By Guinevere Latoza
Philippine Heart for Investigative Journalism
Highlights
- A flawed Philippine clear vitality public sale meant to decrease electrical energy charges as an alternative emboldened energy corporations owned by Enrique Razon Jr., Ramon Ang, and the Lopezes to lift value gives.
- 99.86% of builders’ bid submissions merely copied the federal government’s most value limits.
- Customers will now be billed for greater than 2,000 MW of additional electrical energy that the DOE had not beforehand deliberate for.
Corporations owned by a number of the nation’s richest enterprise tycoons have run circles round authorities regulators, permitting them to realize management of the nation’s clear vitality sources. Final yr, Ramon Ang’s San Miguel, port magnate Enrique Razon Jr.’s Prime Infrastructure, and the Lopez household’s First Gen Company gained profitable contracts to use the nation’s hydroelectric and geothermal vitality sources.
That is the story of how these corporations bought these contracts on the expense of shoppers who should now shoulder energy prices that would have been decrease if there had been true competitors.
Half 1: The clear vitality rush
For hundreds of years, the luxurious forests of Mount Ping-as in Pakil, Laguna had been explored solely by locals and pilgrims climbing towards a chapel at its summit. Not.
Right now building staff are clearing bushes and carving a six-kilometer highway resulting in the mountaintop the place an enormous reservoir is being constructed. The reservoir is a part of a hydroelectric undertaking that works like a large rechargeable battery: Water is pumped up from close by Laguna de Bay by way of a protracted canal when the facility grid has extra electrical energy than individuals want. When demand spikes, that water is launched again down, spinning generators that may generate 1,400 megawatts (MW) of electrical energy—sufficient to energy over half of all the Visayas.
Alongside the identical ridgeline, drilling crews have been tenting since January, getting ready the bottom for wind generators that may quickly stretch throughout the neighboring cities of Paete and Kalayaan.
Ping-as will not be alone. Within the upland villages of Rizal, the Higher Wawa Dam in Rodriguez city is being linked to a reservoir on a neighboring peak. Just like the hydropower undertaking in Pakil, water will surge between the 2 basins by way of an underground tunnel, including one other 600 MW to the grid by 2030.
Throughout the nation, mountains are being carved, coastlines are being studied for offshore wind, and huge tracts of land are being transformed to photo voltaic farms. The Philippines has set an formidable objective: generate half its electrical energy from clear sources by 2040. It will require 20,000 MW of latest renewable capability.
The stakes are excessive. Almost two-thirds of the nation’s electrical energy comes from burning coal that pollutes the air, drives local weather change, and leaves shoppers on the mercy of unstable international costs. The Philippines already has the second-highest electrical energy charges in Southeast Asia. Each peso of that invoice is cash odd Filipinos can’t spend on meals, faculty charges, or medication.
Renewable vitality guarantees a cleaner and affordable various to fossil fuels. Energy from wind, water, daylight, and geothermal warmth produces little to no emissions and shields shoppers from pass-on gasoline fees and value shocks tied to international commodity markets.

Miriam Dela Cruz has been ready for that change her complete life. The 22-year-old working pupil grew up in Sitio Ligtas, a distant upland village close to the Higher Wawa Dam, the place electrical energy comes from diesel mills or is borrowed from neighbors within the lowlands by way of prolonged energy traces. Her household lately purchased photo voltaic panels, however they run out at evening. “Napaka-importante po sa amin ng murang kuryente dahil hindi sapat ang kita sa hanapbuhay,” she mentioned.
Thousands and thousands of Filipinos share Miriam’s hope. However in a rustic the place a small circle of highly effective enterprise households controls the facility provide and authorities oversight stays weak, the vitality transition is not any assure of aid. Even the federal government’s most well-intentioned efforts to spice up clear energy may be captured by the nation’s wealthiest tycoons who’ve develop into so wealthy and so highly effective, solely they’ve the means to construct crucial infrastructure.
The pumped storage hydropower initiatives being constructed on these mountains—owned by tycoons Enrique Razon Jr. and Federico Lopez—are a telling instance of how massive company pursuits can journey the wave of the renewable vitality growth whereas undermining its promise of reasonably priced electrical energy.
Half 2: The uncompetitive bidding
In February 2025, the Division of Power (DOE) opened the third spherical of bidding for the federal government’s Inexperienced Power Public sale Program (GEAP), which was meant to drive down electrical energy prices by making clear vitality corporations compete in opposition to one another for contracts. That didn’t occur. As a substitute, there was little competitors, and the successful bidders would find yourself billing shoppers excess of what they may in any other case be paying.
