The Supreme Court (SC) has declared unconstitutional a provision within the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers. Teams had beforehand criticized the supply as discriminatory as a result of it requires seafarers who initially win in instances to put up a bond whereas their shipowner or manpower company is interesting the choice.

The Excessive Court docket likewise voided different provisions within the legislation and different issuances associated to it.

In a call penned by Affiliate Justice Maria Filomena Singh, the Excessive Court docket en banc partially granted the 5 consolidated petitions difficult the legality of Republic Act (RA) No. 12021, or the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers. The petitions likewise questioned sure provisions of the legislation’s Implementing Guidelines and Laws (IRR), in addition to associated authorities issuances.

Petitioners include labor lawyer Sonny Matulaa number of seafarers, labor organizations, and maritime academic establishments.

“The Court docket emphasised that though the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers was enacted to advance the welfare of Filipino seafarers, all legislative measures should conform to the Structure. The legislation due to this fact stays legitimate and enforceable, apart from the provisions expressly declared unconstitutional or void,” mentioned the ruling penned by Singh.



Signed by President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. in 2024, the Magna Carta clarifies the rights of Filipino seafarers — simply working situations, proper to prepare, and freedom from discrimination.

Bond fee is unconstitutional

The ruling voided the legislation’s Part 59 or the requirement for Filipino seafarers who had already gained their labor disputes to put up a bond or fee, whereas their shipowners or companies are interesting the victory earlier than courts. The bond requirement was supposedly meant to make sure restitution or financial reward, ought to the case be subsequently reversed or modified.

Teams challenged this as a result of the one probability for seafarers to be reimbursed for the bond they put up is that if they win their case.

The Excessive Court docket sided with the petitioners and dominated that this bond requirement violates due course of and equal safety clauses beneath the 1987 Structure.

The SC mentioned this rule imposes a monetary burden on seafarers in search of to implement favorable labor judgments, and topics them to a drawback “not equally imposed on different staff.”

“Whereas recognizing the State’s curiosity in stopping ambulance chasing and defending the maritime trade towards unrestituted awards, the Court docket discovered that these aims didn’t justify the challenged restriction on the execution of financial awards,” mentioned the SC.

The SC additionally declared unconstitutional the authorization to make use of the Division of Migrant Staff’ (DMW) Agarang Kalinga at Saklolo Para sa mga OFW na Nangangailangan (AKSYON) Fund to pay for the bond premiums. The Excessive Court docket mentioned this mechanism failed the constitutional requirement that public funds must be used for a public goal, as discovered beneath Part 29(1), Article VI of the 1987 Structure.

“Sections 4 and 5, Rule III of Division of Labor and Employment (DOLE) Division Order No. 247, Sequence of 2025, had been likewise declared unconstitutional and void insofar as they applied the bond requirement,” the Excessive Court docket added.


SC declares parts of Magna Carta of Seafarers unconstitutional.  So what?

“Nice, ultimately, our petition was resolved by the SC. This a excellent news. That is victory for staff particularly the seafarers,” Matula informed Rappler.

“We argued (that Part 59) is discriminatory. It violates the equal safety clause of the 1987 Structure as a result of land-based staff don’t face this requirement. We additionally contend that it creates an unfair monetary burden on sick, injured, or unemployed seafarers,” he added.

Extra unconstitutional guidelines

The SC additionally struck down Part 60 of RA No. 12021, in addition to Part 4 of RA No. 10706, or the Seafarers Safety Act. The Excessive Court docket mentioned these provisions regulated the observe of legislation, which is a violation of Part 5(5), Article VIII of the 1987 Structure.

Petitioners challenged these sections as a result of they regulate lawyer-seafarer contracts and cap contingent authorized charges at 10%.

“Petitioners argue that this rule (Part 60) usurps the unique constitutional energy of the Supreme Court docket to manage the observe of legislation and will limit seafarers’ entry to competent authorized counsel,” mentioned Matula.

The SC defined that whereas the legislative division might create legal guidelines to guard seafarers from attorneys’ alleged abusive practices like ambulance chasing, amongst others, the regulation of attorneys’ skilled conduct and the observe of the legislation stays beneath the Excessive Court docket’s unique authority.

Ambulance chasing refers back to the observe of attorneys of soliciting skilled employment.

Aside from the mentioned provisions, the SC additionally declared unconstitutional Part 1, Rule XXII, of the legislation’s IRR. It is because it applies Part 59 to financial rewards from complaints filed on or after the magna carta’s effectivity.

“The Court docket discovered that the implementing provision contravened Part 94 of the legislation, which expressly preserves the rights, privileges and advantages beforehand loved by Filipino seafarers earlier than its effectivity. It reiterated that administrative rules should conform to the statute they implement and can’t diminish rights expressly preserved by legislation,” mentioned the SC.

On maritime training

In the meantime, the Court docket denied the problem to the legislation’s Sections 75, 76, and 78, as a result of it mentioned they don’t violate constitutional assure of educational freedom.

  • Part 75 – States that the Maritime Trade Authority (MARINA) has jurisdiction over maritime training within the nation.
  • Part 76 – Requires shipboard coaching for worldwide maritime diploma applications. MARINA determines the applicability of the coaching, together with the period.
  • Part 78 – Requires maritime increased academic establishments providing worldwide maritime diploma applications to have their very own coaching ships, simulators, or associated applied sciences. This additionally requires them to enter into agreements with native or worldwide transport corporations, shipowners, or companies for the shipboard coaching program of scholars or cadets.

The Philippine Affiliation of Maritime Establishments, Inc. and different maritime academic establishments questioned these provisions earlier than the SC.

In its ruling, the SC mentioned tutorial freedom ensures the autonomy of upper academic establishments, however this freedom doesn’t exempt them from affordable rules.

“(The Court docket) discovered that the challenged provisions established minimal regulatory requirements supposed to make sure the standard of maritime training, the competency of Filipino seafarers, and compliance with relevant worldwide maritime requirements. Notably, the necessities regarding enrollment and obtainable shipboard coaching alternatives had been thought-about affordable measures to handle the provision of sensible coaching for maritime college students,” mentioned the SC.

“The prohibition towards charging tuition or matriculation charges for shipboard coaching carried out by third celebration suppliers was likewise sustained as a measure towards unjustified expenses,” it added.


More Filipino seafarers are being abandoned at sea

The petitioners additionally questioned the legislative course of resulting in the magna carta’s passage. However the SC denied this particular problem and upheld the procedural validity of the legislation.

It discovered that Congress complied with the constitutional necessities in passing a legislation, such because the three-reading rule beneath Article VI of the Structure.

“The Court docket likewise upheld the President’s Certification of Urgency and acknowledged the authority of the Bicameral Convention Committee to reconcile variations between the Home and Senate variations of the proposed laws,” the SC added. – Rappler.com

https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/

https://www.rappler.com/philippines/supreme-court-decision-parts-magna-carta-seafarers-unconstitutional-why-matters/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here