MALAYBALAY CITY (MindaNews / 5 June 2026) – Did Senator Chiz Escudero’s attendance within the Senate session on Wednesday allow the minority to achieve a quorum? It might be recalled that the 24-member physique was delivered to a standstill after the bulk led by Senate President Alan Peter Cayetano refused to attend the session after an ally, Senator Jinggoy Estrada, was arrested for the non-bailable cost of plunder.

Estrada’s subsequent detention has left the bulk bloc with solely 11 members who can be a part of the deliberations and voting, as Senator Ronald dela Rosa went again into hiding after casting his vote in favor of Cayetano as Senate President. This was exactly why Cayetano’s group pushed for distant participation and voting to keep up the higher hand. However the minority sensed the scheme, and walked out to protest the obvious try to railroad present guidelines, resulting in the stalemate.

However Escudero, supposedly a member of the bulk bloc, attended the session on Wednesday the place Win Gatchalian was elected as Senate President Professional Tempore, giving the continued intramural a brand new, intriguing twist.

As anticipated, Cayetano, clearly conscious that he was shedding management of the chamber’s energy levers, referred to as the transfer unlawful and asserted that he’s nonetheless the Senate President.

The Palace, in the meantime, has acknowledged Gatchalian as Performing Senate President.

This state of affairs has made authorized minds flip to historical past that occurred 77 years in the past.

Avelino vs Cuenco

In 1949, the Supreme Court docket was requested to resolve a state of affairs of an identical nature confronting the Senate within the toddler years of the post-Struggle republic.

Twelve senators voted to oust Jose Avelino as Senate President after he adjourned the session and his allies walked out to stop Senator Lorenzo Tañada from delivering a privilege speech towards Avelino. The 12 senators who remained within the chamber voted to declare the Senate President’s place vacant and designated Mariano Cuenco as the brand new Senate President. At the moment, one senator, Tomas Confesor, was in another country.

Avelino filed a with which I warrant petition asking the Supreme Court docket to declare him the rightful Senate President and oust Cuenco.

The Court docket stored its arms off from the query of who was the legit Senate President, invoking the constitutional precept of separation of powers and the “political nature of the controversy.”

“The Court docket won’t sally into the legit area of the Senate on the plea that our refusal to intercede may lead right into a disaster, even a decision  No state of issues has been proved which may change the mood of the Filipino individuals as a peaceable and law-abiding residents. And we must always not permit ourselves to be stampeded right into a rash motion inconsistent with the calm that ought to characterised judicial deliberations,” it stated. (I assume the phrase “decision” is a typo. It’s possible “revolution” based mostly on the previous phrase “disaster”.)

The Court docket, nevertheless, dominated on whether or not there was a quorum on the time Cuenco’s group voted him as Senate President to help his designation, the place “being basically one which relies upon completely upon the desire of nearly all of the senators.” Additionally, a quorum is required for the Senate to transact (its) enterprise.

In its determination dated March 4, 1949 (G.R. No. L-2821), the Supreme Court docket dominated: When the Structure declares {that a} majority of “every Home” shall represent a quorum, “the Home: doesn’t imply “all” the members. Even a majority of all of the members represent “the Home”. (Missouri Pac. vs. Kansas, 63 Regulation ed. (U. S.), p. 239). There’s a distinction between a majority of “the Home”, the latter requiring much less quantity than the primary. Due to this fact an absolute majority (12) of all of the members of the Senate much less one (23), constitutes constitutional majority of the Senate for the aim of a quorum.

The Court docket additionally identified that Cuenco’s group had tried to compel the attendance of the absent senators, a constitutional requirement, however failed as a result of persevering with refusal of Avelino’s group to cooperate. What the Court docket was saying was that the Senate should not be paralyzed owing to the repetitive boycott by one group. The Court docket upheld public curiosity over technicality that might have rendered the Senate inutile.

Some could argue that this jurisprudence is already outdated because it was based mostly on the 1935 Structure. However be aware that the wording of the related provision stays the identical within the 1987 Structure – “A majority of every Home shall represent a quorum…”

The important thing right here could possibly be the usage of the article “a” as an alternative of “the”. “A” is an indefinite determiner in distinction to “the” which is a particular article. “The” would have meant reckoning the quorum based mostly on “all” the members of the Senate. Thus, it could actually solely imply that the way in which the framers of the Structure phrased the availability anticipated conditions that might require flexibility.

In Avelino vs Cuenco, the Court docket counted out the absent senator, Confesor, in figuring out whether or not there was a quorum or not. Notice that Confesor, not like Senators dela Rosa and Jinggoy Estrada, was not even a fugitive or in detention for an alleged crime however was merely on a international journey.

If and when the Cayetano bloc opts to carry the topic to the Court docket, how will the Justices view the absence of dela Rosa and Estrada? Dela Rosa’s whereabouts are unknown, whereas Estrada is legally barred from attending periods? Will it contemplate them past the “coercive energy” of the Senate to compel attendance, and so should be excluded in figuring out the quorum or majority?

(MindaViews is the opinion part of MindaNews. H. Marcos C. Mordeno may be reached at boymords@mindanews.com)

https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/

https://mindanews.com/mindaviews/2026/06/someone-elses-windows-the-senate-did-history-just-repeat-itself/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here