GEAP is the federal government’s flagship program for reinforcing clear energy era. For each spherical, the DOE declares how a lot renewable vitality it desires so as to add to the grid. Then, builders compete to produce it by providing the value they’re prepared to cost per kilowatt-hour (kWh). The DOE picks the most affordable gives till the focused capability is met.
Profitable a contract is a boon for companies: The federal government ensures that for the following 20 years, no matter electrical energy they feed into the grid can be paid on the fee they secured within the public sale, even when energy costs drop. That distinction between the public sale fee and the market fee is then handed on to shoppers. Since January, electrical energy customers have been paying what’s often called the GEA allowance, which is tacked on to their month-to-month payments.

Right here’s how it’s computed: the Nationwide Transmission Company forecasts how a lot electrical energy all operational GEA vegetation can produce in a yr. Then, it calculates how a lot they need to be paid by calculating the distinction between the public sale fee and the precise fee within the open market. This distinction, plus different administrative prices and a buffer fund to cowl cost delays, is split throughout all electrical energy consumed nationwide, so every shopper’s share relies on how a lot energy they devour. The Power Regulatory Fee (ERC), the physique that ensures honest electrical energy costs, opinions and approves the ultimate fee.
In 2025 to 2026, the GEA allowance was calculated at P0.0371 per kWh. For a typical family consuming about 300 kWh of electrical energy a month, this implies paying round P133.56 extra per yr. This may increasingly not look like a lot. It could even be offset sooner or later. Over 2,400 MW of photo voltaic and wind locked in underneath earlier GEA rounds and anticipated to be operational this yr nonetheless generate energy extra cheaply than the open market which averaged final yr at P4.421 per kWh. When that cheaper provide pushes out costly fossil-fuel energy, it may possibly in concept drag down market costs for everybody.
However households will solely really feel that aid if utilities purchase extra from the open market fairly than sticking with pricier long-term contracts with choose energy vegetation. If not, low-cost renewable energy simply sits on the grid whereas payments keep excessive.
Due to its many volcanoes, the Philippines is likely one of the world’s largest producers of geothermal energy. Final yr, the DOE opened the bid for 100 MW value of geothermal capability; seven plants in Batangas, Bicol, Negros Island and Cotabato had been certified to bid. However solely three joined the public sale, providing simply 30.1 MW, or roughly a 3rd of the 100-MW goal. All three had been owned by the Lopez household’s First Gen Company. With no rival bidders, there was successfully no competitors. It was virtually sure the gives could be accepted.
In April 2025, the ERC advised the DOE that every one three Lopez-owned vegetation quoted costs that had been too excessive. The ERC had set P5.1092 per kWh for the enlargement of present geothermal vegetation and P7.6441 for brand new ones because the affordable most that also permits corporations to show a revenue.
Then ERC chairperson Monalisa Dimalanta pointed this out in an inside report, “The Power Regulatory Fee’s Analysis Report for the Third Inexperienced Power Public sale (GEA-3)”, which she addressed to then-energy secretary Raphael Lotilla. PCIJ obtained a replica of the report and confirmed its findings with a number of sources.

The Power Growth Company, a subsidiary of Lopez-owned First Gen, had provided P12.2867 per kWh for its new Bago plant in Negros Occidental, 60 % greater than the ERC’s most fee for brand new vegetation. The identical firm provided P9.9316 per kWh for its present Mindanao 3 plant, almost twice the utmost calculated by the ERC.
Bac-Man Geothermal Inc., one other First Gen affiliate, provided P8.2 per kWh for its new Tanawon plant in Bicol, exceeding the ERC restrict by almost P0.6.
The ERC mentioned that the absence of the 52-MW Maibarara Geothermal Plant in Batangas, which was initially certified, enabled remaining bidders to intentionally enhance their gives. Maibarara withdrew as a result of the power gained’t be capable of ship energy by 2027, which was the DOE deadline for geothermal vegetation, in accordance with the ERC report. With out competitors from Maibarara, First Gen was assured to win the bid.
Alberto Dalusung III, vitality transition adviser on the Institute for Local weather and Sustainable Cities, believes that there’s no level in bidding if there’s no actual competitors. The DOE, he mentioned, ought to have ensured that the capability being provided by potential bidders exceeds twice the quantity it’s opening up for public sale. If the DOE is auctioning off 100 MW, it ought to make sure the bidders collectively have the capability to provide 200 MW.
