DAVAO CITY (MindaNews / 15 November 2026) — Almost 9 years in the past, in November 2017, I confronted legal expenses for becoming a member of a protest towards the go to of then US President Donald Trump to the Philippines. He was in Manila for the thirty first ASEAN Summit hosted by then President Rodrigo Duterte. What ought to have been an train of our constitutional proper to protest led to a violent police dispersal.
Water cannons, truncheons and even a sonic weapon had been used towards protesters attempting to march towards the summit venues. I used to be among the many progressive lawmakers and protest leaders charged with violating the Public Meeting Act, direct assault and disobedience to individuals in authority. The police accused us of inciting protesters to breach barricades.
I thought of the costs politically motivated, significantly since I used to be a sitting member of Congress exercising my proper to dissent towards a visiting overseas chief. The assault and disobedience expenses had been finally dropped for lack of proof that we had personally attacked law enforcement officials.
That have uncovered a well-known contradiction: authorities readily invokes democracy and nationwide sovereignty in coping with overseas powers however turns into illiberal when Filipinos train those self same rights to query our relationship with a strong ally.
Trump is again in Manila, almost 9 years later. His return brings into focus points far larger than the go to itself: navy entry, financial dependence, geopolitical rivalry, local weather duty and Philippine sovereignty.
Two worldwide conferences in distant venues present a helpful lens via which to look at these points: COP31 in Antalya, Türkiye, and the forty ninth ASEAN Summit in Manila.
Their agendas differ, however each reveal the unilateralist character of Trump’s overseas coverage—one which places American strategic and financial pursuits forward of multilateral commitments and the considerations of much less highly effective nations.
America’s retreat from local weather duty
Whereas Trump is welcomed in Manila, the US is drawing criticism in Türkiye for its absence from worldwide local weather negotiations. For the second consecutive yr, his administration has declined to ship an official authorities delegation to the UN local weather convention.
Trump has dismissed local weather change as a hoax whereas his authorities retreats from worldwide commitments and rolls again home environmental protections.
That is no minor diplomatic snub. America is among the many world’s largest historic contributors to greenhouse fuel emissions and possesses huge financial and technological sources.
Its withdrawal weakens efforts to safe local weather finance, adaptation assist and compensation for loss and harm — commitments significantly important to creating international locations which have contributed little to the disaster however undergo its worst penalties.
Washington’s retreat additionally creates house for China and different powers to current themselves as defenders of multilateral cooperation. However for international locations just like the Philippines, the problem will not be which superpower fills the diplomatic vacuum. It’s whether or not the worldwide group will ship the sources and concrete commitments wanted to confront a disaster already devastating susceptible communities.
Trump’s return: Army dependence and strategic alignment
The considerations raised in Türkiye are usually not disconnected from what is occurring in Manila. Opposition to Trump’s go to has introduced collectively progressive lawmakers, church teams, individuals’s organizations, farmers, employees, Indigenous communities, professionals and scholar activists.
Their protest is directed not merely at Trump however on the insurance policies and agreements related together with his administration and the Marcos authorities’s unquestioning alignment with Washington.
The Makabayan bloc has filed Home Decision No. 1593 opposing the administration’s reception of Trump. On the coronary heart of the protest is the priority that the Philippines continues to grant Washington navy and diplomatic concessions with out adequately analyzing what the nation offers up in return.
The enlargement of American navy entry beneath the Enhanced Protection Cooperation Settlement (EDCA), further navy websites and more and more frequent joint workout routines dangers drawing the Philippines deeper into the strategic confrontation between Washington and Beijing.
We have now each proper to defend our territorial integrity and maritime pursuits within the West Philippine Sea. However defending these rights shouldn’t imply surrendering our independence in figuring out our safety and overseas coverage. An expanded US navy presence doesn’t mechanically assure Philippine safety. It may simply as simply make our territory a staging floor for a wider battle, exposing our individuals to risks over which we now have little management.
The query will not be whether or not we should always keep relations with the US, however whether or not these relations genuinely serve Philippine sovereignty and the Filipino individuals.
Pax Silica: Improvement for whom?
Past navy cooperation, Trump’s go to brings one other main concern: Philippine participation in Pax Silica, a US-led initiative to construct allied provide chains for essential minerals, semiconductors, synthetic intelligence infrastructure and superior manufacturing.
The Marcos administration promotes it as a chance to draw billions in investments, create jobs and transfer the nation up the worldwide worth chain. However the projected financial features have to be weighed towards the social and environmental prices.
The proposed industrial hub in New Clark Metropolis raises severe questions in regards to the allocation of land, ancestral domains and agricultural communities.
Aeta communities in Tarlac and farmers whose land claims is probably not adequately mirrored in formal titles deserve explicit consideration. Expertise has proven how giant improvement tasks can displace communities which have occupied and cultivated their land for generations. Promised investments and jobs could come later; the lack of land and livelihood may be quick and irreversible.
The environmental prices additionally deserve scrutiny. Semiconductor manufacturing and demanding mineral processing require huge quantities of water and electrical energy, probably inserting further strain on the Sacobia watershed and inspiring harmful mining elsewhere.
Extra basically, will Pax Silica strengthen home industries, construct technological capabilities and supply first rate jobs? Or will it primarily give overseas companies entry to our land, sources and low cost labor whereas know-how, mental property and earnings stay in overseas fingers?
The identical questions apply to the Luzon Financial Hall and associated infrastructure initiatives. Our opposition is to not improvement or overseas funding. It’s to a improvement mannequin that sacrifices land rights, meals safety, environmental safety and financial independence for guarantees whose advantages could largely accrue to overseas companies.
Sovereignty should come earlier than alignment
What connects the conferences in Türkiye and Manila is similar basic query about American energy. In a single, Washington retreats from its duty in addressing a worldwide disaster to which it has contributed enormously. Within the different, it expects allies to accommodate its navy and financial priorities whereas reserving the liberty to behave unilaterally.
For the Philippines, this isn’t an summary debate. It considerations entry to our territory, management over our pure sources, the route of our financial improvement and our skill to chart an impartial course amid intensifying geopolitical rivalries.
This doesn’t imply rejecting bilateral cooperation. Relations between nations should relaxation on mutual respect, not unquestioning obedience. The Marcos administration should reply – have to be be made accountable – for the navy entry it grants, the financial commitments it enters into and the communities that will bear their prices. A high-level summit can’t place these selections past public scrutiny.
Almost 9 years in the past, I confronted legal expenses for protesting the go to of an American president. At present, the identical wrestle for democratic rights and nationwide independence confronts us in a unique kind.
Whether or not the problem is local weather duty in Türkiye or navy and financial cooperation in Manila, we should ask whose pursuits our authorities is absolutely serving.
Our overseas coverage and improvement priorities must be measured not by how carefully they advance Washington’s geopolitical and company agenda, however by how nicely they defend our individuals, sources and future.
Nationwide sovereignty and peoples’ curiosity trump Pax Silica!
(MindaViews is the opinion part of MindaNews. Carlos Isagani T. Zarate is a public curiosity lawyer and former three-term Bayan Muna consultant.)
https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/
https://mindanews.com/mindaviews/2026/11/commentary-two-conferences-two-distant-venues-one-unilateralist-us-policy/


