What occurs when the folks you inherited a enterprise with are additionally the folks you may not work with? You’ll be able to give up a job, promote your shares, or discover a new enterprise companion. However what if that companion is your brother, sister, cousin, or father or mother, and the corporate is one thing your grandparents spent their lives constructing?

I’ve lined Philippine enterprise households for many of my journalism profession, interviewing kinfolk locked in battles over possession, management, inheritance, and household land. Some disputes had been already taking part in out in courtroom, whereas others had been waged quietly behind closed boardroom doorways whilst the businesses saved working. Because the feud between cousins Federico “Piki” Lopez and Eugenio “Gabby” Lopez III unfolded this yr, I discovered myself returning to these tales, my interview notes, and studying Harvard Enterprise Overview analysis on why household companies combat and the way some survive. In June, I joined family-business adviser Enrique Soriano in an online forum with enterprise homeowners throughout Asia to debate why even wildly profitable dynasties break aside.

The Lopez cousins are hardly the primary rich household to face this drawback. India’s Ambani brothers cut up up the Reliance empire their father constructed, whereas the Ortigases fought over management of their actual property enterprise. In Singapore, a father accused his son of attempting to take over the board of one of many nation’s largest property builders. Some households ultimately referred to as a truce. Others determined they may not be enterprise companions, and nonetheless fought for years, burning via money on attorneys and leaving the subsequent era to wash up the mess.

All of this introduced me again to 1 large query: Is holding a household enterprise collectively all the time price the price?

The Lopezes attain a crossroads

For many years, the Lopez title has been tied to a number of the Philippines’ most well-known corporations: ABS-CBN, Meralco, Benpres (now Lopez Holdings), First Philippine Holdings, First Gen, and Rockwell Land. The companies modified over time, but the household stayed related to an empire their elders constructed, misplaced, gained again, and rebuilt.

Underneath Oscar Lopez‘s management, the household revealed Phoenix, a e-book about how they bounced again from onerous instances. Piki wished a unique image for the subsequent chapter: not the phoenix, which rises once more after being destroyed, however the butterfly, which transforms into one thing utterly new. He has additionally talked lots about compounding, the concept that sensible selections made persistently over many years repay excess of fast wins. In his September speeches to stockholders, he burdened that “route issues greater than velocity,” pointing to the group’s choice ten years earlier to cease constructing coal-fired energy crops even when coal was nonetheless making good cash. 



That mindset explains Piki’s recreation plan for First Gen’s power investments. He believes the corporate should put together for an influence market that depends increasingly on renewable power. His cousins have questioned whether or not the bets he’s making are definitely worth the massive price tag, risks, and years of ready. They’ve additionally challenged his authority to make these calls on his personal. Gabby and his allied cousins wished one thing very totally different: speedy money circulate and shared family stewardship over a distressed media mission—ABS-CBN—that might not afford to attend till 2031 for long-gestation hydro initiatives to repay. 


EXCLUSIVE: Inside Piki Lopez’s town hall as cousins rally for ABS-CBN

The combat turned public and private. In April, majority homeowners of Lopez Inc.—representing three of the 4 branches of the household—accused Piki of performing “like a king with out accountability,” questioning First Gen’s deals with Enrique Razon Jr.’s Prime Infrastructure, together with promoting management of its natural-gas business and investing in water-pumping hydropower initiatives. The bulk group later referred to as the hydropower wager “a horrible deal.” First Gen pushed again on these claims, defending the enterprise logic, pricing, and board approvals behind its offers.

