A vital ruling due on Monday, March 23, might take a look at whether or not Philippine courts will hold sustaining expenses which have already been thrown out in case after case — and power a reckoning with a nationwide safety equipment that has handled due course of as an impediment fairly than a proper.

A Tacloban court docket is set to rule March 23 on motions to rethink the terrorism financing conviction of journalist Frenchie Mae Cumpioand on her proper to bail whereas she appeals a sentence of as much as 18 years.

After greater than six years behind bars — most of it spent in pretrial detention — the end result may very well be decisive, not only for her however for the handfuls of assist employees, organizers, and neighborhood activists who’ve been swept up in the identical authorized equipment that imprisoned her.

The timing issues. Simply weeks earlier than the ruling, a regional trial court docket in Tacloban dismissed all terrorism financing charges in opposition to Jazmin Jerusalem, the 65-year-old government director of the Leyte Heart for Growth and Empowerment (LCDE). The Feb. 27 ruling by Choose Georgina Uy Perez was sweeping: not solely did it reject the costs in opposition to Jerusalem for lack of a legally operative terrorist designation on the time of the alleged acts, it dismissed the case with prejudice — that means the prosecution can’t refile on the identical info. Every week earlier, a separate Manila court docket had additionally lifted a provisional asset preservation order in opposition to LCDE after the Anti-Cash Laundering Council did not hyperlink the group’s accounts to any illegal exercise.

Collectively, these dismissals kind a sample that’s more and more tough for the Philippine nationwide safety institution to disregard. Courts throughout the nation have rejected terrorism financing expenses in opposition to activists, rural assist employees, labor organizers, and clergy — most often as a result of the proof was constructed on the unverified testimony of alleged former rebels, or on the authorized fiction that home felony legal responsibility might connect to a international terrorist designation that was by no means correctly printed within the Philippines.

What has not modified is the tempo at which new charges continue to be filed.

Who higher to focus on than these they’ve at all times focused: activists?

UNDERSTANDING why these circumstances hold going even after courts throw them out requires understanding what the prosecution of terrorism financing within the Philippines has actually been about.

In 2021, the Financial Action Task Force (FATF), the worldwide intergovernmental watchdog on cash laundering and illicit finance, positioned the Philippines on its “gray record,” a designation that alerts deficiencies in a rustic’s programs to fight terrorism financing and cash laundering, and topics it to elevated worldwide scrutiny. For a authorities that had pledged to ship the nation off that record, the strain was huge and the answer, it turned out, was easy: prosecute extra folks. And who higher to focus on than these they’ve at all times focused: activists?

Human Rights Watch warned in February 2025 that Philippine authorities had been utilizing FATF’s grey-listing as cowl to file “baseless terrorism-financing expenses in opposition to civil society teams and activists.” The report’s findings had been blunt: many of the circumstances concerned not real terrorist financing however folks and teams accused of hyperlinks to the Communist Celebration of the Philippines and the New Folks’s Military — assist employees, journalists, clergy, union officers, humanitarian organizations — primarily based largely on testimonies from alleged insurgent defectors whose claims courts have repeatedly discovered to be uncorroborated.

The Philippine Heart for Investigative Journalism obtained a police memorandum that made the technique express. The operation to construct terrorism financing circumstances in opposition to activists was codenamed “Challenge Exit the Greylist.”

The Philippines was faraway from the FATF gray record in February 2025. The circumstances in opposition to activists and humanitarian teams haven’t stopped.

Because the HRW World Report 2026 documented, even after the FATF delisting, new terrorism financing expenses continued to be filed in opposition to civil society organizations and their members. The equipment, as soon as constructed, doesn’t stand down.

Not technicalities however minimal necessities for felony prosecution in a constitutional democracy

IN THE Jerusalem case, prosecutors relied on affidavits from 4 alleged former rebels who claimed she had funneled LCDE’s improvement funds to the NPA. The court docket discovered no impartial proof of any conspiracy, and famous that co-conspirator testimony, below Philippine guidelines of proof, can’t stand alone with out corroboration. It additionally discovered that no legitimate home terrorist designation existed on the time the alleged acts had been dedicated. A international or supranational designation, the court docket dominated, can’t have authorized power within the Philippines except it has been printed in accordance with the Terrorism Financing Prevention and Suppression Act.

These will not be technicalities. They’re the minimal necessities for felony prosecution in a constitutional democracy.

Within the Cumpio case, Reporters Without Borders (RSF) investigated the proof and located indicators that the weapons cited within the authentic expenses had been planted. Cumpio herself testified that she and her co-accused had been pressured to show away through the raid. The court docket finally acquitted her on the firearms and explosives expenses — the identical expenses that justified her preliminary detention and the denial of bail for years. It then convicted her on the terrorism financing cost, counting on witnesses RSF stated had been “below the shut watch of the army” and had appeared in a number of comparable prosecutions.

That conviction is now the topic of the March 23 movement for reconsideration.

The Nationwide Union of Peoples’ Legal professionals (NUPL), which has dealt with a number of of those circumstances, described the pattern bluntly: “Terrorism and terrorism financing legal guidelines are getting used in opposition to human rights defenders and their organizations. That is lawfare, and its function is to paralyze the operations of organizations like LCDE that present providers to sectors and communities in remoted areas.”

