start of the cycle of a corruption scandal and infrequently suspends or stops an ongoing corrupt exercise. Corrupt officers try to stop the scandal from transferring on to the subsequent stage by issuing denials or explanations, or attacking their accusers.
Many instances of believable corruption are of the “flash within the pan” sort – they don’t transcend uncovering/exposé. Examples are the instances of offshore wealth uncovered within the Offshore Leaks, Panama Papers, and Pandora Papers.
1.2 Investigation. Performed by the OMB, congressional committees or particular commissions, typically with public hearings, investigation places public officers suspected of getting engaged in corruption within the heart of intense media consideration and public scrutiny. Grand corruption typically entails a number of gamers with no less than a few of them being high-ranked public officers.
On the investigation stage, implicated officers make each effort to keep away from being indicted, particularly on the cost of plunder. Plunder, which is non-bailable when the proof of guilt is powerful, may imply quick detention. Worse, an official discovered responsible of plunder will get life imprisonment.
The investigation stage typically finally ends up with only some or nobody or no large fish being formally charged, as within the PEA-Amari and Ilocos Norte Tobacco Excise Tax scandals, and doubtless the Philhealth scandal too.
1.3 Indictment and prosecution. At this stage, one factor to be careful for right here is whether or not there are some names, particularly these of high officers, that don’t seem on the lists of these 1) indicted, and a couple of) indicted for extra critical fees, similar to plunder. Corrupt officers handle to keep away from being on both record by way of the brilliance of their attorneys, the incompetence or lack of diligence of the prosecution and/or the contamination within the judicial system. Those that do stand trial search to make it as fast as doable, not simply because they don’t wish to get out of the glare of public opprobrium, but additionally as a result of in addition they wish to get again to the great outdated days. Lengthy trials typically work within the corrupt officers’ favor as public consideration and stress wane over time. In the course of the prosecution stage, these accused of significant crimes similar to plunder typically have interaction in plea-bargaining, similar to within the Garcia “Plunder” case, in an effort to face fees on lesser offenses.
Within the case of sure high-level authorities posts, impeachment serves as a type of indictment and this has had some curious denouements within the Philippines: widespread rebellion (Joseph Estrada) and unconstitutionality ruling (Sara Duterte).
1.4 Punishment or acquittal. Maybe essentially the most hanging characteristic of scandals that finish at this stage is that many grand corruption instances finish with both no conviction in any respect (NBN-ZTE, Euro Generals, AFP Pabaon and PCSO Fund scandals) or no conviction of ringleaders (Fertilizer Fund scandal). A lot of these charged, particularly essentially the most distinguished figures are sometimes acquitted due to “insufficiency of proof” and “inordinate delay” within the instances filed in opposition to them. Years of litigation typically assist in diminishing public consideration and recollection.
Punishment for corruption ranges from administrative sanction (similar to suspension or dismissal from one’s authorities place), to gentle jail sentence to life imprisonment. Regardless of all of the grand corruption scandals which have come to cross over the previous few many years, a complete of solely 4 individuals have really been convicted of plunder: Estrada (Juetengate), Janet Lim-Napoles and Richard Cambe (PDAF), and a Bureau of Internal Revenue cashier. It is a damning testimony to the inefficacy of the OMB and different anti-corruption our bodies.
1.5 Non-implementation/reversal of punishment or pardon. Many Filipinos suppose that justice has been realized with the conviction or administration sanction of corrupt officers. However there are nonetheless various methods to bypass or cut back punishment: non-implementation or reversal, as within the instances of Imelda Marcos and Senator Villanueva, and presidential pardons as within the instances of former President Estrada and Jaime Ponce de Leon. The facility of govt clemency of the President consists of commutation of sentence, conditional pardon or absolute pardon. Parole, not essentially for good habits, is one other avenue, however the media doesn’t normally maintain observe of this.
1.6 ‘Rehabilitation’ and relegitimation. Rehabilitation refers to efforts of a public official who has been implicated or tainted in a corruption scandal to regain public acceptability, respectability and credibility. Relegitimation consists of efforts at regaining the belief of voters or most of the people. For trustworthy public officers who’ve been wrongly implicated, and for once-corrupt officers who want to change for the higher, rehabilitation and relegitimation are needed for them to have the ability to resume, or revert to, real public service with out hindrances or inhibitions. As may be gleaned or suspected from the frequent repetition of names in corruption scandals, nevertheless, incorrigibly corrupt public officers are literally utilizing “rehabilitation” and relegitimation as devices for the resumption or continuation of predation.