The cousins reached a ceasefire in May, however it didn’t maintain, and by August, Gabby’s branch sold its 25.68% share in Lopez Inc., the personal holding firm sitting on the very high of the household empire, to businessman Ramon Ang for about P11.56 billion. In the meantime, ABS-CBN lined up fresh funding. Piki then locked down management of the boards of Lopez Holdings and First Philippine Holdings (FPH), the 2 corporations that maintain the group’s stakes in First Gen and geothermal giant Energy Development Corporation (EDC). In November, FPH authorised the proposed P15.92-billion sale of its 90.74% controlling stake in Rockwell Land to Gabby’s department’s funding agency, Crème Funding Company, a deal that’s nonetheless ready to shut. (READ: What it took to save ABS-CBN)

Taken collectively, these offers recommend the cousins are shifting towards a future the place they not must agree on easy methods to run the identical companies.

However is splitting up truly higher than staying collectively?

When enterprise disagreements turn into household wars

One household proprietor needs larger money payouts at present, whereas the relative working the corporate needs to plow again these income into rising the enterprise. One other thinks they need to promote the corporate whereas patrons are providing a great value, whereas another person needs to reserve it for the grandkids. One needs to journey out an business droop, satisfied a struggling enterprise will bounce again, whereas one other needs to cease pouring cash into what seems to be like a sinking ship, particularly when that money might fund a unique enterprise that takes years of heavy spending earlier than turning a revenue.

But every walks away believing the others are grasping, reckless, or unreasonable. The actual hassle begins when the folks across the boardroom desk aren’t simply extraordinary traders, however siblings who grew up competing for his or her dad and mom’ and uncles’ consideration, cousins who really feel their department of the household sacrificed extra, or heirs who keep in mind the founder’s needs in a different way.

Josh Baron and Rob Lachenauer, who advise enterprise households and write for Harvard Enterprise Overview, clarify how on a regular basis enterprise arguments flip deeply private. In Why Fights Erupt in Family Businesses, they present how fights over cash, energy, and standing get twisted up with household historical past. An argument over firm spending can convey again previous resentment over unequal remedy. A combat over who will get to be CEO can reopen previous arguments about favoritism. Promoting an organization would possibly appear to be a wise alternative to 1 relative and a betrayal of the household legacy to a different.

Soriano raised one other complication throughout our webinar: many household companies keep united for many years just because one robust founder or household elder can settle all of the arguments. Family members won’t like each choice, but they settle for the chief’s authority. As soon as that chief passes away, the subsequent era realizes it has inherited not solely the companies, but in addition previous disagreements that had been by no means actually resolved.

The Lopezes had larger-than-life leaders in Eugenio “Geny” Lopez Jr. and his brother Oscar, who died in 1999 and 2023, leaving their successors to determine easy methods to personal and run surviving empires with out these robust elders round to settle arguments.

Different Philippine households have ended up in far messier wars.

Take Banco Filipino, as soon as the nation’s largest financial savings financial institution, well-known for its slogan, “Subok na Matibay, Subok na Matatag (Examined Sturdy, Confirmed Steady).” Based by Tomas Aguirre in 1964, the financial institution was shut down by the Central Financial institution in January 1985 earlier than reopening in 1994 after the Supreme Courtroom dominated the Central Financial institution had abused its energy. However its complications had been removed from over. It saved clashing with regulators over monetary assist, its cash troubles, and the fallout from its first shutdown.

Newsbreak magazine, Don Tomas Aguirre, Ana Marie Aguirre-Koruga, Albert Bobby Aguirre, Banco Filipino
BANCO FILIPINO. This unfold in Newsbreak’s March 3, 2003 problem exhibits the late Don Tomas Aguirre (left) and his kids, Ana Marie Aguirre-Koruga (higher proper), and Albert “Bobby” Aguirre (backside proper) on a polo area. Rappler

