(Opening Assertion of  lawyer Joel Butuyan, widespread authorized consultant for victims, on the Affirmation of Expenses listening to  within the Worldwide Prison Courtroom on Monday, 23 February 2026 at The Hague within the Netherlands)

Madame President, Your Honors, by means of a gap assertion, we convey the views and considerations of the 497 victims approved to take part in these proceedings.

On the outset, Your Honors, we talk the very deep disappointment of the victims on the choice permitting Rodrigo Duterte to not be current on this stage of affirmation of expenses. 

The sight of Mr. Duterte being learn and being confronted with the grave and horrible expenses towards him would have constituted an important element of justice for the victims. This case symbolically represents the final boat that the victims can board to go on a journey in the hunt for justice for his or her family members who had been brutally killed upon the orders of Mr. Duterte.

If this Chamber prevents the boat from crusing by not confirming the fees, the victims will without end be moored in an island the place the nights are crammed with the screams and cries of their massacred family members. There may be completely no different recourse for the victims. 

At least former Philippine Justice Secretary Crispin Remulla admitted only a few months in the past that the door to home justice is completely closed for victims of the Duterte extrajudicial killings.

Remulla declared, and we quote, “It’s tough to show the case right here and construct up the case as a result of those that want to talk are concerned within the crime. There’s nothing, not even a police report. You don’t have a scene of the crime. You don’t have ballistics. You don’t have DNA.”

Remulla additional declared, and I quote, “Every part that could possibly be erased was erased in order that the circumstances wouldn’t push by way of. That’s the reason this has reached the ICC.”

Beneath the Philippine justice system, Your Honors, no legal case can attain the courts except they’re initiated and filed by the Division of Justice or the Workplace of the Ombudsman. 

From Justice Secretary, Remulla has been appointed as Ombudsman. So the 2 gatekeepers of justice are successively occupied by a rating official who has declared that there’s completely no hope for home justice for the victims. 

If the fees will not be confirmed on this case, one of many gravest considerations of the victims is that Mr. Duterte will return to the Philippines as a conquering hero. He’ll resume preaching his gospel of impunity.

Actually, if Mr. Duterte might threaten to slap the judges of this nation, the sort of terror-filled threats and the violent actions that may simply be used towards the victims if the suspect walks free from this courtroom. 

If the fees will not be confirmed, it’s a very critical concern of the victims that Mr. Duterte might be portrayed in historical past by his multitude of followers because the chief who vanquished the ICC and who cleansed his nation of 30,000 rapists, murderers, and harmful criminals, which had been the scornful phrases he sweepingly used towards all those that had been killed in his murderous spree. 

Your Honors, Mr. Duterte has been in detention right here in The Hague for nearly a yr now. However there was no peace and relaxation for the victims. From the time their family members had been killed and constantly as much as this time, they reside in fixed concern for his or her lives. 

The arrest and detention of Mr. Duterte has not stopped impunity within the Philippines.

The virus of impunity that he unfold everywhere in the nation has grow to be a most cancers that has metastasised, infecting thousands and thousands of Filipinos. Mr. Duterte has created clones of himself. He transformed thousands and thousands of peace-loving residents into bloodthirsty disciples who’ve grow to be converts to the idea that violence and killings are legitimate options to societal issues.

The killings masterminded by Mr. Duterte proceed to have penalties for the victims, even to this present day, due to his clones. These mini Dutertes harass, threaten, or commit outright violence towards the victims and their households. 

As proven by the variety of victims taking part on this continuing to date, many nonetheless concern to come back out and inform their tales of how their lives turned a dwelling hell on account of Mr. Duterte’s crimes, and since they’re continually fearful of being focused with violence by Duterte fanatics.

Many victims have been hesitant to take part on this ICC case as a result of they reside in communities that thrive with Duterte clones. They see the halls of energy of their nation teeming with Duterte disciples. They see and listen to senators, congresspersons, mayors, governors, and highly effective public figures who’re mini Dutertes.

The daughter of Mr. Duterte is the Vice President, and she or he has only recently declared that she is operating for President in 2028. One Duterte son is a congressman, one other is the Davao Metropolis mayor, and his grandchildren occupy positions of energy. 

The plague of impunity has unfold not solely amongst Filipinos within the Philippines, however even amongst expatriate Filipinos in faraway lands like right here in The Hague.

Once we reported to the victims that we, their exterior authorized representatives, really feel like fugitives who keep away from our personal countrymen right here in The Hague

(opening assertion lower brief because it was 11 a.m. time for a 30-minute break).

