COTABATO CITY (MindaNews / 29 June 2026) — There’s a silence in Philippine politics that at all times comes earlier than a giant political defection. It’s not the silence of doubt. It’s the silence of a executed deal. The deal is just ready to be revealed on the proper time. Earlier than a senator even crosses the ground or a mayor adjustments political occasion affiliation, it’s all over. The general public sees a present. They don’t see the negotiation. That is what makes occasion switching so damaging to democracy.
Two latest instances present this. One is the collapse of Alan Peter Cayetano’s Senate majority in June 2026. The opposite is Cotabato Metropolis Mayor Bruce Matabalao’s transfer from the UBJP to the brand new Bangsamoro Federalist Celebration (BFP), in the identical month. The Senate case is effectively documented. The Cotabato case just isn’t as clear. Nonetheless, it raises actual issues. We must always deal with the 2 instances in a different way.
Senator Chiz Escudero got here again to attend a Senate session on June third, following weeks of supporting the bloc of Cayetano (Tamayo, Valente, 2026). With this, the numbers modified, enabling Senator Sherwin Gatchalian’s bloc to proclaim that the Senate presidency was vacant. After two weeks, one other Senator, Joel Villanueva, give up the bloc of Cayetano and pledged his assist to Gatchalian, making it 13 (Oliquino, 2026; Sarao, 2026).
This was not simply guesswork about secret offers. Senator Panfilo Lacson stated Senator JV Ejercito personally secured Villanueva’s vote. Ejercito informed Lacson late at evening on June 16 that “it’s executed” (Tamayo, 2026). It is a actual instance of personal dealing, and sealed the evening earlier than a public vote. Earlier studies had already marked Sen. Villanueva as a straightforward goal resulting from his involvement in a corruption scandal (Oliquino, 2026). We don’t know if he was provided something particularly. However we all know this sort of strain was already occurring within the Senate earlier than his change.
Escudero and Villanueva each stated they weren’t taking sides. They stated they only wished the Senate to maintain working (Oliquino, 2026). However Cayetano later stated he understood “the pressures that had been delivered to bear” on Villanueva, with out saying what these pressures had been (Oliquino, 2026). That line, paired with Ejercito’s late-night name, suggests one thing actual had been provided.
Cotabato Metropolis is totally different. Mayor Matabalao received twice beneath the UBJP, the political arm of the MILF. He resigned on 10 June 2026. The next day, he joined the BFP and was appointed vice chairman of the occasion (Cabrera, 2026b). He stated the choice got here after months of personal reflection, together with time throughout his Hajj pilgrimage.
No report exhibits a dealer arranging Matabalao’s change, the way in which Ejercito organized Villanueva’s. He has denied the apparent model of a bribe declare. What we do know is that this choice, which pulled half the town council and several other barangay officers with him, was made completely in personal for months (Cabrera, 2026b). Even his personal occasion solely realized about it when his resignation letter arrived. There was no public debate. Voters by no means obtained a say.
One element provides ambiguity to the state of affairs. In April 2026, Matabalao posted that nobody had pressured him to modify events, and that he remained loyal to UBJP (Matabalao, 2026). Weeks later, Chief Minister Macacua visited his workplace, saying the purpose was to reconcile with a former working mate (Dimapalao, 2026). Quickly after that go to, Matabalao defected to the very occasion that already backed Macacua’s personal political plans. No report explains that hole. It’s a honest query, not proof of a deal.
This sample just isn’t new. Students have lengthy studied it. Hutchcroft and Rocamora (2003) confirmed that Philippine events act as non permanent automobiles, not carriers of perception, which is why leaving them prices so little. Kasuya (2009) described how politicians chase whoever holds energy, a sample seen within the management posts handed out after the Senate reorganization. Teehankee (2013) known as this turncoatism “sweetheart,” after the end result of the multi-sided political contest, as a result of events are constructed round folks, not platforms. Quimpo (2008) framed this as a system the place personal bargains get unveiled later within the language of conscience.
The true hazard just isn’t that politicians change events. Some motion is regular. The hazard is that the general public by no means sees the second that issues: the negotiation, or at the least the deliberation. Voters can decide a document. They can’t decide a personal discuss they had been by no means proven. Till events construct actual self-discipline, and the press begins asking who brokered a deal and when, residents will hold watching politics as a completed present, not a course of they had been ever a part of.
(MindaViews is the opinion part of MindaNews. Datu Al-Zahid Hanok Salik is a college member of the School of Arts and Sciences, Mindanao State College—Maguindanao. He’s a Grasp’s scholar in Political Science, specializing in Worldwide Relations, at Universitas Islam Internasional Indonesia. His thesis is titled “The Unbroken Path: Imamanism and Historic Continuity in Bangsamoro Political Thought.”)
https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/
https://mindanews.com/mindaviews/2026/06/commentary-the-quiet-room-where-loyalty-dies-secrecy-and-the-architecture-of-political-betrayal/