On the similar time, the Aguirre household was tearing itself aside from the within. I covered the legal fight involving Ana Maria Aguirre-Koruga, a minority stockholder who sued the financial institution’s administrators in 2003, together with her personal brother, Albert Aguirre, who was then vice chairman. She accused them of dangerous banking practices, conflicts of curiosity, and shady loans meant to counterpoint insiders. The administrators denied the claims. In 2009, the Supreme Court ruled in Koruga v. Arcenas that her complaints belonged with the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP), not a daily trial courtroom. That ruling solely determined who had authority to listen to the case, not whether or not her accusations had been true. The bank shut down for good on March 17, 2011, below BSP orders. The state deposit insurer, Philippine Deposit Insurance Corporation, took over a financial institution with 62 branches, 173,480 accounts, and P17.8 billion in buyer deposits. The household and regulators saved arguing over who was in charge. Whereas the sibling feud wasn’t the only real purpose Banco Filipino collapsed—its monetary and regulatory issues ran a lot deeper—the household battle performed out inside a financial institution holding the life financial savings of 1000’s of extraordinary Filipinos.

The Ilusorio family feud acquired much more private. Potenciano “Nanoy” Ilusorio constructed a multi-billion-peso empire anchored by prime actual property, the pioneering satellite tv for pc agency Philcomsat, and the unique Baguio Nation Membership. However by 1999, his six kids had cut up into rival camps over their dad and mom, the household fortune, and who ought to be in cost. When Nanoy grew previous and frail, a few of his kids took him below their care, prompting their mom, Erlinda Kalaw-Ilusorio, to sue them for allegedly holding her husband away from her, a battle the Supreme Courtroom dismissed in 2001 because the “unhappy story of a distinguished household shattered by conflicts on expectancy in fabled fortune.” (READ: What drives people to declare war against their own flesh and blood?)

Even Nanoy’s loss of life in June that yr didn’t cease practically 300 civil and prison lawsuits filed between the rival camps, and based on an account Soriano revealed in 2016, some kids solely discovered of Erlinda’s loss of life 4 days later, resulting in separate funerals. At one service, the urn reportedly held Nanoy’s ashes as a result of one other department of the household saved Erlinda’s. One other service reportedly barred three of the sisters on the door with safety guards.

A combat that began over cash and energy had reached the purpose the place kids couldn’t even mourn their dad and mom collectively.

In different distinguished Philippine clans, the fracture started not at a father or mother’s deathbed, however when siblings started questioning how a brother or sister was managing inherited property—turning boardroom suspicions into prison complaints and proxy wars.

For the Jacintos, who constructed their wealth in metal, banking, and actual property, additionally fought over their inheritance. After their patriarch, Fernando Jacinto died, his kids clashed over how household properties had been being managed and offered. Musician and businessman Ramon “RJ” Jacinto stepped in after kinfolk questioned actual property offers dealt with by their sister Marilene, who was working components of the household enterprise. One combat centered on a big property in Misamis Oriental offered in 2007 for P226 million, which RJ’s camp argued was far beneath its appraised worth. One other concerned a Novaliches property reportedly price about P300 million. Appearing as president of family-owned Oregon Land Inc., RJ accused Marilene of faking a deed to switch the land. Prosecutors charged her in 2012 with falsifying public paperwork, an accusation that led to prison proceedings, although not a conviction. The feud confirmed how inheritance fights can shortly spiral into claims of betrayal and prison prices between brothers and sisters. (READ: Shaping the future: Family legacies)


Family feud: Court ruling saves Olivia Yanson’s share in PH’s biggest transport fleet  

Within the Yanson household, the set off was a boardroom ouster over who would run the enterprise. They dad and mom based Vallacar Transit Inc. and the Ceres bus empire, thought of among the many largest bus conglomerates in Southeast Asia with about 5,000 buses ferrying 700,000 to 850,000 passengers in routes throughout Visayas and Mindanao areas. In July 2019, 4 siblings—Roy, Emily, Ricardo Jr., and Ma. Lourdes Celina Yanson-Lopez—tried to oust their youngest brother, Leo Rey Yanson, from working the bus group. Their mom, Olivia Yanson, sided with Leo Rey and Ginette, splitting the household into Yanson 4 and Yanson 2 camps. They fought over who had the precise to elect board administrators and run the corporate, triggering lawsuits and battles over firm information. In 2025, the Supreme Courtroom mentioned Olivia was mentally sound when she executed her will that designated the Yanson 2 camp because the righful heirs of their household enterprise empire. The family still hasn’t reached the sort of broad peace deal wanted to place the feud behind them. (READ: Yanson family feud gets uglier as court brands 4 siblings ‘fugitives from justice’)