Amongst those that have been implicated in plunder or corruption scandals earlier than, the record of public officers who’ve been most proficient in relegitimation would come with former Presidents Estrada and Arroyo, Senators Lapid, Jinggoy Estrada, Imee Marcos and Villanueva, and former Senator Enrile.
1.7/2.0 Return to regular. Finish of cycle (RN/EC). Every thing seems regular once more. It will be tough for most of the people to measurement up who among the many public officers implicated or convicted in corruption scandals are, or have become, trustworthy public servants, and who’re or have remained corrupt. Typically, nevertheless, the title of a public official beforehand implicated crops up once more in a brand new corruption scandal. The official turns into a part of new cycle.
Somecorrupt former officers, similar to Imelda Marcos, select to “retire” and simply wallow within the luxurious of their ill-gotten wealth. (Though her sentence bars her from returning to public workplace, she may nonetheless have very properly made a Joseph Estrada-style comeback had she wished.) Nonetheless different corrupt officers impart their predatory knowhow to their sons, daughters or different kinfolk, making certain the handing on of the baton of the venerable dynastic custom referred to as corruption. The truth that sure surnames or center names come up in scandal after scandal are indicative of some bequeathal processes at work.
Proceed in cycles
Corruption scandals proceed in cycles, some going by way of only one stage (Uncovering/Exposé), others by way of as many as six levels, earlier than issues “return to regular.” Corrupt public officers, particularly the large fish, attempt to maintain the cycle of a corruption scandal as quick as doable. Via Phases 1 to five, they attempt to get away from any accountability, any investigation, any cost, any punishment. If they can not get away at one stage, they struggle once more on the subsequent stage. If the penalty being thought of is far too extreme, similar to life imprisonment (for plunder), they attempt to deliver it right down to a lesser crime or to nothing, by way of connections, plea bargaining, bribery, no matter works.
Corrupt officers present process judicial processes resort to case-dragging, nevertheless, in the event that they deem that the President or the Ombudsman is actually coming down laborious on them. They don’t merely look forward to “higher” occasions; in addition they lay their bets on doable successors who’re extra pliable or are kindred spirits.
For incorrigibly corrupt public officers, Stage 6 (“Rehabilitation” and Relegitimation) is an important stage. If a corrupt official succeeds in being elected or appointed to public workplace once more, she or he will get entry once more to all of the alternatives for lease creation, extraction and sharing with corrupt businessmen and contractors and his/her political dynasty. Tens of millions, billions, trillions of pesos!
The expertise of Joseph Estrada is maybe essentially the most instructive of all. A public official charged with plunder can undergo all of the levels — uncovering/exposé, investigation, indictment and prosecution, conviction, pardon, rehabilitation and relegitimation — and his son finally ends up convicted of bribery. If a politician convicted of plunder can nonetheless get again to public workplace, why can’t different public officers charged with the standard or lesser corruption fees observe in his footsteps?
The DPWH rip-off is at the moment transitioning from Stage 2 to Stage 3 with the beginning of indictments in opposition to some public officers and personal contractors. Trials of these charged might begin, probably in just a few months. What the anti-corruption motion ought to be careful for, nevertheless, is 1) that the large fish, or some large fish, might escape indictment or conviction in Phases 3 and 4; 2) that the large fish, or some large fish, might escape indictment or conviction for plunder, put up bail early on, and even depart the nation; and three) that the corruption scandal cycle strikes on to Phases 5 and 6 and to the resumption of corrupt exercise in Stage 7 (Return to regular).
Vigilance, willpower, and doggedness are crucial in any respect levels of the cycle of a corruption scandal if the anti-corruption motion desires to be sure that corrupt political officers, particularly the large fish, don’t get away … and get again into the sport. – Rappler.com
Nathan Gilbert Quimpo, who has retired from instructing political science and worldwide relations on the College of Tsukuba, Japan, taught a web-based course on “Corruption” on the Ateneo de Manila College final yr and earlier this yr. He’s now based mostly in Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/
https://www.rappler.com/voices/thought-leaders/opinion-corruption-cycles/



