‘Perhaps it is extra shocking when the prosecution turns into impartial. And possibly it is extra shocking if we defend the respondent,’ says Home lead prosecutor Gerville Luistro

In an impeachment trial, the place the Home panel’s job is to prosecute, Senator Robin Padilla urged the prosecutors to not be “one-sided.”

The comment drew fast murmurs from the Home prosecution panel, a workforce of legal professionals. Some exchanged puzzled appears, briefly interrupting Padilla’s questioning. Senate workers shortly raised “Silence Please” indicators.

The response grew to become loud sufficient that impeachment courtroom presiding officer Chiz Escudero referred to as for order.

Moments earlier, Padilla had questioned Home prosecutor Gerville Luistro in regards to the credibility of Arturo Lascañas. He mentioned that Lascañas’ affidavit was “tainted by lies” due to his contradictory statements.

Lascañas’ affidavit was cited by Luistro in the course of the examination of the witness. This doc, nonetheless, just isn’t a part of the proof of the Home prosecutors.

Padilla famous that Lascañas had cleared former president Rodrigo Duterte of any wrongdoing in an October 3, 2016 assertion, however later modified his account in affidavits dated February 20 and March 6.

“What do you name an individual who says various things? Is not it a liar?” (What do you name somebody who retains altering his story? Isn’t he a liar?)

Luistro tried to clarify that the Lascañas doc was cited solely to indicate how the Nationwide Bureau of Investigation dealt with its probe into Vice President Sara Duterte’s alleged threats towards President Ferdinand Marcos Jr.

Escudero, nonetheless, instructed her to reply the query instantly.

“With out specific reference to Arturo Lascañas, I agree with you, Presiding Officer,” Luistro replied when requested whether or not somebody who repeatedly adjustments their story must be thought of an unreliable witness.

What’s the precise function of prosecution?

Requested later about Padilla’s comment, Luistro gave a lawyer’s reply.

“With all due respect to senator-judge Padilla, apparently this impeachment trial is adversarial,” Lusitro mentioned.

“Perhaps it is extra shocking when the prosecution turns into impartial. And possibly it is extra shocking if we defend the respondent,” Luistro mentioned. (It might be extra shocking if the prosecution had been impartial. It might be much more shocking if we had been defending the respondent.)

Home non-public prosecutor Lorna Kapunan joked that Luistro’s response had been the diplomatic model.

“If it had been me,” Kapunan quipped, “gentlemanly however a bit impolite.” (I’d be well mannered, however a little bit impolite.)

Nonetheless, Kapunan careworn there was no intention to disrespect Padilla.

“It was an instinctive response,” she mentioned, explaining that the prosecutors had been caught off guard by the suggestion.

She even discovered some humor within the second.

“We’re at all times appreciative that Senator Robin at all times brings shade and shock and pleasure. Particularly as a result of he was the final one to manifest — all of us wakened earlier and had been scolded within the entrance row,” Kapunan mentioned. (Padilla actually woke all of us up this afternoon — and we within the entrance row even obtained scolded.)

Ultimately, Kapunan returned to what she noticed as the apparent level.

“The prosecution is de facto for the prosecution, and the protection is for the protection,” she mentioned. “It’s the nature of the beast.”

Nicely, to stop additional reactions, Kapunan mentioned she simply bowed her head and prayed.

Head, Person, Face
KAPUNAN. Home prosecutor Lorna Kapunan bows her head throughout a press convention on July 22, 2026, reenacting her response after Senator-judge Robin Padilla referred to as out the Home prosecution panel.

– Rappler.com

https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/

https://www.rappler.com/newsbreak/inside-track/robin-padilla-prosecutors-one-sided-job/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here