This household drama resonated elsewhere in Asia the place South Korea’s Lotte Group—the retail, hospitality, and confectionery large behind Asia’s largest shops, luxurious motels, and iconic snacks—turned the stage for a succession war between brothers Shin Dong-joo and Shin Dong-bin, sons of founder Shin Kyuk-ho. The enterprise large had main operations in each Japan and South Korea. Dong-joo, the older brother, was distinguished in Japan, whereas Dong-bin ran a lot of the Korean aspect. After Dong-joo misplaced high posts in Japan in late 2014 and early 2015, the brothers erupted right into a public battle over who had their father’s blessing and who ought to lead the empire. Their aged father was pulled straight into the crossfire. At one level, Shin Kyuk-ho backed his eldest son, prompting Dong-bin’s camp to query whether or not their father was nonetheless mentally match to make selections. The brothers battled via shareholder votes, lawsuits, and press statements, turning their father’s psychological well being and authorized guardianship right into a courtroom case. Dong-bin ultimately gained over shareholders and saved management, although Dong-joo saved combating him. As a substitute of splitting the empire in two, one brother walked away with management of the primary group.


Why the Lopez cousins are breaking up — and what other feuding dynasties teach us

The Shin feud proved a tough fact: being the founder’s son, even being the oldest, doesn’t assure inheriting the throne.

Why some households select to remain collectively

In Singapore, the Kwek household— the powers behind iconic skyscrapers, luxurious condos, and over 160 motels worldwide—confirmed how shortly a disagreement between a father and son might transfer from the household boardroom into the headlines. In February 2025, Metropolis Developments government chairman Kwek Leng Beng accused his son, chief government Sherman Kwek, of trying a boardroom “coup” by bypassing governance guidelines to nominate impartial administrators, prompting the elder Kwek to go to courtroom to fireside his son. Buying and selling in Metropolis Developments shares was suspended because the confrontation turned public. For a listed property developer, the dispute raised questions that went past the connection between father and son: Who had the authority to nominate administrators? Have been company procedures being adopted? And will the corporate proceed working successfully whereas its chairman and chief government had been combating?

But the confrontation ended comparatively shortly. On March 12, 2025, Metropolis Developments introduced that the courtroom proceedings had been settled and could be discontinued. Kwek Leng Beng remained government chairman and Sherman remained chief government, whereas the 2 newly appointed impartial administrators whose appointments had sparked the dispute, Jennifer Duong Younger and Wong Su-Yen, stepped down. Singapore’s Straits Times later reported that trusted household associates and senior figures had helped mediate the truce. The corporate continued below the identical household management, though the settlement didn’t essentially imply that each private disagreement had been resolved.

Right here within the Philippines, the Ortigas household—the landed dynasty behind Ortigas Heart and Greenhills—additionally managed to save lots of its core property enterprise after years of infighting. At stake was OCLP Holdings, which controls prime Ortigas land, Greenhills Shopping Center, and Tiendesitas. To realize an edge, rival branches teamed up with competing giants: the Rafael Ortigas group with Ayala Land, and the Francisco Ortigas group with SM Prime Holdings. The battle spilled into courtroom over board elections and whether or not nominees tied to a rival developer might maintain seats.

These divisions let Ayala and SM deepen their footholds in a fractured enterprise. In November 2014, the builders and Ortigas factions dropped their lawsuits and agreed to work collectively. The household saved its landholdings intact slightly than carving them up, although peace got here at a steep value: bringing in highly effective giants handed outsiders main affect over an empire that had belonged to the Ortigas household for generations.