If there was low participation, Dalusung mentioned, the division ought to have accepted simply half of the overall capability provided to keep away from higher-end gives. Within the case of the geothermal bids, that will be round 15 out of the 30 MW.
Power undersecretary Rowena Guevara, who supervises this system, asserted that whereas the division foresaw greater than 100 MW of capability from potential bidders, “some weren’t capable of qualify in time for the public sale.” She was additionally chilly to the thought of merely accepting half of the overall capability provided. “The capability is direly wanted and since ERC set a ceiling for the charges, the public sale proceeded,” she mentioned.
Half 3: How Razon cornered a hydropower deal
In November 2024, DOE deliberate one massive competitors for 4,000 MW of hydropower capability to be delivered by 2032. Beneath these guidelines, the 4 most cost-effective bids out of eight would have already coated the 4,000 MW goal, with value gives starting from P2.9 to P3.5 per kilowatt per hour (kW/h). This consists of the Kibungan, San Roque Decrease East, San Roque West and Maton initiatives, all positioned within the mountainous Cordillera Administrative Area.
A month later, the DOE raised the goal to 4,250 MW and cut up the public sale into three batches with completely different deadlines:
- Lot 1: 2,000 MW for vegetation that may go browsing between 2028 to 2030
- Lot 2: 2,000 MW for vegetation that may go browsing between 2031 to 2032
- Lot 3: 250 MW for vegetation that may go browsing between 2031 to 2035
The DOE mentioned this cut up assured a gradual supply of energy over the following decade. It additionally ended up favoring ports magnate Enrique Razon Jr., a relative newcomer in energy era, and allowed him to increase his footprint in an industry lengthy dominated by the Lopez and Aboitiz households and San Miguel.


Razon’s Prime Infrastructure had vegetation in Pakil and Wawa they usually provided the best bids—over P6 per kW/h. With the cut up public sale, they now had greater possibilities of successful as a result of they solely wanted to compete with one different bidder: the Kibungan plant run by Coheco Badeo Company.
Kibungan, Pakil and Wawa had been the one three that would meet the 2030 deadline for the primary lot. And for the reason that two most cost-effective gives in that class—Wawa plant and Kibungan—might solely provide 1,100 MW, the DOE accommodated Pakil’s excessive provide since it could present the remaining 900 MW. DOE accepted all three bids. San Miguel’s plant in Aklan gained the contract to produce 250 MW because it was the one one which happy the 2031 to 2035 deadline within the third lot. It had no rivals.
After the bidding, San Miguel purchased a stake in Coheco Badeo. Two months earlier than the public sale, it additionally bought a 40-percent stake within the firm that totally controls Pan Pacific, thereby cornering all however two of the seven vegetation that gained bids.
In the long run, the DOE accepted bids for six,350 MW, cut up between San Miguel and Razon’s Prime Infrastructure, with the best value provide reaching P6.16 per kW/h, almost 40 % greater than the open market fee final yr. Customers will now be billed for greater than 2,000 MW of additional electrical energy that the DOE had not beforehand deliberate for.
Dimalanta, who oversaw the public sale evaluation, personally believes San Miguel and Prime bid aggressively as a result of they had been assured they’d win regardless. She expressed her misgivings earlier than the February 2025 bidding befell. “We instantly flagged it to the DOE. ‘Pag ganito ka-konti, is that this nonetheless best for an public sale for those who solely have a handful of bidders?’” she recalled. The DOE assured them it could be positive.
Power insiders and shopper advocates fear that after the contracted vegetation come on-line, energy payments would soar. They level out that these pumped storage hydropower vegetation can be paid for his or her total capability at any time when they’re referred to as on, whether or not or not they ship the electrical energy in full. This implies they are going to be paid in kilowatts per hour, and never per kilowatt-hour.
The DOE, nevertheless, defended its selections, saying the public sale advances the nation’s objective of reaching 35% renewable vitality by 2030 and 50% by 2040, up from simply 25% final yr. “We would have liked assured capability by a sure timing,” vitality undersecretary Guevara advised PCIJ. She additionally pressured the significance of pumped storage hydropower vegetation, that are paid for storage since they take in extra electrical energy when provide outpaces demand, and launch it again to the grid when individuals want it most.