Thanks, Your Honors.

I used to be within the means of explaining the unfold of impunity within the Philippines, and I’ll resume, Your Honors. 

The plague of impunity has unfold not solely amongst Filipinos within the Philippines, however even amongst expatriate Filipinos in faraway lands like right here in The Hague. 

Once we reported to the victims that we, their exterior authorized representatives, really feel like fugitives who keep away from our personal countrymen right here in The Hague, as a result of chances are high they’re Duterte clones, they expressed their utmost concern that if we, their attorneys, really feel threatened by mini Dutertes in another country, we should always think about the much more intense concern they reside with every single day of their communities teeming with mini Dutertes.

The victims additionally want to convey that if the judges of this Honorable Chamber could be subjected to on-line harassment by Duterte clones, we should always think about the extent of vulnerability the victims are uncovered to of their poor villages. 

Your Honors, there is just one answer to cease the impunity propagated by Mr. Duterte from persevering with to deliver hurt and struggling to the victims, and that’s for this Honorable Chamber to substantiate the fees in order that witnesses can testify and proof could be offered on the horrible crimes dedicated by Mr. Duterte. The testimonies and proof offered will inoculate these mini Dutertes from the virus of impunity that has contaminated them.

When they’ll see and listen to the utter cruelty, the sheer brutality, in different phrases, the brazen inhumanity of the crimes dedicated by Mr. Duterte, and the humanity of these whose lives had been violently taken, it should rekindle the embers of humanity that also stay of their hearts. 

Many of those mini Dutertes or Duterte clones are literally victims of huge doses of pretend information broadly circulated on-line. They have to be vaccinated with the reality, and the reality vaccine can solely come from the testimonies of witnesses, of victims and proof offered in a trial earlier than this courtroom.

Fact is the antidote to the virus of impunity, Your Honors. 

The victims dread a future the place expenses will not be confirmed on this case. It’s going to imply that the virus of impunity will proceed to unfold and infect many extra.

Victims concern that Duterte clones will grow to be a fair larger group that may elect one other apostle of impunity because the Philippines’ subsequent chief. If that occurs, an much more critical situation of impunity can happen within the Philippines, presumably worse than the orgy of violence that occurred from 2011 to 2019, and this time there might be no ICC to run to for help and assist.

The victims humbly beseech this Honorable Chamber to reaffirm the 2 essential targets of the ICC recognized within the Preamble of the Rome Statute.

First, to prosecute and punish probably the most critical crimes that deeply shock the conscience of humanity, and second, to place an finish to impunity and to contribute to the prevention of crimes of unimaginable atrocities. 

If this Chamber confirms the fees, this Courtroom will obtain its first goal of prosecuting, and if convicted, punishing Mr. Duterte for the unspeakable crimes he’s charged with. However attaining the primary goal won’t robotically make this Courtroom attain its second goal.

Merely placing ahead the proof gathered and the idea of legal responsibility of the prosecution won’t essentially resolve this Courtroom’s second goal. This Courtroom ought to permit victims to testify, and the file of the proceedings should replicate the harrowing experiences of these impacted by humanity. It’s the view and the brutality, in different phrases, the utter inhumanity of the crimes masterminded by Mr. Duterte, in order that the individuals who adore and idolize him, the individuals who have grow to be disciples of impunity, will see for themselves the inhumanity of the suspect.

For this to occur, the fees ought to all be confirmed. 

The virus of impunity that has unfold everywhere in the Philippines could be very grave and critical, Your Honours. Think about a frontrunner like Mr. Duterte, who proudly and publicly proclaimed his aspirations of following the footsteps of Adolf Hitler when he mentioned, quote, Hitler massacred 3 million Jews. “Now there are three million drug addicts. I’d be blissful to slaughter them.” And but, he’s worshipped by an enormous variety of Filipinos.

In so many nations, you have to to cover your adoration of Hitler. Mr. Duterte flaunted it, and his fanatics are unaffected by it. Mr. Duterte has pronounced so many different horrible declarations meant to advertise and encourage impunity, as it is going to be detailed tomorrow by my colleagues.

And but, he’s idolized by a mess of Filipinos. The Protection will declare that he was merely bombastic and acerbic when he made these statements. But when he had been merely being pompous and flippant, the individuals who had been killed needs to be alive and laughing as we speak at his supposed pranks and stunts.