There are robust enterprise causes to maintain a household group intact. Firms below widespread possession can share money, expertise, financial institution relationships, and management, permitting a stronger sister firm to assist a struggling one survive a tough patch or undertake huge investments too giant for one department alone. There’s additionally the pull of household historical past, the place a enterprise constructed by a grandfather means way more to his grandkids than an extraordinary inventory funding, making a sale really feel like erasing a part of the household identification even when the monetary math is sensible.

But holding an organization collectively merely as a result of the founder wished it saved collectively can create one other drawback: What occurs when the subsequent era not agrees on what the enterprise ought to do?

Adviser Josh Baron has argued in Why Family Businesses Need to Find the Right Level of Conflict that avoiding disagreement is definitely unhealthy. Households should debate powerful questions slightly than letting homeowners quietly stew over selections they really feel powerless to vary. When kinfolk can nonetheless negotiate and compromise, staying collectively preserves big worth. However when each funding, dividend payout, job appointment, or asset sale turns into one other battle for management, the price turns into far too excessive.

When separating turns into the reply

India’s Ambani household determined that the brothers had been merely higher off working totally different corporations. (READ: Timeline: Key dates in India’s Ambani brothers’ dispute)

After founder Dhirubhai Ambani died in 2002 with out leaving a will, his sons Mukesh and Anil fought publicly over who would management Reliance Industries—India’s largest private-sector conglomerate, spanning petrochemicals, refining, telecom, and retail—till their mom, Kokilaben, stepped in to dealer a June 2005 peace deal. Mukesh saved Reliance Industries and its core oil and chemical operations, whereas Anil took cost of telecom, energy, and monetary providers. Nevertheless it didn’t cease each argument because the brothers later fought over natural-gas provide offers in a battle that reached India’s Supreme Courtroom. Nonetheless, they not needed to agree on each single funding or administration name.

India’s Bajaj household—one of many nation’s oldest enterprise dynasties, well-known for placing India on wheels as a bike, scooter, and monetary providers powerhouse—additionally cut up up its corporations amongst totally different branches after years of combating. Underneath a 2008 settlement, Shishir Bajaj’s department took management of companies like Bajaj Hindusthan and Bajaj Shopper Care, whereas different household branches saved the group’s core auto, finance, and industrial corporations.


Why the Lopez cousins are breaking up — and what other feuding dynasties teach us

Splitting up let every department observe its personal recreation plan. Their paths shortly diverged: the core Bajaj companies boomed, whereas Bajaj Hindusthan struggled with heavy debt and a troublesome sugar market. Dividing the empire ended the combat over who was in cost, however it didn’t assure that either side would win.

In Hong Kong, Walter Kwok was pushed out as chief of Solar Hung Kai Properties—the true property titan behind town’s tallest skyscrapers, luxurious malls, and housing estates—in 2008 after clashing along with his brothers Thomas and Raymond over easy methods to run the empire. The battle pulled of their mom, Kwong Siu-hing, and twisted up the household trusts. Walter misplaced his government job, although he didn’t lose his monetary slice of the household fortune. He went on to begin his personal property firm, Empire Group Holdings, whereas new belief guidelines spelled out every brother’s share of the household wealth.

Taking a unique path is the Murdoch household—the real-life inspiration behind HBO’s hit drama Succession, and the media dynasty behind Fox News, The Wall Avenue Journal, and main shops throughout the US, UK, and Australia which have formed elections and public debate for many years. After a courtroom battle over the household belief controlling voting energy in Fox Company and Information Corp, a September 2025 settlement locked in Lachlan Murdoch’s future management. His three older siblings from 95-year-old Rupert Murdoch‘s first two marriages—Prudence MacLeod, Elisabeth Murdoch, and James Murdoch—walked away with big payouts and exited the belief. Grace and Chloe, Murdoch’s two youngest daughters from his third spouse, Wendi Deng, stayed on as monetary beneficiaries below the brand new setup, however with out the voting energy given to Lachlan.