A 2025 joint study by NUPL and the Council for Folks’s Growth and Governance discovered that 31% of civil society organizations surveyed had been accused of terrorism financing with out foundation, 62% skilled red-tagging, and 57% reported bodily surveillance.

Not simply an assault on journalism however a scientific marketing campaign in opposition to organized civil society

THE GLOBAL response to Cumpio’s case has been substantial. Five UN expertstogether with Particular Rapporteur Ben Saul, described her conviction as “deeply troubling” and referred to as for her launch on bail pending enchantment. UN Particular Rapporteur Irene Khan has flagged the extreme size of her pretrial detention. Greater than 340 journalists and journalism unions have referred to as on President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. to safe her freedom. The One Free Press Coalition listed her case among the many world’s 10 most pressing press freedom conditions in 2025.

All of this consideration is warranted, despite the fact that a lot of it got here late. However it additionally displays a persistent tendency in worldwide press freedom advocacy to middle the journalist on the expense of the broader story.

Frenchie Mae Cumpio’s case shouldn’t be, at its core, a press freedom case. It’s a civil society case wherein a journalist occurs to be essentially the most outstanding sufferer. Her co-accused, Marielle Domequil — a church lay employee convicted alongside her and sentenced to the identical 12 to 18 years — has acquired a fraction of the worldwide consideration, regardless of being in exactly the identical authorized jeopardy and having spent the identical six years behind bars.

And Cumpio and Domequil are simply two of dozens. Jerusalem, a UN award-winning catastrophe reduction employee who has served Japanese Visayas communities because the Eighties, particularly within the wake of the devastation of typhoon Haiyan in 2013, spent greater than a 12 months below lively prosecution earlier than the costs had been dismissed.

Group journalist Deo Montesclaros of Pinoy Weekly faces terrorism financing expenses in Cagayan Valley. Felipe Gelle, a farmers’ rights advocate, faces comparable expenses in Negros Occidental, at the same time as courts have already dismissed similar expenses in opposition to his colleagues. The Cebu-based Community Empowerment Resource Network was pressured to dissolve solely after the federal government filed terrorism financing expenses in opposition to 27 of its workers members and froze its accounts.

Press freedom organizations framing this primarily as an assault on journalism — and directing their campaigns nearly solely at Cumpio — inadvertently reinforce the federal government’s personal implicit argument: that that is an remoted case involving a selected particular person, fairly than a scientific marketing campaign in opposition to organized civil society. That framing lets the federal government handle the optics by pointing to Marcos’ said dedication to press freedom, whereas the machine grinds on in opposition to everybody else.

The actual story is the machine.

What has labored, irrespective of how imperfectly, are the courts

THE Nationwide Activity Drive to Finish Native Communist Armed Battle (NTF-ELCAC), is the institutional engine behind most of those prosecutions. It’s a state physique that coordinates army, police, and prosecutorial motion in opposition to organizations it designates as communist fronts — a course of that requires no judicial discovering, no due course of, and no normal of proof. Red-tagging by NTF-ELCAC has preceded nearly each terrorism financing prosecution involving civil society.

Marcos has repeatedly pledged to uphold press freedom whereas affirming he’ll never abolish NTF-ELCAC. That isn’t a contradiction he seems troubled by.

Worldwide strain, thus far, has been largely declaratory. UN rapporteurs challenge statements. Coalition letters flow into. Press freedom rankings are cited — the Philippines positioned 116th out of 180 countries within the 2025 RSF World Press Freedom Index. None of this has been enough to compel both an acquittal in Cumpio’s case or a real reform of the prosecution structure.

What has labored, irrespective of how imperfectly, are the courts.

In case after casejudges have discovered that the proof in these circumstances can’t stand up to scrutiny. That isn’t nothing. However courts can’t reform a system on their very own, particularly when prosecutors hold submitting and the Anti-Cash Laundering Council retains freezing belongings no matter what courts do. Jerusalem’s funds, as an illustration, remain frozen even after each the terrorism financing case and the asset forfeiture case in opposition to her had been dismissed. The AMLC has not returned them.

Courts want to use their very own rulings persistently and with prejudice the place the info warrant — because the Jerusalem dismissal did. The AMLC must unfreeze what the courts have already cleared. The FATFwhose compliance framework has been explicitly weaponized by the Philippine authorities, should be pressed by its member states – all of them from developed nations, largely from Europe –  to implement its personal Recommendation 8which requires governments to take a risk-based method that doesn’t hurt respectable nonprofit exercise. Prosecution quantity shouldn’t be a measure of institutional integrity. Donor nations which have offered the Philippines with technical help on terrorism financing — Australia chief amongst them — ought to take that severely.

The March 23 ruling is a take a look at of whether or not Philippine courts will maintain what’s, by now, a visibly failing marketing campaign — one which has generated dismissal after dismissal, drawn condemnation from the United Nations and different our bodies, and left harmless folks in pretrial detention for years at a time, with out essentially the most fundamental assure of bail. The courts have been saying no. The query is who else within the authorities will. (Carlos H. Conde / Rights Report Philippines)

https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/

https://mindanews.com/mindaviews/2026/03/analysis-philippines-terrorism-financing-machine-is-breaking-down-in-court-but-the-damage-keeps-spreading/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here