Mr. Duterte didn’t solely order the mass killing of individuals suspected of being drug personalities, Your Honors. He smeared them with accusations of being rapists, murderers, and harmful criminals. Mr. Duterte imposed an rigid condemnation that if you’re a drug persona, you might be robotically a harmful legal who has engaged in unimaginable atrocities.

The households of these killed didn’t solely endure the lack of a cherished one, their households had been even disgraced with being related to a rapist, assassin, or harmful legal. 

Even after their family members had been murdered, many households had been subjected to deplorable injustices. As a substitute of gunshot wounds as reason for dying of their dying certificates, households had been shocked to see pneumonia, coronary heart assault, stroke, sepsis, and different false causes of dying that had been as a substitute written down.

Different households had been charged substantial quantities, sums the impoverished households couldn’t afford, simply to retrieve the our bodies of their family members from the funeral parlor who had been suspected by the households of being in cahoots with the law enforcement officials. 

Some members of the family had been even arrested and imprisoned by law enforcement officials on false expenses and for the aim of stopping them from complaining. 

In a single specific incident, Your Honors, a younger man and his common-law spouse had been sleeping of their shanty when males in civilian garments knocked down the door to their home. The boys dragged the spouse out of the room, the husband was already surrendering, and he even began to strip bare to point out he had no medicine or firearm on his physique. He mentioned within the Filipino language, “Sir, malinis po ako. Maghuhubad ako Sir” Translation in English: “Sir I’m clear. I’ll strip bare, Sir.” Nonetheless with out mercy, the boys shot and killed him. After killing the husband, they arrested the spouse and accused her with falsified and non-bailable expenses.

When the deceased mom and cousin went to the police station to seek out out what occurred to the younger man, as a result of they weren’t within the scene of the crime when it occurred, the 2 had been additionally summarily arrested and charged with fabricated crimes. 

If the Honorable Chamber confirms the fees on this case, the witnesses and proof will present that those that had been smeared by Mr. Duterte earlier than they had been killed, they had been inside their homes, sleeping peacefully with their households, consuming meals with their family members, taking part in with their kids, or hugging their wives. Others had been merely strolling alongside the road, having snacks on the roadside eatery, or plying the highway incomes a poor man’s dwelling.

They had been all doing odd, peaceable, and plain human actions. Confirming the fees will restore the dignity of those that had been killed and the honour of their households. 

The unfairness suffered by the households of these killed didn’t start and finish with the killings of their family members.

Every killing set off a sequence response that’s constantly churning out a day by day crucible of hurt, injury, and loss. By masterminding the mass homicide of mere suspects, Mr. Duterte has introduced irreparable and infinite hurt to the households. An awesome majority of these killed had been the only real breadwinners of poor households.

These households had been depending on every day’s wage for his or her day by day sustenance. They had been hand-to-mouth households. With the dying of their breadwinners, the widowed spouses, a majority of whom are girls, have needed to tackle the roles of two mother and father.

On high of caring for their kids and sustaining the family, the widowed spouses now have the extra burden of being breadwinners for his or her households. 

Households have been pushed to even much more critical destitution, Your Honors. The injury to the kids is immeasurable.

Their improvement and upbringing have been completely compromised. They’ve been strolling by way of life with one lacking parental limb. Dropping a dad or mum beneath very dire financial circumstances and beneath probably the most violent circumstances ends in wounds that may by no means heal and that may completely render them handicapped for all times.

After which there’s the indescribable anguish of oldsters who misplaced a toddler. No dad or mum is meant to survive a toddler. Dad and mom endure a lifetime of grief when a toddler dies forward of them. And the lifetime grief is unimaginably worse when a toddler dies beneath probably the most inhuman circumstances. 

The crimes masterminded by Mr. Duterte didn’t solely have an effect on people however entire communities. Throughout the Philippines, quite a few city communities of probably the most impoverished villages had been scarred by the violence and abuses wrought by a lawless anti-drug marketing campaign that additional worsened the distress and trauma of residents in marginalized communities.

In a single illustrative occasion, Your Honors, after the daddy of a household was killed inside his home by law enforcement officials, all the neighborhood was so traumatized that for nearly three months, and in the course of the coldest months within the Philippines, they deserted their homes at evening and as a substitute slept within the open public market. They didn’t really feel safe inside their homes as a result of there can be no witnesses if the police would simply barge in and shoot at them. Within the public market, the presence of many witnesses, they thought, will deter the police from capturing and killing them.

