(Opening assertion of the Protection delivered by Lead Protection Counsel Sheila C. Sison, on Day 1 of the VP Sara Duterte impeachment trial on the Senate on 6 July 2026)

Your honors, fellow Filipinos, Good afternoon. 

As we start at the moment the impeachment trial of the Vice President, and within the days forward, this Courtroom will undertake its constitutional job of receiving and weighing the events’ proof and finally to determine whether or not these items of proof justify both a judgment of conviction or acquittal, guided solely by its members’ conscience and their solemn oath to do neutral justice. 

The current enterprise of this Courtroom, due to this fact, not solely carries the load of the Structure but in addition the imprint of our nation’s historical past as a result of the Filipino individuals have proven that they always remember.

We, as a nation, always remember. 

Atty. Sheila C. Sison, Protection Lead Counsel within the VP Sara Duterte Impeachment Trial. Screenshot from Senate Impeachment Courtroom

However why is the act of remembering necessary? What does it matter to our historical past and to extraordinary Filipinos?

As a result of on this trial, the Prosecution proposes that we unseat the Vice President elected to workplace by greater than 32 million Filipino individuals. Greater than the variety of votes solid for the sitting President, and far higher than any of the votes secured by every of the members of the Home of Representatives who now are right here to prosecute her and search to undo this  individuals’s alternative. 

Samakatuwid ang malinaw na layunin sa likod ng mga paratang na ito ay ang pagpapatalsik sa isang Bise Presidenteng inihalal ng mahigit tatlumpo’t dalawang milyong Pilipino at bunga ng kanilang malayang pagpapasiya. 

No matter one’s political persuasion is, the truth is that the Prosecution now comes earlier than this Courtroom to take away a Vice President chosen by an amazing variety of the voters. 

You all have heard the Prosecution say repeatedly that it’s because they search accountability. That the individuals have the appropriate to carry their leaders accountable. This isn’t a matter of debate. 

Certainly, the individuals have a proper to demand accountability from their leaders. What we have now but to listen to from the Prosecution, nevertheless, is that this: when the Structure declared below Part 1, Article 11, that public workplace is a public belief and that public officers and workers should always be accountable to the individuals, serve them with utmost accountability, integrity, loyalty, and effectivity, act with patriotism and justice, and lead modest lives, the Structure doesn’t solely converse to the Vice President.

Justice contains equity; with out equity, there may be abuse

It additionally calls for the identical requirements from the prosecutors. Being public officers themselves, the general public prosecutors and the members of the Home of Representatives are additionally held to the identical constitutional customary. 

And so we should bear in mind what historical past tells us.

This isn’t the primary time that members of the Home of Representatives have tried to take away the Vice President, and in a fashion not compliant with the Structure. 

In a July 2025 choice, the Supreme Courtroom unanimously declared in Duterte v. Home of Representatives, GR No. 278353 and 278359, that the impeachment proceedings within the Home of Representatives have been tainted with grave abuse of discretion, rendering the articles of impeachment that the Home transmitted final yr to the Senate as void ab initio.

Early this yr, the Supreme Courtroom unanimously denied with finality the Home of Representatives’ movement for reconsideration of that call, with a reminder that whereas impeachment is a strong democratic course of to name out corruption and grave abuse, impeachment will be abused, and that impeachment ought to by no means be abused to keep up the hegemonic dominance of greed by shaming those that occupy excessive authorities positions into stopping them from doing what they have been sworn to do.

However maybe probably the most enduring reminder of the Supreme Courtroom that we should not overlook in all the course of this trial is that within the phrases of the Courtroom, “the rule of legislation that does justice is our lodestar, and that justice contains accountability. Justice contains equity. With out equity, there may be abuse.”

This equity is what our democracy is all about. 

Basic authorized rules

It’s in gentle of those reminders that we draw consideration to sure basic authorized rules that we predict we should not overlook all through this trial, mga batayang prinsipyo na dapat nating tandaan sa buong panahon ng paglilitis na ito, ano man ang ating kulay o politika. 

