The Supreme Court (SC) has clarified an vital authorized idea that might profit same-sex relationships: Gay {couples} who reside collectively could now be thought of as co-owners of their properties.

Ruling on the Josef v. Ursua case, the Excessive Courtroom stated that same-sex {couples} could also be acknowledged as property co-owners beneath Article 148 of the Household Code, so long as they’ve proof of precise contribution for the stated property.

Affiliate Justice Jhosep Lopez penned the 2nd Division’s ruling, with concurrences from Senior Affiliate Justice Marvic Leonen, and Affiliate Justices Amy Lazaro Javier, Mario Lopez (retired as of 2025), and Antonio Kho Jr.

“(This) a software for them to have the ability to assert their contribution to the acquisition of the property, a recognition that as a home accomplice, their share have to be revered and acknowledged,” household legislation practitioner and professor Flordeliza Vargas advised Rappler.

The case stemmed from a petition filed by Jennifer Josef in opposition to her former accomplice, Evalyn Ursua, to settle a property possession dispute. The 2 lived collectively as a pair and bought a home and lot, however each agreed to register the property beneath Ursua.

Once they separated, the 2 agreed to promote the property and divide the proceeds equally. Ursua even executed an acknowledgment, noting that Josef’s co-ownership of the property. However later, Ursua modified her thoughts, refusing to promote the property and acknowledge her former accomplice as a co-owner.

Josef introduced the case to the Regional Trial Courtroom (RTC), however her petition was denied. She later introduced the case to the Courtroom of Appeals, however to no avail, thus, submitting the petition with the Excessive Courtroom.

Other than granting Josef’s petition and acknowledging her co-ownership within the property, the SC remanded or returned the case to Quezon Metropolis RTC Department 87 for additional proceedings.

Courtroom’s rationalization

The choice dwelled on the nation’s Family Codewhich governs marriage, relationships, separations, and even property relations of households. On this particular case, the SC closely mentioned Articles 147 and 148 that cowl the properties of single people.

Article 147 explains {that a} man and a lady in a relationship, however not married, shall have equal shares to their wages and salaries. As to their properties, “acquired by each of them via their work or business,” they are going to be guided by the foundations on co-ownership.

In the meantime, Article 148 covers cohabitations which aren’t beneath the previous article. Underneath this provision, properties acquired by the couple via joint contribution “shall be owned by them in frequent in proportion to their respective contributions.”

In her petition, Josef stated that the 2 articles clearly shield the rights of heterosexual relationships with out the advantage of marriage, however the stated safety was not out there to gay {couples}.

“With this, there’s a clear lack of safety supplied by our legal guidelines, primarily the Household Code, given its inherent and discriminatory favor in direction of heterosexual {couples}, which deprives petitioner of her property rights and pursuits,” the petitioner stated.

The SC, within the ruling, acknowledged that the applying of those Household Code provisions amongst same-sex {couples} really grew to become a “nuanced query” within the authorized group.

The presence of the phrase “capacitated to marry one another” beneath Article 147 pertains to marriage, and beneath the Household Code, marriage is a union between a person and a lady. For the reason that petitioner and the respondent have the identical intercourse, they can’t marry one another, so Article 148 covers their property relations, the SC defined.

In response to the Excessive Courtroom, beneath Article 148, the properties acquired may be thought of frequent if:

  • The property had been acquired throughout cohabitation
  • There may be proof exhibiting that the properties had been acquired via precise joint contribution of cash, property, or business

“Contemplating that there’s co-ownership between petitioner and respondent, then every co-owner could demand at any time the partition of the factor owned in frequent, insofar as her share is anxious. Having rightful curiosity over the topic property, petitioner has the fitting to demand the division of the topic property,” the SC stated.