It’s also the sufferer’s view, Your Honors, that the fees needs to be confirmed as a result of the ensuing presentation of witnesses and proof in the course of the trial will drive police and different legislation enforcement officers to confront the brazen depravity of the killing of civilians that they both personally dedicated or allowed to be dedicated in the course of the Duterte reign of terror. In a single operation, the police summarily killed three males, two brothers and one pal, within the very early morning. The police declared that the three had been nanlaban. They fought again, however the neighbors noticed in any other case. 

The entire neighbourhood was so horrified on the macabre remedy of one of many fatalities. The bullet-ridden physique of one of many three males was introduced out from the second-floor window and dropped to the bottom as a result of the police couldn’t deliver the physique out by way of the doorway.

When the physique hit the bottom, the neighbors recoiled at listening to the physique emit a cry, “aray,”  translation in English, “ouch.” The person was nonetheless alive when his physique was thrown to the bottom, and the police simply left him to bleed to dying. 

The trial will maintain a mirror to the police drive and compel them to see how they had been was executioners and assassins, and their group reworked into a huge legal organisation or was a killing machine by Mr. Duterte.

The Philippine Nationwide Police and the drug enforcement businesses haven’t made any initiative to purify the corrupted minds of their officers and personnel to our data. The trial on this case might be an incredible educating alternative that may work to rectify the warped and wicked minds of Philippine safety officers. 

The fees have to be confirmed, Your Honors, for the sake of all the nation, which has been desensitised or made numb by the huge incidents of impunity and the glorification of impunity promoted by Mr. Duterte.

The entire Philippines must know the true story throughout these bloody years. There was no alternative for all the nation to essentially discover out the entire reality of what occurred. It has been hush-hush, tidbits of sporadic information, and all the time drowned out by trolls who mass produce and broadcast false, faux, and fabricated information.

The victims additionally connect an important historic significance to this case. If the Chamber confirms the fees, the trial proceedings will produce a historic file of probably the most bloody interval of post-war Philippine historical past, an obligation that the Philippine justice system has refused to carry out. 

The historic account of the mass homicide of so many Filipinos in the course of the Duterte regime must be accessible to our future generations, similar to the Nuremberg trials and the Tokyo trials, in order that they’ll study from it and never repeat the identical mistake of choosing and glorifying leaders who preach and apply impunity.

The prosecution has offered 78 cases of homicide and tried homicide, clarifying that these incidents are solely representatives of the extent of the crimes dedicated towards hundreds of civilians, Your Honors. 

The victims beseech the Honourable Chamber to keep in mind that Mr. Duterte’s bloody rule, each in Davao Metropolis and nationwide, resulted in as many as 30,000 victims of killings, greater than 300,000 victims of arbitrary imprisonment, and unaccounted numbers of victims of torture, sexual assault, and different types of crimes towards humanity. 

For a lot of households within the Philippines, the fees introduced for affirmation in these proceedings signify solely a fraction of the fact the victims have endured.

The victims beseech the Honorable Chamber to recollect the tons of of hundreds of victims, that tons of of hundreds of victims are banking on vicarious justice from this case. Lastly, Your Honours. 

(5 minutes) 

Lastly, Your Honors. The victims want to humbly underline that what’s finally at stake in these proceedings is the supreme of all types of human rights: the correct to life. The suitable to life is the very basis of each civilised society. The ancestors of each nation fought towards invaders, colonisers, despotic monarchs, and fascist leaders with a view to safe the correct to lifetime of their households, their communities, and the long run generations.

The heroes of each nation sacrificed their lives to defend the correct to lifetime of their individuals. We, as residents of recent societies, are inheritors and beneficiaries of the sacrifices of our ancestors who bequeathed to us the correct to life. We owe it to them to defend this supreme legacy for our era and for the generations to come back.

For the previous few years, Your Honors, we now have seen an rising variety of nation leaders who time-travelled from the Darkish Ages and now swagger in trendy instances as in the event that they personal individuals’s lives. These brutal and merciless leaders should be held to account for his or her brazen disregard of humankind’s proper to life. Our ancestors fought within the battlefield to safe a proper to life.

In these trendy instances, the battleground for the battle to guard our proper to life is inside the 4 partitions of this Honorable Courtroom. Could the God of Life, the God of Humanity, information the Honorable Members of this Chamber. Thanks, Your Honors.

https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/

https://mindanews.com/duterte-icc/2026/02/duterte-icc-the-whole-philippines-needs-to-know-the-real-story-during-those-bloody-years/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here