NAAWAN, Misamis Oriental (MindaNews / 11 June 2026) — There was a lot drama within the Senate not too long ago.
The Worldwide Felony Courtroom fugitive Senator Bato dela Rosa, who has been in hiding since November 2025, all of a sudden emerged from his rathole to hitch the coup that ousted Sotto. Due to Bato’s daring transfer, Sotto was changed by Cayetano as Senate President.
A capturing occurred within the Senate hallway. Bato, whom Cayetano declared underneath his custody, disappeared, eluding the arresting authorities in a getaway automotive of fellow senator Robin Padilla.
The duo may face a cost for obstruction of justice or have already been.
All of the sudden, Jinggoy Estrada was arrested by the Ombudsman for plunder.
Then got here the problem to the Cayetano management.
The disappearance of Bato and the arrest of Estrada altered the majority-minority composition of the Senate. A impasse resulted at 11:11. Then, from the bulk bloc Chiz Escudero unexpectedly crossed over to the minority. The minority turned to 12 and claimed they’re now the bulk. The previous minority chief grew to become the brand new majority chief and declared all positions vacant. Thereupon, they elected Sherwin Gatchalian as Senate Professional Tempore and appearing Senate President. Cayetano and his followers, in fact, protested. Cayetano asserted he’s nonetheless the Senate President and received’t quit.
Was the election of Gatchalian authorized and legitimate?
What quantity constitutes a majority, 12 or 13?
That is the raging query of the day.
Legal professionals, deans of regulation faculties, former justices of the Supreme Courtroom, and a few political pundits who preamble their arguments with citations of their titles and accomplishments, are divided on the matter.
Suffice it to say that the Philippines Structure (Article VI, Part 16) gives that the Senate President and the Home of Representatives, its Speaker, shall be elected by the bulk vote of all its respective members.
The Structure is silent as to what constitutes a majority vote.
The Supreme Courtroom is the ultimate arbiter of this concern.
In the meantime, right here’s my piece of cake on the raging concern or query.
A extra resonant that means of majority is 50+1 of those that are current and may vote. A quorum contains or refers back to the majority of the members of a physique to do enterprise. That is what I realized as early as grade 1 once we elected class officers. Those that are absent or not bodily current can not vote or be voted upon. So, why ought to they be counted in figuring out a quorum?
Within the Philippine Senate state of affairs, Senator Bato is hiding and can’t vote on a measure. Jinggoy Estrada is charged and is detained for plunder. These charged with plunder, a criminal offense for which reclusion perpetua is the penalty, are disqualified from holding public workplace. Estrada, who’s in jail for that crime, can not vote. In impact and for all intents and functions, the present Senate has solely 22 eligible members. A majority of twenty-two is 12. Thus, the 12 senators elected their Senate Professional tempore and appearing Senate President, Sherwin Gatchalian.
However what stopped them from electing a separate Senate Professional Tempore and Senate President? What are they cautious of?
At any price, Gatchalian instantly put the Senate again in enterprise, which was in hiatus throughout the two-day boycott of its constitutional duties underneath Cayetano.
The Decrease Home acknowledged Gatchalian as a reliable appearing Senate President, and so does the Government Division.
To date, Gatchalian is safe in his put up.
He even declared his readiness to preside over the Senate Impeachment Courtroom to attempt VP Sara Duterte
Cayetano, to remain in energy, could run for assist from the Supreme Courtroom.
The Supreme Courtroom, nonetheless, is unlikely to poke its nostril right into a Senate controversy.
(MindaViews is the opinion part of MindaNews. William R. Adan, Ph.D., is a retired professor and former chancellor of Mindanao State College in Naawan, Misamis Oriental.)
https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/
https://mindanews.com/mindaviews/2026/06/turning-point-the-magic-number/