A wanted clarification

Citing Valdes v. Regional Trial Courtroom, Department 102, Quezon Metropolis, Leonen stated in his separate concurring opinion that Article 148 refers to any sort of cohabitation that doesn’t fall beneath Article 147. Though Article 147 is explicit in gender (man and lady), Article 148 will not be, he stated.

“In consequence, Article 148 can also govern the property relations of same-sex {couples} who cohabitate,” Leonen defined.

In response to Leonen, the nation’s legal guidelines ought to be interpreted to have a extra mature understanding of the complexities of relationships. And amongst these complexities, he stated, is the reality that there are same-sex {couples} who cohabitate with one another.

“To be completely different is to not be irregular. A same-sex relationship is a traditional relationship and due to this fact ought to be lined by Article 148 of the Household Code. In any other case, we render legally invisible some types of professional intimate relationships,” the senior Justice of the Peace added.

Lazaro-Javier, in her separate concurring opinion, stated Article 148’s first sentence is simply too basic and could also be interpreted to cowl even same-sex {couples}’ cohabitations.

“Given the prevailing values in trendy society in addition to the evident but unjustified distinction within the therapy of heterosexual {couples} vis-à-vis their gay counterparts, I don’t see any motive why the safety of Article 148 of the Household Code shouldn’t be prolonged to members of the LGBTQI+ group,” Lazaro-Javier stated.

The Josef v. Ursua case in the end settled the dialogue on the applicability of Article 148. Previous to the ruling on the case, College of the Philippines Faculty of Legislation Affiliate Dean Paolo Tamase stated it was not clear whether or not Article 148 might additionally apply to same-sex {couples}.

Vargas additionally shared the identical view: “In reality, in our ebook, Household Legislation Quantity II, we acknowledged that Artwork. 148 can apply to same-sex {couples}. The framers of our Household Code had no dialogue regarding its applicability solely to heterosexual {couples}.”

A win, however extra work forward

Though the Philippines has but to acknowledge same-sex unions, the Josef case is a significant improvement in guaranteeing the rights of gay {couples}. Vargas defined that the SC ruling is taken into account a win as a result of not less than a facet of their relationship — property relations — is now acknowledged beneath Philippine home legal guidelines.

“It may well have an effect on different elements of same-sex relationship as a result of there’s now a recognition beneath the legislation of their standing as a relationship that our legal guidelines want to acknowledge and shield,” Vargas stated.

“Whereas Congress will nonetheless have to enact legal guidelines that will likely be protecting of the rights of these in same-sex relationships, the ruling in Josef v. Ursua can influence asserting their proper to healthcare decision-making and their proper to inherit from their accomplice,” she added.


Fight for same-sex marriage in PH still alive despite Supreme Court ruling

Bahaghari chaiperson Reyna Valmores Salinas welcomed the SC ruling, calling it a landmark jurisprudence for the civil rights of LGBTQ+ members within the Philippines. Though this acknowledgment is a win by itself, like Vargas, Salinas believes that the nation nonetheless must enact different legal guidelines to make sure the rights of LGBTQ+ members.

“So greater than this ruling — a fantastic change in interpretation of the legislation the place LGBTQ+ Filipinos have been dismissed for therefore lengthy — we should name for a change within the legislation itself. It’s time we amend the Household Code and  institute marriage equality, in any other case often called same-sex marriage,” the Bahaghari chairperson stated.

The Philippine LGBT Chamber of Commerce additionally famous that the SC determination confirmed how far the group has come as same-sex {couples} can now take pleasure in a semblance of safety.

“As we construct on this progress, we proceed to name for the passage of the Equality Invoice; the creation of an LGBTQIA+ Enterprise Fund; incentives for Micro, Small, and Medium Queer Enterprises; free entry to state-led capability applications; LGBTQ+ illustration in public-private enterprise councils; and authorized recognition of the Proper to Care,” the group stated. – Rappler.com

https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/

https://www.rappler.com/newsbreak/in-depth/supreme-court-decision-same-sex-couples-co-ownership-properties/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here