SEC Chairman Francis Lim’s push to boost brokerage capital and rise up market-making requirements addresses a long time of market stagnation. However as veteran dealer Vivian Yuchengco warns {that a} uniform P120-million threshold threatens smaller Filipino homes, regulators should steadiness systemic resilience with aggressive entry.
The Securities and Alternate Fee’s (SEC) drive to modernize the Philippine capital market has encountered organized resistance.
Veteran stockbroker Vivian Yuchengco, chair of the Philippine Affiliation of Securities Brokers and Sellers (PASBDI), warns that the SEC’s proposed P120-million unimpaired paid-up capital (UPC) requirement might push smaller Filipino brokerage homes into compelled consolidation or closure.
Although her warning carries financial weight, SEC Chairman Francis Lim’s regulatory rationale is compelling.
In an interview with Vantage Level, Yuchengco narrates {that a} agency working on the present P30-million baseline must elevate an extra P90 million—a fourfold enhance. But the central query is whether or not preserving the trade’s historic headcount ought to take priority over constructing sturdy safeguards for the investing public.
Philippine capital markets have drifted for decades in a low-liquidity trapconstrained by shallow buying and selling depth, sluggish turnover, and governance buildings which have shielded incumbents on the expense of dynamism.
Chairman Lim’s multi-pronged reform agenda—elevating broker-dealer capitalization, placing term limits on long-tenured Philippine Stock Exchange (PSE) broker-directorsand introducing rigorous market-making guidelines—shouldn’t be mere routine oversight. (READ: (Vantage Point) SEC’s float gambit: Shaking the stock market from deep slumber)
It’s an pressing, obligatory modernization drive designed to rebuild credibility, fortify market resilience, and switch the nation’s moribund alternate into an engine for real capital formation.
Chairman Lim explains that trendy brokerage operations require substantial monetary stamina not only for commerce execution, however for enterprise cybersecurity, regulatory compliance, danger administration, and market growth. Moreover, decades of inflation have severely eroded the true buying energy of historic capital baselines.
Crucially, two distinct initiatives should not be conflated. The final P120-million UPC rule is a draft proposal envisioned for phased rollout via 2030. In contrast, the P150-million threshold below SEC Memorandum Circular No. 28, Series of 2026applies strictly to brokerages volunteering as designated market makers.
As a result of market makers constantly quote two-way costs, bridge supply-demand gaps, and maintain securities on their very own books, an elevated capital buffer is crucial to resist sharp volatility with out sparking settlement contagion.
Counterarguments
Nonetheless, PASBDI’s newly launched 10-page place paper, “Calibrated Capital, Credible Safety,” introduces salient counterarguments.
In a survey of 55 brokerage corporations, PASBDI discovered that 54.5% (30 corporations) oppose the uniform P120-million rule, with one other eight backing it solely with revisions. Amongst 36 respondents counting on the P30-million threshold, 25 voiced opposition; conversely, not one of the 5 corporations already holding P120 million or extra objected. Whereas the survey doesn’t seize your complete trade, it confirms that resistance is concentrated amongst smaller-capitalized homes.
PASBDI’s most persuasive level facilities on regulatory proportionality. Invoking Precept 30 of the Worldwide Group of Securities Commissions (IOSCO), the affiliation argues that prudential mandates ought to mirror the precise dangers intermediaries assume.
It proposes a three-tiered capital framework, contending {that a} agency merely introducing shoppers to clearing brokers mustn’t face the identical regulatory burden as an establishment carrying buyer margin financing, holding custody of property, or operating heavy proprietary books.
This risk-based philosophy has benefit. But smaller dimension doesn’t routinely equate to decrease danger. Even modest brokerages can inflict systemic reputational harm and catastrophic investor losses via poor custody, lax inner controls, or operational misconduct. Any tiered mannequin must not ever compromise the baseline security of buyer property.
PASBDI additionally raises a legitimate operational objection to the proposed P20-million surety bond mandated for December 2028, forward of the capital milestones in 2029 and 2030.
If underwriters require 100% collateral, the bond would immobilize liquid funds urgently wanted for every day buying and selling and settlement. A agency going through a P90-million fairness name alongside a cash-collateralized P20-million bond would endure an efficient P110-million instant funding drain.
Consequently, PASBDI recommends stretching the glide path—proposing P60 million by 2029 and P90 million by 2032.
Nevertheless, different affiliation compromises show much less convincing. PASBDI suggests quickly recognizing independently appraised will increase in actual property owned by brokerages as regulatory capital.
Right here, regulators should maintain agency. Property valuations on paper can not settle failed trades, fulfill instant margin calls, or reimburse retail buyers in a flash crash. Illiquid brick-and-mortar property aren’t any substitute for real, loss-absorbing liquidity.
Monetary statements throughout the road underscore that capital dimension, profitability, and regulatory cushion should be evaluated individually.
Unbiased retail chief COL Monetary held P1.78 billion in internet liquid capital and a rare 548.33% risk-based capital adequacy ratio (RBCA) as of June 2026.
Financial institution-backed BDO Securities absorbed a P189.71-million internet loss in 2025, but maintained P487.15 million in fairness and P216.85 million in internet liquid capital, remaining absolutely compliant.
First Metro Securities reported P169 million in paid-up capital, backed by documented operational expertise operating market-making for the First Metro ETF.
BPI Securities logged P202.36 million in capital regardless of an working loss, whereas AB Capital posted P97.84 million in mixed capital inventory and APIC.
In the meantime, conventional corporations like David Go Securities—which closed 2025 with P42.45 million in unimpaired capital, P12.59 million in internet revenue, and a sound 199% RBCA ratio—show that compliant, worthwhile homes may very well be locked out below a inflexible, one-size-fits-all threshold.
PASBDI’s most constructive advice is for the SEC to publish a proper regulatory impression evaluation detailing the dangers addressed, the corporations affected, and the aggressive fallout. Doing so would fortify, not diminish, Lim’s authority.
As Chairman Lim instructed Vantage Level: “Our message is obvious: market making should create actual liquidity, not synthetic exercise; truthful competitors, not unfair benefit. The SEC’s guidelines require safeguards for conflicts of curiosity, clear citation requirements, and accountable incentives. We would like a market that isn’t solely extra energetic, but in addition fairer, extra clear, and worthy of investor belief.”
The identical philosophy should anchor the broader capitalization reforms. Lim deserves robust help for tackling structural stagnation that has hobbled the alternate for many years.
The objective shouldn’t be to guard each legacy participant no matter functionality, nor to arbitrarily purge viable unbiased corporations. It’s to forge an trade resilient sufficient to resist shocks, increase market depth, and command public belief.
By taking reputable proportionality considerations into consideration, the SEC can refine its timeline with out diluting its mandate—making certain that the investing public stays the final word beneficiary. – Rappler.com
Sources: PASBDI, Calibrated Capital, Credible Safety (October 2026); SEC draft amendments to Guidelines 28.1 and 33.1; SEC Memorandum Round No. 28, Sequence of 2026; and audited brokerage monetary statements filed with CMIC. Historic figures don’t set up present SEC accreditation.
Beneath are some Vantage Level items you may need missed:
Click on right here for different Vantage Point articles.
https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/
https://www.rappler.com/voices/thought-leaders/vantage-point-high-barriers-stakes-sec-francis-lim-liquidity-gambit/