Every of those households dealt with their cut up in a different way. The Ambanis and Bajajs divided up working corporations. Walter Kwok stepped out of administration whereas holding a monetary stake. The Murdochs rewrote who holds voting management over their media empire. None of them presents a one-size-fits-all recipe for fixing household feuds.

Enrique Soriano
ADVICE. Enrique Soriano, household enterprise marketing consultant of the Wong & Bernstein  Group, speaks throughout a discussion board. Courtesy of the Wong & Bernstein Group 

Enrique Soriano, who has suggested enterprise households throughout the Philippines and Asia, doesn’t view such separations as failures, noting throughout our June webinar that kinfolk who can not work collectively are sometimes higher served by an orderly division of enterprise pursuits to allow them to cease being enterprise companions with out stopping being household.

After all, that’s a lot simpler mentioned than completed. A household deciding to separate nonetheless has to agree on who will get what, how a lot every firm is price, who takes on the money owed, and what occurs to shared properties. One relative would possibly need out, solely to seek out the others can’t afford to purchase their shares. One other would possibly wish to hold management, however has to herald an outdoor investor to assist pay for the buyout.

And a peace deal that satisfies the kinfolk doesn’t routinely work out for the on a regular basis public traders who even have cash using on these corporations.

Is divorce the higher reply?

The Lopez cousins seem like heading towards a extra everlasting cut up of their enterprise pursuits, although whether or not that seems effectively for his or her corporations, outdoors stockholders, and the household itself will take years to see.

Half 1 | The Lopez heirs who ran Rockwell but never controlled it
Half 2 | Why Gabby Lopez wants Rockwell as ABS-CBN struggles
Half 3 | Why Piki Lopez is letting Rockwell go

Different enterprise dynasties provide no straightforward solutions: The Kweks and Ortigases discovered methods to maintain their shared companies intact after fierce battles, although each needed to make main compromises. The Ambanis and Bajajs carved up their empires. The Kwoks and Murdochs separated day-to-day management from monetary possession. The Shin brothers’ succession battle left one brother working Lotte, whereas the Aguirres, Ilusorios, Jacintos, and Yansons confirmed how household fights can spiral into years of lawsuits and lasting damaged relationships and private wounds.

There’s a world of distinction between holding an organization collectively as a result of the homeowners truly agree on its future, and holding it collectively simply because no person needs to be blamed for breaking apart the household empire. There’s additionally a distinction between splitting as much as chase new ambitions and splitting it up simply to cease a combat.

For the Lopezes, going their separate methods might give every department the liberty to give attention to what it values most. Piki can focus on long-term power bets, whereas Gabby and his allies can give attention to lifestyle-related shopper and media companies. But, that freedom brings new pressures, and success will depend upon the alternatives all sides makes subsequent.

A household can survive a company divorce. Its corporations would possibly even develop stronger due to it. Or the cut up might go away either side worse off than earlier than. However the true query isn’t simply whether or not kinfolk ought to keep collectively or go their separate methods. It’s whether or not the companies, and all of the individuals who depend upon them, will truly be higher off afterward. – Rappler.com

Half 2 on Thursday, November 19 | Dividing the Lopez empire: Who decides what a household enterprise is price?
Half 3 on Friday, November 20 | Two cousins, two large bets: Will the Lopez cut up truly work?

Lala Rimando wrote about Philippine enterprise, and managed newsrooms, together with Newsbreak, ABS-CBN, Rappler, and Forbes, for over 25 years. She’s now primarily based in La Union, taking good care of her mother with dementia, and dealing on the multimedia biography of the late John Gokongwei.


(Rappler’s Best) The day Gabby Lopez said, ‘We’re done’

https://weblog.passive-income4u.com/create-your-very-own-auto-publish-news-blog-site-and-earn-passive-income-in-just-4-easy-steps/

https://www.rappler.com/enterprise/why-lopez-cousins-breaking-up-what-lessons-family-feud-dynasties/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here