Half 4: The flagged energy bids
The ERC wasn’t satisfied. Digging deeper, it discovered that many of the corporations that joined the public sale appeared to have based mostly their value gives on questionable value figures. About 99.86% of all submissions merely copied the utmost value assumptions the fee itself had set as a ceiling and never as a goal.
“This reveals a crucial disconnect between regulatory intent and sensible implementation,” the ERC report mentioned, including that the sample raised critical issues about whether or not the submitted figures had been credible or aligned with the public sale’s function.
The report singled out Prime Infrastructure’s subsidiaries for quoting charges above the appropriate vary and basing these quotes on assumptions that didn’t precisely mirror their initiatives.
Right here is the problem in plain phrases: pumped storage hydropower vegetation sometimes final 40 years. Ahunan Energy, Inc. had beforehand declared its Pakil plant might function for 50 years. Olympia Violago Water and Energy Inc. mentioned its Wawa plant might run for 35 years. Each are owned by Razon’s Prime Infrastructure. Early this yr, the Lopezes’ First Gen purchased a 40% stake in these hydropower initiatives.
But when each corporations submitted their P6 per kW/h value gives—the 2 highest within the pumped hydropower storage class—a few of their monetary calculations assumed they’d solely have 20 years to recuperate their prices.
A shorter reimbursement window means greater annual prices, which drives up the value they cost shoppers. “Ang mortgage kasi nila, often 20 years, diba. Pero ang lifetime ng plant is 40 years. Oh, so sabi ng ERC, divide (the mortgage) by 40, not by 20,” Guevara defined.
The ERC ultimately really useful decrease charges for the vegetation and 5 different certified bidders based mostly on corrected knowledge. This successfully grew to become a ceiling for every bid. All however one accepted the cuts.
To vitality specialists and shopper advocates, final yr’s public sale reinforces a long-standing concern: when just some highly effective enterprise households dominate electrical energy era, shoppers are hostage to electrical energy charges unchallenged by competitors.
Petronilo Ilagan, president of the Nationwide Affiliation of Electrical energy Customers, mentioned {that a} really aggressive public sale might have introduced the costs decrease than the imposed ceilings. “‘Yung ceiling na yan is simply the ceiling, not essentially dun agad ang presyo mo. Hindi ibig sabihin dapat ganun ang kita mo. It could possibly be lower than that.”
Environmental lawyer and local weather skilled Antonio La Viña put it plainly. “Renewable vitality also needs to result in decrease costs in electrical energy. As a substitute, it’s growing the costs as a result of it’s captured,” he mentioned. “That’s what we now have to vary. That’s what we now have to make extra clear. We’ve to push again in opposition to oligarchs.”
Simply 5 corporations management almost 70% of the nationwide grid, based mostly on ERC knowledge as of Might 2026. That focus of energy didn’t occur in a single day.
Half 5: Energy in personal palms
Beneath Ferdinand Marcos Sr.’s dictatorship within the Seventies, the state held a monopoly over all main energy vegetation by way of the National Power Corporation. This allowed the federal government to maintain electrical energy costs low for residential shoppers, in accordance with a 1994 World Bank document.
By 1983, nevertheless, the state company had incurred huge monetary losses that hindered it from sustaining growing older energy vegetation and constructing new ones. Electrical energy shortages plagued the ultimate years of the Marcos regime.
In 1987, President Corazon Aquino ended Napocor’s monopoly by way of Executive Order No. 215, encouraging personal corporations to enter energy era within the hopes of fixing the scarcity. However the disaster solely deepened.
New capability couldn’t hold tempo with rising demand, and by the early Nineteen Nineties, each day blackouts lasting eight to 12 hours battered areas throughout the nation. The outages “severely crippled the economic system as factories had been compelled to shut or cut back operations. Productiveness fell and unemployment fee elevated,” in accordance with a 2007 paper from the Philippine Overview of Economics.
Beneath President Fidel Ramos, Congress allowed Napocor to fast-track new energy vegetation—lots of them coal- and gas-powered—constructed by personal builders. The blackouts eased, however electrical energy costs rose as contracts compelled shoppers to pay for an oversupply of energy they didn’t want.
On the flip of the millennium, the federal government formally handed electrical energy era to the personal sector. The Electric Power Industry Reform Act of 2001 (EPIRA) mandated the sale of presidency energy belongings to non-public companies with the objective of bettering vitality safety, increasing electrification, and reducing electrical energy costs by way of competitors. Right now, over 90% of put in energy within the nationwide grid is wholly managed by personal companies, in accordance with ERC data.