If we’re to be true and trustworthy to our proclaimed values such because the pursuit of accountability, justice, and integrity in our system of presidency, then we should stay possessed of an unyielding resolve to make sure that the trial and judgment on this case are performed in accordance with the command of the Structure, the majesty of the legislation, and the self-discipline required by the foundations.

In any other case, those that stand in sanctimonious judgment of the Vice President will ship a transparent message that the legislation will be bent when it fits the comfort of the highly effective, and that justice will be sacrificed on the altar of partisan pursuits. 

Malagang tandaan ang mahigpit na paalala ng ating Korte Suprema. “Impeachment isn’t a purely political continuing. It’s primarily a authorized, political, and constitutional mechanism.” 

Ibig sabihin, kailangan naaayon sa batas at Konstitusyon ang anumang proseso nito. 

In keeping with the Structure, it’s the Senate that shall have the only real energy to try to determine all instances of impeachment. This energy isn’t shared.  The Structure offers no different physique, division, tribunal, company, or a mere committee of any of those establishments the facility to attempt an impeachment case. 

The Home merely initiates. The Senate tries. 

But, we have now seen the Committee on Justice conduct what its chairperson, the lead prosecutor on this case, described as a mini-trial, which, as all of us had witnessed, turned an enormous fishing expedition of alleged proof that weren’t even a part of the impeachment complaints below its consideration, and which the respondent accused was made to reply. 

In that mini-trial, we noticed how the purported items of proof have been curated to assemble a story in opposition to the Vice President even earlier than this case reaches trial.

Senate Impeachment Courtroom and Courtroom of Public Opinion 

The Articles of Impeachment introduced earlier than this Courtroom as an train of the Home’s energy to provoke impeachment instances are due to this fact, in sober reality, the product of an impermissible intrusion of clear constitutional boundaries. 

Over the course of the impeachment trial, the Prosecution will try to persuade this Courtroom and the Courtroom of Public Opinion that the allegations within the articles of impeachment are supported by supplies they obtained throughout their mini-trial and that proof exists to maintain a judgment of conviction. 

They may declare that the notices of suspension and disallowance issued by the COA and the COA choice denying the Vice President’s enchantment of that disallowance help their accusations, with the discharge of that call by the COA conveniently timed and coinciding with the Committee hearings.

They may declare that the certifications of the PSA verify their allegation that recipients of the confidential funds don’t exist, although they listed one Mary Grace Piattos of their pre-trial temporary as amongst their witnesses, or that the liquidation of the confidential funds in a span of 11 days was allegedly swift as to ask suspicion. 

The Prosecution will assert that the supposed NBI findings of comparable signatures throughout a variety of acknowledgment receipts submitted to the COA are supportive of their conclusion that the disbursements of the confidential funds have been irregular. 

What the Prosecution isn’t saying

What the Prosecution averted informing the general public to date are these:

  • that it was the then-Secretary of the Division of Funds and Administration, Amenah Pangandaman, who issued a Memorandum for the President via Government Secretary Lucas Bersamin on October 18, 2022, recommending the approval of the Workplace of the Vice President’s request for confidential funds; 
  • that the Workplace of the President did in truth approve that advice of the DBM via a Memorandum from the Government Secretary dated November 28, 2022, and signed by the previous Government Secretary Lucas Bersamin by order of the President; 
  • that on December 13, 2022, the DBM issued a Particular Allotment Order No. SARO-BMB-C-22-001-2004 signed by former Secretary Amenah Pangandaman to cowl the request of monetary help subsidy and confidential funds of the OVP that, however the approaching finish of the fiscal yr, the confidential funds have been nonetheless launched to the OVP on December 20, 2022, below this documented approval course of; 
  • that the COA choice is much from being last, that there’s a pending movement for reconsideration of that call, that, assuming arguendo, the COA denies that MR at the moment, or whereas this trial is ongoing, as might plausibly occur below the circumstances, the respondent accused nonetheless has authorized cures out there below the legislation and guidelines, and may file a petition to query the validity of any forthcoming decision of the COA on the MR below Rule 64 by way of petition for certiorari below Rule 65 of the Guidelines of Courtroom, and, extra importantly, that nothing within the Discover of Disallowance or COA choice states any findings of supposed misuse of confidential funds as confirmed by Legal professional Gloria Camara when she was requested on this level throughout the committee listening to on April 14, 2026.

