The Philippines is as soon as once more arguing within the incorrect courtroom.
Not The Hague—that half is lastly proper. The argument I imply is the one taking place on tv, in senatorial halls, in social media threads throughout the nation: ICC versus sovereignty. Worldwide justice versus home dignity. Overseas meddling versus homegrown impunity. Decide your aspect.
Let me be direct: either side have professional factors. And either side are lacking the purpose totally.
What Each Sides Get Proper
The case for the ICC is stable. The Philippine justice system was by no means going to prosecute Rodrigo Duterte—not whereas allies held the Senate, not whereas the identical police power that carried out the killings remained largely intact, not whereas victims’ households confronted the very actual threat of silencing. The ICC, insulated from these pressures, can do what our establishments selected to not: construct a report, hear testimony in security, study the systematic nature of what occurred. And when a former head of state faces worldwide accountability, it alerts to each future chief that impunity has a ceiling.
The sovereignty critique can also be severe—not as Duterte’s camp deploys it, however at its core. There’s something genuinely uncomfortable about the truth that it took a court docket within the Netherlands to do what Manila refused to do. The ICC has no enforcement mechanism of its personal. With out authorities cooperation, its warrants are paper. Worldwide trials are notoriously gradual, and Duterte is 79 and reportedly sick. And right here is the deepest concern: does handing this to The Hague permit Philippine establishments to keep away from the reckoning they desperately want?
That concern is true. However the conclusion most draw from it—that this makes the ICC the incorrect path—just isn’t.
The Mechanism Folks Miss
The ICC trial, even with all its limitations, does one factor no Philippine court docket has performed: it builds a everlasting report.
Each testimony, each doc, each sufferer assertion entered at The Hague can’t be shredded by a sympathetic archivist or sealed by a pleasant decide. It’s reality written the place nobody in Malacañang can attain it. This issues not simply as authorized course of however as ethical acknowledgment—a proper, worldwide refusal to permit the erasure of thirty thousand lives.
And right here’s what the sovereignty camp misses: that report is leverage. The Marcos administration’s discomfort with ICC involvement just isn’t incidental—it’s diplomatic and reputational value. Each continuing that continues, each testimony that enters the report, raises the worth of impunity for any Philippine authorities. This isn’t leverage for international powers. It’s leverage for Filipino civil society, journalists, and advocates to demand extra from their very own establishments.
The ICC trial just isn’t the vacation spot. It’s a catalyst—a stress level that may power what no home political association has but managed: making it genuinely expensive for the Philippine state to do nothing.
What the Thirty Thousand Truly Want
The talk we’re having treats justice as a authorized occasion—a verdict, a conviction, a punishment. However the households of thirty thousand lifeless don’t primarily want a verdict. They want three issues: reality, dignity, and the credible promise of non-repetition.
Reality: acknowledgment that one thing incorrect occurred, and that it was not their family members’ fault. Dignity: recognition that these killed have been human beings, not collateral in a battle on crime. Non-repetition: significant reform of the establishments that killed them.
Right here is the arduous actuality. The ICC, by itself, can ship reality—partially, painfully slowly, however it could possibly ship it. It can not ship non-repetition. The machine that killed thirty thousand folks continues to be operating. The command tradition that made abstract execution acceptable stays intact. A verdict within the Netherlands can not dismantle an establishment in Manila. Solely Filipinos can do this.
What Must Occur
That is the place I wish to title what’s required, particularly.
The Marcos administration should cease treating ICC cooperation as a diplomatic chip and begin treating it as a authorized obligation. This isn’t about politics. It’s about whether or not the Philippines can declare to be a rule-of-law state.
Congress should maintain significant hearings—not performative ones—on police reform. Every bit of testimony from The Hague is admissible in that political discussion board. Use it.
The Fee on Human Rights have to be totally funded and shielded from political interference. Its finances cuts in recent times aren’t administrative selections. They’re alerts about accountability.
Sufferer households and civil society have to be supported to have interaction the ICC course of actively—not as passive recipients of worldwide justice, however as contributors who carry what they study again into Philippine advocacy.
And each Filipino who follows this trial should reject the sovereignty entice. Ask anybody who invokes it a easy query: the place was your sovereignty when thirty thousand have been being shot? Sovereignty is not only freedom from international interference. It’s the obligation to guard Filipino lives. A authorities that failed that obligation doesn’t get to invoke sovereignty as a protect.
The Window Is Not Closed
The ICC trial will likely be gradual. It might outlast Duterte himself. It is not going to, by itself, rework the Philippine state.
Nevertheless it has created one thing that didn’t exist earlier than: a second of worldwide visibility, everlasting testimony, and political value for inaction. That second is not going to final perpetually.
The query is what we Filipinos do with it.
Thirty thousand names are ready for the reply.
(Bong Montesa of Cagayan de Oro is a lawyer and professor based mostly in Pasig Metropolis. He has spent three a long time in battle and peacebuilding work within the Philippines.)
https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/
https://mindanews.com/mindaviews/2026/02/thirty-thousand-deserve-more-than-a-debate-about-jurisdiction/