The ERC, which was created by the identical legislation, is tasked with guaranteeing honest electrical energy charges and guarding in opposition to market abuse. It had not at all times been a powerful regulator however within the case of GEA-3, the fee went so far as scrutinizing why the public sale guidelines bred opportunistic habits amongst vitality giants.
However whereas the ERC had energy over the charges it couldn’t change the public sale guidelines it deemed problematic. Beneath EPIRA, the DOE points the insurance policies and the ERC enforces and implements. “In the long run, what’s the duty of ERC? Pricing. The duty of DOE is the phrases of reference and ensuring we now have sufficient provide,” Guevara mentioned.
Client advocate Ilagan argues that in bidding out GEA-3, the DOE had betrayed the spirit of EPIRA, which is to ensure that the facility provide is obtained as a minimum value. However he counseled the ERC. “Tama yung ginawa ng ERC diyan,” he mentioned.
Previously, Ilagan had been crucial of the ERC, significantly for not reviewing fees that energy corporations go on to shoppers. In 2023, he accused then ERC chair Dimalanta of failing to recalculate Meralco’s charges, which led to her suspension in September 2024. She regained the publish two months later after the Ombudsman lifted the order and resigned in July 2025.
However Ilagan additionally desires the ERC to make use of its rate-auditing powers extra aggressively. The tariffs given to GEA builders are fastened for 20 years. However he says this must be periodically reviewed to see if the charges are extreme in the long term.
“Naturally, companies will shield their curiosity, “ he mentioned. “They wish to earn extra. That’s enterprise. In order that’s the place the federal government must be aggressive in a approach,” he mentioned. “Will the federal government do its perform in defending shoppers?”
Half 6: The making of a ‘simply’ vitality transition
By one measure, the DOE’s clear vitality program is working. Its public sale rounds have secured over 20,000 MW of renewable vitality capability by way of 2035. That is already sufficient, on paper, to fulfill the Philippines’ goal of producing half its electrical energy from clear sources by 2040.
Two extra bidding rounds are set this yr: one for offshore wind and one other for waste-to-energy initiatives. Amid rising gasoline costs pushed by battle within the Center East, the DOE has additionally fast-tracked the supply of 1,471 MW from renewable vitality vegetation already underneath growth.
However megawatts alone will not be the measure of a simply vitality transition.
“Simply transition implies that the burden of the vitality transition or any local weather transition we do to cut back carbon emissions will not be borne by the surroundings, biodiversity, and by individuals, particularly the poor,” mentioned La Viña, who led the Philippine delegation at COP21 in 2015. There, governments vowed to restrict international warming to 1.5 levels Celsius by way of the Paris Settlement.
The nation nonetheless has a protracted approach to go. Beginning in 2010, coal’s share of the nation’s energy era climbed steadily. By 2024, it dominated the combo at 62% whereas renewables fell to 22%.
Power specialists who spoke with PCIJ mentioned the federal government’s push to speed up renewable vitality is critical. However they warn that with out reforming how clear vitality is procured and priced, the transition dangers delivering the identical end result of privatization that works higher for corporations than for shoppers.
For ICSC’s Dalusung, who served on the Ministry of Power underneath the Marcos Sr. administration, the repair begins with the public sale guidelines themselves. He mentioned that some renewable vitality applied sciences actually have excessive upfront prices. By designing really aggressive guidelines, solely then can builders enter into value wars that will compel them to deliver down gives. “We have to do a second take a look at the protocols,” Dalusung mentioned.
Again within the upland villages of Rizal, 23-year-old boat operator Gideon Gumaad mentioned he and his neighbors stay skeptical in regards to the hydropower undertaking rising of their city. He grew up close to the Higher Wawa Dam and watched the undertaking rework the panorama. His household bought their land to the builders and relocated to a close-by village to make approach for the undertaking.
However in a spot the place dependable electrical energy has by no means been assured and options like diesel mills, borrowed energy traces, and photo voltaic panels are by no means sufficient, hope is difficult to let go. Gideon needs for the undertaking to ease the burdens his group has lengthy carried. “Nagtataka talaga ang mga tao kung makakatulong ba talaga. Sana nga,” he mentioned. —PCIJ.org
https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/
https://mindanews.com/special-reports/2026/06/tycoons-swoop-in-on-the-clean-energy-boom-raising-prices-for-consumers-a-story-in-6-parts/