Burden of proof by no means shifts

Throughout all different Articles, the Prosecution will lay a panorama of what it deems to be their proof in help of their speculations and conclusions. 

We’re not strangers to all these accusations exactly as a result of this was not the primary time these narratives have been foisted into the minds of most people. We’ve heard the identical tales and tales of those accusations since 2024, when the Home carried out its Quad Com hearings and, most lately, the mini-trial of its Committee on Justice.

However what we should not overlook amid all these accusations is the elemental authorized precept that the burden of proof by no means shifts. 

The burden of proof by no means shifts. He who accuses should show his allegations with proof that meets not solely the diploma of proof required but in addition meets the evidentiary requirements of admissibility, credibility, relevance, materiality, and competence. 

We due to this fact shouldn’t lose sight of the core precept that the burden of proof is on the Prosecution, and until it discharges that burden, the accused needn’t even provide proof on her behalf andt she might be entitled to an acquittal.

That is the legislation then. That is the legislation now. And the underlying precept for this burden of proof is easy: below our Structure, each accused is presumed harmless till confirmed in any other case. 

Invoice of Rights as defend

An accused has in her favor the presumption of innocence which the Invoice of Rights ensures. This additionally brings to fore the truth that, within the phrases of the Supreme Courtroom in Individuals v. Pagal, the person citizen is however the speck of particle or molecule vis-a-vis the huge and overwhelming powers of presidency, and his solely assure in opposition to oppression and tyranny are his basic liberties below the Invoice of Rights which defend him in instances of want. 

Sa madaling salita, kinikilala ng ating Saligang Batas na sa bawat paglilitis, ang isang particular person ay nahaharap sa malalim at napakalaking makinarya ng buong Estado, at ang tanging sandigan lamang niya laban sa anumang pangaabusa ng kapangyarihan ay ang kanyang mga batayang karapatan sa ilalim ng ating Konstitusyon.

Kaya’t mahalagang linawid na sa gitna ng pagtatangkang ikondisyon ang kaisipan ng mamamayang Pilipino at sa gitna ng walang humpay na komentaryo sa mga pampublikong espasyo, wala pang maituturing na anumang ebidensya o aligasyon na napapatunayan ng prosekusyon sa simpleng dahilan na ang bawat ebidensya ay kailangang dumaan muna sa paglilitis at pagsusuri ng korteng could kapangyarihan sa ilalaim ng ating Saligang Batas. 

Higit sa lahat, ang anumang paglilitis ay kailangang naayon sa itinatakda ng ating batas at Structure at hindi lamang sa kagustuhan ng iilang could hawak ng kapangyarihan. 

One would possibly ask, why is it necessary that we should not overlook these fundamental rules?

The ruling of the Supreme Courtroom tells us why: the Invoice of Rights applies to all the impeachment course of as a result of inasmuch as our courtroom acknowledges that impeachment is a political course of, it reminds us that it isn’t a purely political course of however a authorized and constitutional mechanism.

Thus, if we’re to uphold the rule of legislation, serve justice, and invoke the accountability mechanism, then this Courtroom and we as a individuals should assure, that every one efforts to carry our leaders accountable, should be performed proper. 

This we should not overlook. 

I thank the courtroom and the general public for the privilege of your time. Could God bless our nation. 

https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/

https://mindanews.com/mindaviews/2026/07/the-burden-of-proof-never-shifts-all-efforts-to-hold-our-leaders-accountable-must-be-done-right/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here